3 ms·
We're not all that confident about where there's water in our own solar system. We seem to discover 'possible' water on the moon or Mars every week. And yet we
by mattmanser 15y ago
We're not all that confident about where there's water in our own solar system. We seem to discover 'possible' water on the moon or Mars every week. And yet we know this planet is warm and watery? Oh, did you not notice the constant use of the word 'may'.
So I call Utter Bollocks.
This is the worst type of science. It's like the old archaeologists, 'China had Bronze making, therefore everyone got it from them'. They were wrong and we had to wait till science developed carbon dating to prove them wrong.
It's pure speculation dressed up as science. A wild guess based on our own solar system. A population of 1 does not a survey make.
And the artist's impression at the top really makes me cringe. Who is giving these plonkers money to spend on artist impressions?
Unfortunately this is all a direct consequence of the way scientific funding works. But as someone who has a scientific mind it makes me die a little inside when I see this kind of thing.
- hugh3 15y agoI haven't been able to find any original sources yet (and I'm not about to watch that podcast) but I'm fairly sure that what they have found is a planet in the habitable zone. And that's pretty darn neat in itself. (What was really missing was information about its size and density.) As for the bits about it being "muggy", I can only assume that this is something the journalists, looking for an angle, tricked the scientists into saying. We can't say anything definitive about chemical composition of these planets at this stage, we can only infer things from their temperature and density.