6 ms·
This is “uncensorable” in the same way that “sovereign citizens” are immune from prosecution. Once someone uses it for something which is actually illegal, they
by acdha 5y ago
This is “uncensorable” in the same way that “sovereign citizens” are immune from prosecution. Once someone uses it for something which is actually illegal, they’ll learn how useful blockchains are for prosecutors.
The underlying mistake is thinking about this like a game where you can make up rules for the government to follow. What actually happens is one of two paths:
1. You’re outside their jurisdiction, so anything will work because your local police don’t care. Maybe you have to avoid traveling to certain places or doing business with certain companies but you can almost certainly live a full life with minimal impact unless you’re doing something like leaking the secrets of a drug cartel or Russian oligarch.
2. You’re subject to their authority, which gives them a rich suite of tools ranging from arresting you, having ISPs filter DNS or network connections, launching denial of service attacks on your infrastructure, etc. How much effort they’ll expend depends on exactly what you’re doing and how authoritarian the government is, not the technology.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe readme does explain that you could censor it by blocking access the chain entirely, it's not pretending otherwise. But by embedding the information into the chain, if you are just reading posts I don't know how snoops could notice. You just need to run a node that keeps up with the state of the chain; there's no obvious way for network snoops to know whether you're doing that because you are using Handshake to resolve domain names or to read messages embedded in it, since you can do all that offline.
- phoe-krk 5y agoAs long as there is illegal content on the blockchain, they can simply state that you are hosting a node connected to a network that downloads and shares illegal content, which will be true, and therefore that you possess it, which will also be true. And that can be enough to get you prosecuted regardless of how many crypto bros are going to try to convince you, or them, otherwise.
- roywiggins 5y agoWell, sure. They could make owning a computer illegal, or whatever. Anything outside your skull is censorable. The readme doesn't pretend that this works if you can't access the Handshake chain.
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y ago> Anything outside your skull is censorable Given a bullet and a gun, anything inside your skull is also censorable.
- dannyw 5y agoThey being who, under what law? It's widely known there's child porn on the bitcoin blockchain, not familiar with any prosecutions that have happened. Pretending that the law trumps all technology is as naive as pretending technology trumps all law. No extreme is true: you can build technological problems to solve many social or political problems (example: VeraCrypt with plausible denialability)
- jasode 5y ago>It's widely known there's child porn on the bitcoin blockchain, Are there actual bytes of child porn embedded in Bitcoin blockchain or only encrypted-or-obfuscated urls of possible websites that lead to child porn? Example story from 2018 saying child porn bytes are not in the blockchain and non-tech journalists are misreporting it: https://news.bitcoin.com/no-isnt-child-porn-bitcoin-blockchain/ https://news.bitcoin.com/no-isnt-child-porn-bitcoin-blockcha... Any credible embedding of child porn bytes in the blockchain since that story?
- acdha 5y agoOkay, so now you’ve downloaded the entire chain. Does that seem safe to have in your possession in this scenario? Even if I have the storage, I would not want to find out that someone else had uploaded something illegal when the police search my computer/phone and I have to prove to their satisfaction that I didn’t know. If you don’t download the entire chain, your traffic connecting to certain nodes and downloading certain sizes can be enough to track you - there are academic papers about using this to figure out what movies you’re watching over HTTPS – and that’s assuming that you don’t learn the hard way that the fast server with all of the underground content is the secret police’s honeypot. This is all probably moot in any case because it’s tricky to build something like this which never does DNS resolution, connects to a suspicious server, etc. The average user is going to have a very hard time avoiding mistakes like that, and that’s assuming you don’t have police informants encouraging unsafe opsec or use of treacherous apps — real things which happen to dissidents and activists all over the world. Remember Citizen Lab’s report on the use of NSO’s malware to go after supporters of a soda tax? What bothers me most about cryptocurrency proponents are that most of the claims are being made by people who will not personally suffer the consequences of being wrong if someone follows their advice. If you care about people in dangerous legal environments, that really needs to focus on changing the system rather than advocating use of electronic systems which even experts cannot use safely in those environments.
- friendlydog 5y agoLet's say you use something like a striped raid on different nodes. Node A contains the odd bytes for something copyrighted like "the love guru" those bytes by themselves aren't the copyrighted content and no one claims rights to them. Node B has has the even ones. Downloading either doesn't yield the copyrighted file, but on a person's own machine if they combine them it does. Still illegal?
- mmastrac 5y agoYes. The law isn't naive and seeing content A appear when using innocent content B as a key is beyond a reasonable doubt.
- edoceo 5y agoHaving copyrighted works isn't the inherently illegal part. It's the act of obtaining them outside the licensed methods and then holding them. At that point, according to some, is when it becomes theft. Hosts with unknown blobs of bytes can, and have, been taken to task by various authorities. Maybe it's grey-area but looks more towards the illegal side to me. Not a lawyer.
- hash872 5y agoLet's say instead of 'copyrighted file' it's CSAM material instead. Is it 'illegal'? Maybe you can convince a judge otherwise.... after your home has been raided, you've already done at least some time in jail where all the inmates know you've been arrested for CSAM, your friends & family know you've been arrested for that, that's what comes up under a Google search for your name for all time, thus making you unemployable..... Yes, after spending $500k-1 million on a defense attorney, it's possible that you could convince a judge that that content isn't 'illegal', sure. (How many judges- average age over 60- can learn what a 'striped raid' is?) But none of those other consequences can be reversed, even if you 'win' at trial
- kragen 5y agoThe system you're describing is a system in which random policemen can arbitrarily destroy the life and legacy of whoever they want. Such a system does already exist in many countries. It doesn't depend on people actually hosting decentralized communications facilities at all; police officers can do the same to anyone who refused them free accommodations at their hotel, or declined their offer of partnership in their nightclub venture. It's irrelevant whether there's any forbidden information actually being communicated, striped or otherwise. In other places, there does exist a "rule of law" that limits such abuses to a significant degree.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The underlying mistake is thinking about this like a game where you can make up rules for the government to follow. Thanks for describing that error so clearly and succinctly. It's one of those fundamental misconceptions that's depressingly common. Don't assume you've defeated the them because they haven't cared enough to come after you.
- dd444fgdfg 5y agois that true though? CP on Etherium blockchain is a well known problem, and no prosecution jurisdiction is doing anything about it. Who would even have jurisdiction on something so decentralised? Sure you could shut down some nodes, but not all of them. And even then new nodes would pop up vastly more quickly than you can kill them. So prosecutors really are powerless. I think. Am I wrong?
- alkonaut 5y agoCould the reasoning behind that not simply be that there is only finite resources to use so you want to target where you get the most effect for the least resource and “CP on blockchains” ends up way down in that priority list?
- tablespoon 5y ago> So prosecutors really are powerless. I think. Am I wrong? Yes, you're wrong. > Sure you could shut down some nodes, but not all of them. And even then new nodes would pop up vastly more quickly than you can kill them. Your error is here. If prosecutors actually decide to start shutting down nodes because of CP and make successful prosecutions, it will deter people from running new nodes in that jurisdiction. If hosting a copy of the Etherium blockchain had a high chance of landing you in jail for CP possession, would you start up a new node to replace one that was shut down? Instead of "new nodes ... pop[ping] up vastly more quickly than you can kill them," most operators would get scared and quickly shut down their nodes and wipe their HDs, and the rest would get prosecuted. Maybe you'd have a few stragglers hiding out on Tor, but at that point the network is unusable for any legitimate use. Don't believe me? There's even been a recent example of something like that. China banned Bitcoin mining, and the miners there shut down or GTFO of China: https://fortune.com/2021/11/17/china-bitcoin-mining-ban-crypto-holdouts-ether-solana-price/ https://fortune.com/2021/11/17/china-bitcoin-mining-ban-cryp... > Available data shows that crypto mining no longer exists in China and that China's crypto mining ban completely upended the global Bitcoin mining industry. China went from controlling up to two-thirds of all Bitcoin mining in the world in April to not contributing to the industry at all as of July 2021, according to data compiled by the University of Cambridge’s Centre for Alternative Finance. And anecdotal evidence suggests that the vast majority of Chinese Bitcoin miners relocated their operations to places like Kazakhstan, the U.S., and Canada or simply sold off their equipment at discounted prices and left the industry.
- alangibson 5y ago> where you can make up rules for the government to follow Exactly. It always reminds me of that scene in the Simpsons where Burns goes through tons of security in the nuclear plant, then a dog walks in through a screen door.