14 ms·
Dark Web – Justice League
- UIUC_06 5y agoThe lengthy discussions about what qualifies as "anarchy" is a perfect illustration of why anarchists (and libertarians) never take power. The devotees are more interested in being correct and arguing with each other than in the messy business of making coalitions and keeping them together.
- Der_Einzige 5y agoGood. Everytime we get someone on the far left who trades ideological purity for pragmatism, millions seem to die. I look at leftist infighting with happiness because the kinda of people who infight like this are also unlikely to put me up against a wall.
- smm11 5y agoAnd nobody wants to make a comment.
- 3np 5y agoIf you don't have anything worthwhile to say, better say nothing at all
- JoelMcCracken 5y agoThese kinds of alternative justice systems always seem fascinating to me. I feel like a sociological study on "alternative forms of justice" could be very fruitful.
- tgb 5y agoYou might enjoy "Legal Systems Very Different From Ours" by David Friedman.
- WFHRenaissance 5y agoFun little rabbit-hole for you to dive into: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycentric_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycentric_law
- Fenrisulfr 5y agoThere's been some good research into the history of legal systems. See David Friedman's book Legal Systems Very Different From Ours [1]. There's a small section about prisoners. But a new chapter could definitely be written about cyber-criminals! [1] http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsContents.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsCo...
- BitwiseFool 5y ago+1 for this fascinating read. As soon as I read the GP's comment I wanted to link this.
- stef25 5y agoPersonal anecdote: quite a while ago I got thrown in jail in Thailand (80 people in a cell, a hole in the ground to shit in, one bowl of rice per day, sleep on the concrete floor kind of place). My embassy was quite helpful in negotiating with the guards to get me in a "VIP" cell, which was a room within the cell run by some Iranians. They said if I paid them a certain sum, I'd be under their wing and they'd protect me. Couple days later one of them woke me up and asked me to check if I had any cigarettes missing, which I did (not that I cared much). Someone had seen a Russian guy take some of my smokes while I was asleep and told the "boss". They went and beat the crap out of him. The Iranians also had a line to the cleaning crew who would pass in front of the cell once a day. Every morning you could place an order for (almost) anything you wanted from the outside world. They'd take the payments, write it all down and pass it to the cleaning crew through the bars of the cell who would deliver it all the next day. So while most of our cell mates fought over bowls of rice, in the VIP room we had feasts of curries, fruit, soft drinks. It was like a banquet every day. The main Iranian guy even had Russian girls come over but they couldn't enter the cells. The day I got out one of them approached me and ever so gently and politely asked me "You are going home yes? Could I please have your towel?". He could have just taken it along with anything else I had but he stuck to the rules. So yeah, these guys definitely had a legal system!
- jeffrwells 5y agoThere’s a book I really enjoyed called Narconomics. It helps explain all aspects of the drug trade through the lens of business. One of the most fascinating takeaways was how they handle “contract enforcement” in the absence of a legal system or courts (hint: Violence) I recall an anecdote that Mexican cartels would hire Mexicans —- and not Dutch —- in order to serve as drug mules smuggling product into Amsterdam. Dutch mules would get caught less often, but Mexicans were much less likely to steal the drugs entirely. Because when you sign up to be a mule they take down the names and addresses of your entire family (nearby), and will kill them if you steal the product. Contract enforcement.
- acomar 5y agojudgements from the usual court system are enforced by the police, who are authorized to use force - i.e. violence - in the event of non-compliance. this is not a unique feature of the drug trade.
- drdeca 5y agoWhile this is true, the quantity of the violence needed, and like, the legibility of the conditions under which violence is to be meted out, can be much better in the case of, like, laws and state, than, well, perhaps if there was no state, there could be another mechanism which is comparable or better, but when contract enforcement in a particular area is excluded from state enforcement, while normal areas aren’t, I expect the violence used in that area to be worse.
- abyssin 5y agoI’d say the amount of violence is related to the amount of resources available in the economy where trust needs to be established. If you have a lot of resources, you can spend more on monitoring and surveillance, and afford more losses. When resources become scarce, you climb the control ladder faster and resort to physical violence because you can’t afford not to.
- 5y ago
- joshmarlow 5y agoInterestingly, Medieval Iceland had a polycentric legal system where you could sell the wrong done to you to someone who had more money to prosecute. There's an interesting discussion/description in "The Machinery of Freedom", a book about anarchocapitalism. It's freely available online - http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf
- joshuaissac 5y agoThat sounds similar to creditors selling the right to collect debt repayments to a debt collector, or patent holders selling their patents to a patent enforcement company or patent troll (usually the same).
- stef25 5y agoHere in Belgium there's a platform on which you can sell invoices that have say a 90 day payment term to someone who'll give you say 95% of it, if you need that money immediately. They then get the full invoice after 90 days.
- seanhunter 5y agoThat's a very common form of trade finance worldwide, and is usually called "invoice discounting" or "receivables factoring" https://tradefinanceanalytics.com/what-is-factoring https://tradefinanceanalytics.com/what-is-factoring
- denton-scratch 5y agoFor an overdue bill, the factor is called a debt collector. But it's roughly the same business.
- Fnoord 5y agoThere's collection agencies with no cure no pay (who add up their own fee upon the debt), and there's debt traders who buy a debt for a lower price and who then harass the person who (allegedly!) owes the money. Its a scoundrel market, IMO. Heartless, Ellisonish. County court bailiff (gerechtsdeurwaarder) is a government variant which has legal merit (unlike the other 2). Still, doesn't mean they are morally right (and those in debt have a harder time to defend themselves, legally), but at least it does have that legal merit. The problem is that, yes, often people who are in debt are in the wrong and should pay it, but there's all these corner cases and cases where the debt is incorrect, its an underlying dispute, it was started because of bad communication, etc (been there, done it).
- _0ffh 5y agoThe (consequentialist-)anarchist economist David Friedman (son of Milton) wrote a book about this very topic! I hope you'll find it as interesting as I did! Book: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsContents.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsCo... Talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOB2qxRO5vQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOB2qxRO5vQ [Ed. Seems I'm late, but I'll leave the comment up for the video link.]
- guerrilla 5y ago> I feel like a sociological study on "alternative forms of justice" could be very fruitful. Not sure why you assumed they don't exist already. There are apparently many. Google Scholar that shit.
- JoelMcCracken 5y agoYeah, I should have phrased it differently. I'm sure these exist, but maybe sociology isn't the right discipline, and/or I assume I really don't have enough familiarity to find what I'm looking for. I'll go try that tho!
- guerrilla 5y agoSociology, anthropology and economics are what you want I'm pretty sure.
- motohagiography 5y agoOne wonders if being a judge on one of these cases would be illegal as well.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI could see the logic for a judge being considered an accessory.
- Cupertino95014 5y agoSome enterprising prosecutor is probably, even now, getting ready to bring those judges in and depose them. They don't have any attorney-client privilege, and they certainly know all about some illegal activity.
- empressplay 5y agoAnd the movie / TV series based on it is already in development, I imagine
- dS0rrow 5y agoclearnet link to the complaint section of said forum: https://xss.is/threads/34768/ https://xss.is/threads/34768/
- csdvrx 5y agoIRL this is called binding arbitration, and it's often opt-out for your ISP and cellphone provider. Most companies prefer this, as it's faster and more efficient than the judicial system.
- ThrustVectoring 5y agoIt's a bit more specific than just being "faster" and "more efficient". There's two main advantages: First, waiver of class-action rights. This is a big deal because there's a cottage industry of enterprising lawyers who do find a couple main plaintiffs, generate a suit on behalf of a large class against a deep-pocketed defendant, and settle for something around a dollar per class member plus millions in legal fees. Second is a limitation on discovery and subpoena rights for plaintiffs. In a traditional court setting, you may be allowed to force a company to turn over extensive communication records and other documents, corporate executives to testify or be deposed, and even burden non-party witnesses (eg, part suppliers). In many jurisdictions, companies that wish to use binding arbitration have to pay the entirety of the significant fees to fund the arbitration system (and in a timely manner). It's still worthwhile for them to do so, even if they aren't tipping the scales of justice one micrometer. With the exact same outcome as a court case, the arbitration fees are fully worth it to avoid discovery, better protect executives from being forced to testify, dodge class-action fishing expeditions, etc.
- matsemann 5y agoTrue reason is of course that the arbitration courts side with those paying the bills. Otherwise they would have few repeat customers.
- null0pointer 5y agoIs this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.
- _0ffh 5y agoYes, it's the free market taking over and providing a service that is in demand, in this case arbitration.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoNo. There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power.
- __blockcipher__ 5y ago> There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power. That's a description of our statist status quo :)
- catillac 5y agoI think that’s the joke
- notdemo88 5y ago
- goodluckchuck 5y agoYeah, one might say the anarchists are forming a government.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI wouldn't say so. This is all opt-in, they're not forcing anyone. This is just a private dispute resolution system, not too dissimilar from what can be offered by private companies on clearnet (think eBay).
- smokey_circles 5y ago> Over the past few weeks the FBI, Department of Justice (DOJ), Interpol, and other international law enforcement agencies have worked together to incarcerate and indict ransomware threat actors. Through this effort, millions of dollars in ransom payments have been recovered. yet still, cryptocurrency gets blamed for all the ransomware. nevermind that clearly the law is able to find some course to take, or the unsolved cases unrelated unrelated crypto or any of the myriad of studies about why crime exists. no, the mere existence of monero is why we have international criminal syndicates. never happened with drug cartels or insider trading rings. heck even warlords are bitcoins fault. odd rant, I know, but the argument that "all that crypto does is encourage criminals" is willfully ignorant. tale as old as time. "what did they do before crypto then smartie pants" cash. and before that: gold. probably shiny rocks before that. we could try defeat these actors but honestly I am unable to believe it's just human nature. we suck sometimes
- strombofulous 5y agoAre there any examples of widespread ransomware that demanded payment in cash, gold, or shiny rocks?
- gigaflop 5y agoI think it was the norm for ransoms to be paid in gold or some kind of physical wealth back in the Y1K era.
- strombofulous 5y agoThat's true but the article is specifically talking about ransomware
- Kneecaps07 5y ago> Through this effort, millions of dollars in ransom payments have been recovered I'm curious about who gets this money? I certainly have never heard of a company getting their money back from the feds.
- 5y ago
- nashashmi 5y agoThis makes a whole lot of sense. How can a transaction happen if reputation is not vouched for or established? It is why crooks start building networks and start asking lots of questions about groups. Wherever there is a case of money , there is an angle for reputation building. For the more mature, they categorize this as acceptable losses.
- chris_wot 5y agoYeah, this will eventually go wrong. It's inevitable that someone will work out how to socially game this system.
- papito 5y agoThis just shows that people naturally gravitate toward a system of social harmony and the rule of law, as it lets you reasonably adjust your behavior, as the expectations are formalized, and everyone else is assumed to be abiding by them. The irony is that real world is increasingly moving away from that, toward the "everyone for themselves, nothing matters" chaos.
- justicezyx 5y agoWords are thoughts. Thoughts are mental processes. Be careful with treating similarity in appearance with equivalence in substance. > social harmony and the rule of law The association between the story and social harmony seems plausible, but actually superficial. Social harmony would be that people involuntarily work together without an authority, and reached mutual agreement on their dispute. To me, it is a sign of social conflicts that dark web actors need arbitration. Although that by itself matches our impression that dark web actors are lawless individuals should be punished. More ironically, the story actually shows that they are not lawless in the absolute sense. They just breakd the laws majority of the society abides by (or the majority actually do not even realize exits). > rule of law You know, rule of law is more of a political term nowadays. It refers to a western style of political organization framework centered on written laws and a voting process to revising them, and many other subtle details. Is arbitration on darkweb an example of rule by law? I tend to say no. Arbiter is necessary in all steps, and they seem are not codifying their "laws" for dealing with the future occrance of similar litigation at all.
- papito 5y agoWell, obviously, this is almost a metaphor, as it's a stretch to literally apply the term Rule of Law to something as sketchy as the dark web. Also, note that I did not use something like "Law and Order", as that can have a pretty unpleasant meaning.
- lallysingh 5y ago> The irony is that real world is increasingly moving away from that, toward the "everyone for themselves, nothing matters" chaos. People have been saying that for hundreds of years. We tend to romanticize the past.
- devwastaken 5y agoNo ability to enforce makes it moot. At most you get banned from the forum.
- bowmessage 5y agoMute? Or moot?
- devwastaken 5y agoAutocorrect.
- flubert 5y ago"When the parties agreed, they could lay their dispute before the moot, whose members, much like present-day mediators, attempted to facilitate an accommodation that the disputing parties found acceptable. When reached, such accommodations resolved the dispute in a way that preserved the peace of the community." https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=586941 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=586941 This is like a buy-one-get-one-free comment, not only is the above about evolved dispute resolution systems, it mention the moot.
- quickthrower2 5y agoYes a blockchain escrow with this judge as the decider of how the funds are apportioned would be better.
- edwnj 5y agoYou're doing shady stuff with some fucked up people and it could be anybody incl the feds so reputation is invaluable. I imagine its like ratings on ebay but much much higher stakes.
- ehsankia 5y agoHow well this system works depends directly on the delta between how influential the platform is vs how influential the accused is. As you mention, eBay for the longest time was one of the only/biggest way to sell things online, and reputation on there could make or break how successful your business would be. Similarly, if this forum is used by the majority of people doing business on the dark web, then obviously it isn't "moot" as not following the decision is equal to heavily handicapping your business.. On the other hand, if the group accused is large enough, like some of the $20M ones mentioned in the thread, I assume said groups could easily spin off their own community or still have business even if they were banned from this forum.
- dmitriid 5y agoEvery system ends up needing: - trust - rules - enforcement I'm not even surprised such a system exists, because full anarchy where no one trusts anyone is not good even in theory.
- Miner49er 5y ago> full anarchy I know what you mean, but it's unfortunate that anarchism is sometimes a synonym for "no rules" when it doesn't mean that at all. I think this system is actually very anarchist.
- dimitrios1 5y agoRight. I used to think this as well. In its most basic form, it means no ruler. I view anarchism as the ultimate counter to authoritarianism. The older I get, the more it becomes apparent to me that all of our world governments are authoritarian to a degree, including supposed democratic ones, and there seems to be this arbitrary threshold of "ok now we call this regime authoritarian". But every government rules through multiple forms of coercion. Some are more authoritarian than others, but nonetheless, authoritarian.
- int_19h 5y agoMy personal theory is that it's straight up impossible to have a non-authoritarian government involving more than Dunbar's number of people (counting both the governors and the governed). For larger numbers, the best you can do is a multi-level federated approach where the governing assemblies on each level have no more than that number of delegates from the level below.
- dmitriid 5y agoThen you're likely run into a problem with communication. You can see in basically any large company: communication gets lost, misinterpreted, you end up depending on many other entities to do anything etc.
- 5y ago
- unixhero 5y agoKind of like the Vikings.
- vmception 5y agoDo yourself a favor and demystify the dark web for yourself. Some of the best information is exclusively nestled in forums and marketplaces over there. If you rely on an incentive model of being caught in order to behave, something darknet doesnt offer, that says more about you than anyone else.
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoI’m interested - how do I find it? Is there a guide? List of places to visit?
- vmception 5y agoTypically over a Tor circuit I visit dark.fail and then switch to the onion url so that exit nodes arent being used Onion addresses frequently change so no use bookmarking them Dark.fail lists a variety of forums, marketplaces, marketplaces with forums, and their current addresses and whether those sites are up or down It also has links to a variety of mainstream media news sources and various government resources that you can browse on native onion routes Dread is the biggest forum, reddit clone. A variety of subreddits to hang out in and chat. It is often down though, at least compared to modern clearnet services.
- dewey 5y agoYou said that "Some of the best information" is on there. What would be an example of that? Every time when I was checking it out it was just marketplaces and otherwise just things I could find in the clearnet.
- vmception 5y agoA lot of times its in the marketplaces or their forums. I mentioned an example good for me in another comment
- ggerganov 5y agoCan you give a few examples of what sorts of information is best found in the dark web?
- flatiron 5y agoI live in NJ where weed is legal but you can't buy it (legally) so we are sort of in a weird spot. anyway, it makes me really not care about ordering weed on the dark web from CA. if the feds catch it, its an ounce of weed to a residence, they don't care and im not gonna go in front of some federal judge on federal drug crimes. if CA or NJ catch it, its legal there, who cares. but the site I use uses an escrow system where if you don't get the product or if you aren't satisfied you can file a complaint. i've never used it as i always have gotten what i've ordered but it is pretty odd.
- angryGhost 5y agoif they seize any powder, they might come a knockin'!
- flatiron 5y agoi only do weed and just gummies for my anxiety and only buy enough that its obviously personal use and not some weed gummy empire i'm starting.
- dillondoyle 5y agoIt would be pretty amazing for within the US USPS to not only search but find powdered drugs or pills. It's protected and they need a search warrant. Reasonable cause etc. Maybe if they already had an investigation on you and you were distributing. Customs on the other hand... Though if it's small volume they will often just send you a scary letter in the mail, especially if it's just sketchy looking pills. Or if the scammer is smart they'll just send you the letter and take your money ! Or at least that's what SWIM said from my wasted 20s. LMFAO I miss earlier internet sometimes
- Acutulus 5y agoThat's how it generally happens from what I understand. A local or isolated investigation is started and during the process they may uncover a reasonably high-level source of the product. Should they be lucky enough to get a warrant to scan an email server that has plaintext business contents, they might come across a trove of tracking numbers. From there the three letter agency will disseminate tips and intel to more local police forces and field offices and innumerable people start getting love letters, visits, surveillance. I also recall hearing that the USPS tracking info page is quite complex under the hood and logs a lot of your device/connection information when you enter a tracking number. No idea how true this is, but it wouldn't surprise me at all and I hope people behave as if it is. Agreed about the wasted 20's on the internet. No doubt I could have better spent my time. But there was some incredible and wild stuff going on out in the wires.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Cheetos10 5y ago
- reggieband 5y agoThere is a comic I remember from my childhood, "Tom the Dancing Bug" written by Ruben Bolling. He had a character called "Harvey Richard, Lawyer for Children". I linked a couple of examples [1], [2], [3], [4] but the satire, IMO, is incredible. It lampoons humanities proclivity to layer pseudo-rationality onto the irrational things that we do. It also reminds me of the TV show "The Wire" when Stringer Bell, a senior member of a street drug distribution ring of urban thugs, forces them to conduct their meetings using Rules of Order. [5] If you watch to the end, you see that in those circumstances order means nothing, it is just a facade. I guess you could say that I'm cynical about the prospects of such a court and I tend to see the underlying truth in the satires that point it out. 1. https://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2015/02/26 https://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2015/02/26 2. https://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2014/12/25 https://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2014/12/25 3. https://www.pinterest.ca/pin/545850417313484171/ https://www.pinterest.ca/pin/545850417313484171/ 4. https://www.pinterest.ca/pin/178807047675716661/ https://www.pinterest.ca/pin/178807047675716661/ 5. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xO1zxPRRf4g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xO1zxPRRf4g
- ghostbrainalpha 5y agoThose comics were genius. Thanks for putting them together for us.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- distrill 5y agoThe lengths that pintrest is going to prevent me from viewing the image full size is frustrating. But these comics are great.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoPlease understand, you might like it so much and download it, that would be like shoplifting, no no.
- robbintt 5y ago
- cs702 5y ago"Meet the new boss: same as the old boss." - The Who https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDfAdHBtK_Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDfAdHBtK_Q Actually, I suspect the new "bosses" of the dark web's newfangled justice system are in fact much worse than the old "bosses" of the traditional, old-fashioned, time-tested justice system -- i.e., judges and lawyers.
- burrows 5y agoWorse for who?
- heavyarms 5y agoThere's a good book by Kevin Poulsen called "The Kingpin: How one Hacker Took Over the Billion-Dollar Cybercrime Underground" that is a bit out of date at this point (2011), but it goes into great length on all of the dynamics of the early forums where all of carding/spam/botnet operators did business. In a forum/marketplace like this, your reputation is worth a lot of money. And if you scam someone and get banned, sure, you can just join again under a new identity, but building your reputation up again means you will lose out on a lot of potential sales.
- Fnoord 5y agoGreat book, indeed dated because its pre-dark web (think a place like Hackforums, before Tor was widespread used -- though it did exist, as did Freenet). The crown jewels in such a community is operator/admin access. For both police (basically, for infiltration), as well as for scammers (because they could create or kill credibility with sockpuppets, bans). Remember that's how Reddit was started (sockpuppets), and Assange did it as well.
- alcover 5y agoThat book is fascinating and markedly well written. The underground.. the schemes.. those characters ! It's killing me that Poulsen didn't release another such gem. There's plenty of material in this vein, beginning chiefly with the Gonzales saga - which dwarfs Iceman's story. Mr Poulsen if you happen in this thread, please ! Do it. I'd pay 100$ for a new story.
- cosmodisk 5y agoNot surprising at all. Most criminal organisations, especially larger ones have these mechanisms in place both for internal and external situations. For instance if there are two gangs with overlapping territories,disputes start and can get escalated very quickly into situations where each side is focusing on fighting instead of bringing on money. Sometimes the gang leaders would try to resolve it but often external help is required. Usually it's a well respected person by both sides who is impartial and has the necessary negotiation or political skills to make both sides happy. This is almost universal across the criminal world.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- galaxyLogic 5y agoThis can only point to one thing - Dark Web will have its own Darker Web which doesn't abide even by the rules of the Dark Web. It will however have its own rules, and justice. And so on, recursively.
- havocsupreme 5y agoWhy is the title justice league? I believe the previous title was more helpful
- serverlessmom 5y agoThis makes a lot of sense. In the case of the Dark Web I had always wondered how people felt secure in their purchases, especially considering the wide degree of fentanyl contamination in the recreational drug movement right now.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe drug markets have escrow systems and releasing the funds usually requires a review. This means that most sellers have tons of reviews. If a seller ever gets below 95% satisfaction they're basically done, which forces quite a bit of honesty. Since most purchases are $100+ astroturfing seems pretty uncommon. Many sits also have reviews per item, and if the price changes the reviews start from scratch, further disincentivizing astroturfing.
- b8 5y agoDoxing a scammer seems sorta fair.
- crtasm 5y agotheir relatives and possible girlfriend, not so much.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- maxwell_xander 5y agoHa, these articles always use xss.as instead of exploit.in, despite the latter being vastly more popular and appropriate, because exploit.in charges $100 for membership. I sympathize because, who wants to shell out $100. But even big name news outlets all use xss.in, you see it everywhere, precisely because it's free and anyone can join. Nothing wrong with using it really, just something amusing I've noticed
- 31414114 5y agoObviously I am posting this from a throw-away (also, hail qubes) and am obscuring a few facts. Over a decade ago I was part of a illicit forum where goods and services were sold, and both parties had mandatory escrow with optional arbitration. Over my runtime I have settled between 1 and 100.000 ( ;) ) arbitration cases, ranging from a few cents to well over $100k. For those who may think they know what operation this was ... you probably never heard about it. All I can say that it wasn't ransomware, and nothing porn or trafficking related. The entire topic interested me so much that I went our IRL to take courses in settling disputes and handling arbitration. Based on that I established rules to arbitrate and settle disputes by. Rules for both parties to interact, prior to sale of service/product and during arbitration. Some cases took minutes to hours to settle, others days or weeks, sometimes even months. Sometimes people get incredibly emotionally involved for a few dollars, sometimes disputes for well over what I earned in a year, where solved by both parties only giving (yes/no) answers to my questions and inquiries, for them to request deletion of their accounts after the dispute was settled. The contents being mostly obscured by encryption, but only my rules allowed their commerce to flow in the first place. I was tempted often to step in and steal money, but something told me that sitting out the experience would be so much more valuable for my moral compass and the understanding of people. I am happy it went that way, it did teach me so much about people, disputes, conflicts and problems. Now when I face problems and difficult characters in life, its like I have a cheat code of handling the situation. The other thing I did learn during my ... lets call it 'tenure' was that this type of trade and commerce brings out the darkest characters and the darkest in people. That's another topic on its own ... I am happy to see this get attention on HN. This sort of "justice" has been around since the early 00's, preceding most darknet markets. And somehow I keep being drawn to them ... well until I got scared of by the FEDS (who of course always were around, and sometimes did bust people during ongoing disputes) and then my tenure was over. Good luck to those still in the game.
- guerrilla 5y agoFunny, my friend and I were just talking about this kind of thing last night. I've been watching lots of Soft White Underbelly[1] interviews with gangsters, mafia , etc. and my friend's been reading about the transition from honor culture to state obedience in 1600's in Norway. The conclusion is that any time you create a black market by banning something in demand then a parallel state (competing with the "legitimate" state) will always pop up to protect property, trade and tax because not only is the "legitimate" state enforcing the ban, but they are simultaneously abstaining from their typical "duties" in that regard, leaving a gap to be filled. I find it interesting that the same thing can be achieved online but without the violence that is necessary in person. It's definitely a different space. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjwnDF2dRgI&list=PLBEIBBdgAOApEr8NRXE-oBUy8-9yqtHBK&index=2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjwnDF2dRgI&list=PLBEIBBdgAO...
- valyagolev 5y agoWe were doing this around simple small freelance jobs as well - there were, and still are, websites that will simply list fraudsters, people who wouldn’t pay, or take an advance payment and run away. This, and escrow, are quite typical para-legal means. In many cases you don’t want to go into real contractual stuff because the laws and forms seem to be too complicated, the sums too small, the taxes too annoying to pay, the government to cold and indifferent, and your age is too fourteen. To be honest, this article is excited about something quite mundane… Have you ever presented an argument against your brother’s actions before your mom? Happens anywhere, in any sizable group of people. Clicking on the link I kinda hoped it’d be a real shadow court: you send them an email describing how a corporation did you wrong, they ddos it into oblivion. I wish! World could really do with some decent, non-governmental legal systems to discuss things that are impossible to take to a real court. No matter even if obviously enforceable or not. Just to bring some order into what is done currently by a twitter mob