4 ms·
>Uh, I don't really buy it. Banks can not just fix arbitrary prices for food. They speculate on high food prices because they have reasons to believe that price
by crdoconnor 15y ago
>Uh, I don't really buy it. Banks can not just fix arbitrary prices for food. They speculate on high food prices because they have reasons to believe that prices will rise. Those reasons are the real culprits.
It's like any other bubble - it started basically because of a lack of anywhere else to invest, and at some point it just grew because it was growing. Remember 1999?
>And sorry, how bad is the infographic, if the chart just says "rising food prices driven by speculation" - that is not proof, that is just a claim.
I thought it was common knowledge. Certainly none of the fundamentals of the market for food have changed enough to warrant price rises to that extreme, and most of the demand is being driven by the futures market, not by, say, the entire world eating 70% more food.
- Tichy 15y agoIf it is common knowledge, then why make an infographic about it? I don't see that "certainly" you mention. Rather, there are lots of factors that seem to threaten food supply in the future (isn't the latest scare the depletion of phosphor?). Also other than a failed startup, a ton of wheat still sticks around if you buy it. You can either sell it off or let it deteriorate (for a 100% loss). Sure, you can try to artificially shorten supply and drive prices up that way. It is an age old economic strategy, but as far as I know it has never really worked before (from what I remember from economics textbooks). It would only work for a very short time. Say you hoard rice this year and sell only a little rice at exorbitant prices. Peasants the world over would increase their rice production, so next year there would be a lot more rice, plus your warehouses are already stocked to the ceiling with rice from last year. The prices will now be low - either you sell your rice for cheap, or you throw it into the river. In both cases, the attempt was not really worth it.
- crdoconnor 15y ago>If it is common knowledge, then why make an infographic about it? Because I can't be bothered? >Sure, you can try to artificially shorten supply and drive prices up that way. It is an age old economic strategy, but as far as I know it has never really worked before (from what I remember from economics textbooks). It would only work for a very short time. Say you hoard rice this year and sell only a little rice at exorbitant prices. Peasants the world over would increase their rice production, so next year there would be a lot more rice, plus your warehouses are already stocked to the ceiling with rice from last year. The prices will now be low - either you sell your rice for cheap, or you throw it into the river. In both cases, the attempt was not really worth it. If I'm understanding you correctly, a similar argument was made in 2007 - it's actually really expensive to hoard millions of barrels of oil (which is what was assumed if people were speculating), it wouldn't be easy to hide and nobody had really found any evidence of it. I think Paul Krugman made this argument. Then the bubble went POP pretty spectacularly. I think Krugman eventually admitted he was wrong there. Hoarding wasn't necessary as the price increases from the futures market were transmitted to the actual market for oil (since most oil is bought on futures anyway, very little is bought at spot price) and the speculators weren't actually taking delivery of the oil they were just rolling the contracts forward. I assume a similar dynamic is in play for wheat right now.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's like any other bubble - it started basically because of a lack of anywhere else to invest, and at some point it just grew because it was growing. Remember 1999? Unless you hold a short position in food futures, I don't think you are particularly confident in the correctness of this statement.
- crdoconnor 15y agoLet's suppose you took a 1 year short position in 1998 on Cisco because you were convinced the bubble was going to burst (and it WAS) - you would be well and truly fucked. This is partly why bubbles form. Easier to bet on prices going up (just buy a share, downside is limited) than prices going down (you need to predict when it will go down and your downside is unlimited). Markets can remain irrational for longer than you can remain solvent.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoOn the other hand, lets say you purchased a rolling series of put options (i.e., buy one in Jan 1997, Jun 1997, Jan 1998, June 1998) on a broad assortment of tech stocks. You'd have made a killing. This is the strategy that Burry and others took while shorting the housing bubble. The only way this strategy would fail is if the downturn is slow and gradual (which is not characteristic of a bubble).