7 ms·
This is a beautiful article, and it contain two beautiful quotes, one from David Graeber and the other from Eula Bliss. Alas, I find the contrarian in me rising
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
This is a beautiful article, and it contain two beautiful quotes, one from David Graeber and the other from Eula Bliss. Alas, I find the contrarian in me rising up against in particular the quote from Bliss:
> “The poets gave away their own books, handbound sometimes, and letterpress broadsides made on antiquated machinery, they gave their time to editing each other’s work in their bedroom offices … they performed their work for nothing but applause, and they gave each other places to stay, couches to sleep on.” She makes her point at the end of the paragraph: “I guess … it’s easy for me to believe there’s an alternative to capitalism because I feel like I’ve lived it.”
Yes, yes, you've lived it inside a house that was built with a system closer to capitalism than anything else, sharing couches made in a system closer to capitalism than anything else, printing books and poems on antiquated machinery made in a system closer to capitalism than anything else ...
I live my life in some ways on the periphery of capitalism, in some ways closer to Bliss and her fellow poets, as I somehow manage to convince people to pay me to keep working on software they could otherwise get without paying, software they can copy freely and use for any purpose they want.
But ... that existence is embedded within an utterly enormous capitalist system, and while my entirely optional-in-life DAW software (as with Bliss' poetry) might find a way to break the mold, to live outside of the assumptions of capitalism, I find it so hard to imagine how the food I eat, the bicycle tires I ride on, the solar panels that power my house, how any of the actual physical, tangible essentials and inessentials of life could do the same.
Graeber of course has always had much to say about our paralysis, our inability to imagine a future unlike our present, but as yet, even his writing has not given me a way to do that to the point where I could share Bliss' belief in an alternative.
- rektide 5y agoI feel like this is reductionism, failing to permit any duality. Perhaps some day non-capitalism means might eventually create entirely separate possibilities. But these here examples of non-capitalist ways of living are meaningful & significant to me, to these peoe, today, and i tend to accept their claims of legitemacy. To disregard some people's deliberate attempts at living otherwise for their lack of complete purity in doing so seems beyond the point. Maybe some day we can build alternate modes, where all ends are satisfied internally. But being able to host & share, to cooperate together in alternate modes with one another seems like the defining behavior & characteristic that is essential, to me, that is defining. It's enough. It's valid. Lets test the extremes. What about a hyperadvanced group of oligarchs, owned an advanced automated industrial world, & competed among themselves under capitalism. But provided food & shelter & surplus to the rest of humanity to live under? There's a vestigial capitalism working at some level, but the mass of humanity operates at some other level. To me it feels like the lived perceieved experience of an individual is what counts. We dont have to chase back the entire dependency tree; something new that happens will almost certainly be evolutionary, less revolutionary/apart. Im ok if we want to introduce the idea of a continuum, but i dont feel like some interaction with capitalist production negates the validity. (Also, thanks for the interesting, quote heavy comment!)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoNice reply, thank you. I agree with you when you say > To me it feels like the lived perceieved experience of an individual is what counts. but I think we differ on the impact, in your scenario, on perceived experience is of these "hyperadvanced group of oligarchs, owned an advanced automated industrial world, & competed among themselves under capitalism". While the scenario would certainly allow for a certain kind of freedom and choice, in the backdrop, a system that could allow only a range of choices would still be calling the shots. Perhaps that would still be sufficient for many people ... it might even be sufficient for me. It's certainly the sort of gamble that the Chinese system seems to be trying to take. But one of the inevitable consequences of capitalism is the unequal distribution of wealth, and the freedom to challenge that might be considered an important part of "the perceived experience" of people living in such a system.