3 ms·
That's because that's not a contract. Real contracts can only bind people who sign them, but in places that don't recognize right to work, you can be forced to
by josephcsible 5y ago
That's because that's not a contract. Real contracts can only bind people who sign them, but in places that don't recognize right to work, you can be forced to join a union just because 51% of your co-workers signed.
- cool_dude85 5y agoYou are making the same mistake as the post I replied to. You are "forced to join a union just because 51% of your co-workers signed" effectively everywhere in the US, not just in "right to work" states. If 51% of your co-workers agree, they will form a union, and that union will negotiate a contract on your behalf. You're in, baby. "Right to work" only covers whether you can be made to pay union dues as part of this arrangement.
- josephcsible 5y agoSure, I'll admit that right to work isn't perfect, but it's definitely a big step in the right direction.
- dls2016 5y agoPartnership contracts bind non-signers from receiving benefits of a partnership. And with good reason: you wouldn't want any ole schmoe laying claim to the fruits of your labor. Contracts deprive non-signers of things all the time. That's kind of the point. Do you have a problem with corporations signing "exclusive" deals with other corporations?
- erik_seaberg 5y agoYes, for party A to penalize party B for doing business with party C is an attack on free market competition which should be banned.
- dls2016 5y agoPenalize? So it’s ok for a group of people to enter a contract to form a corporation (“penalizing” non-signatories by preventing them from benefiting from the profits of the corporation)… but it’s not ok for a group of people to enter a contract to collectively bargain with a corporation (“penalizing” non-signatories by preventing them from benefiting from the contract). This is absurd. You’re saying a corporation cannot enter into a contract to be the exclusive supplier of a widget to another corporation?
- erik_seaberg 5y ago“I won’t work for less than $x” is fine. “You can’t hire anyone else willing to work for less than $x” is extortionate. Competition is necessary for a market.