5 ms·
I think you are missing the context. It's not that it proves or disproves the lab leak hypothesis. It's that it shows the scientific authorities were deliberate
by tim333 5y ago
I think you are missing the context. It's not that it proves or disproves the lab leak hypothesis. It's that it shows the scientific authorities were deliberately misleading the public by saying it's a crazy conspiracy theory while in private believing it quite likely.
And as to why that matters rather than "It shouldn't have been posted to HN" type suppression - we have millions dead in this outbreak and "At least 59 maximum biosafety level 4 labs (BSL-4) are planned, under construction or in operation across the world" https://www.ft.com/content/a0badd5d-4d88-4a3b-b019-61c6d8275caa https://www.ft.com/content/a0badd5d-4d88-4a3b-b019-61c6d8275... If labs are the cause we should take steps to try to avoid the next pandemic.
- jacquesm 5y ago> while in private believing it quite likely That's not what they said or believed. That's exactly why I have a problem with this whole exercise, it seems to me to be mostly a game of jump-to-conclusions.
- tim333 5y agoWell "accidental release or natural event? I am 70:30 or 60:40." sounds like Mike Farzan thought it quite likely. And >Before I left the office for the ball, I aligned nCoV with the 96% bat CoV sequenced at WIV. Except for the RBD the S proteins are essentially identical at the amino acid level – well all but the perfect insertion of 12 nucleotides that adds the furin site. S2 is over its whole length essentially identical. I really can’t think of a plausible natural scenario where you get from the bat virus or one very similar to it to nCoV where you insert exactly 4 amino acids 12 nucleotide that all have to be added at the exact same time to gain this function – that and you don’t change any other amino acid in S2? I just can’t figure out how this gets accomplished in nature. Do the alignment of the spikes at the amino acid level – its stunning. Of course, in the lab it would be easy to generate the perfect 12 base insert that you wanted. Another scenario is that the progenitor of nCoV was a bat virus with the perfect furin cleavage site generated over evolutionary times. In this scenario RaTG13 the WIV virus was generated by a perfect deletion of 12 nucleotides while essentially not changing any other S2 amino acid. Even more implausible IMO. from Bob Garry sounds like he also thought it quite likely. Source https://republicans-oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Letter-Re.-Feb-1-Emails-011122.pdf https://republicans-oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2...
- jacquesm 5y agoMeanwhile, we have hard proof that this does occur in nature. So this part of the discussion is no longer relevant from an evidence of view, the 'even more implausible' part turned out to be true. This - again - illustrates why I think this whole thread is a large pile of rubbish. If you are arguing with old information for an implausible viewpoint why are you arguing at all?
- tim333 5y agoI'm arguing mostly that scientists should be open with the relevant data. I don't see what should be controversial about that. It's like there's an air crash and the authorities say we must not investigate and keep all documents confidential in case it upsets the plane manufacturer. It's not a good idea to do that. Specifically EcoHealth Alliance who were the main US funders of WIV and main enthusiasts for gain of function research on bat viruses should publish their emails and data. They are a US government funded non profit and have no business obstructing all inquiries really. I mean even if you are convinced the origin is natural and not involving a lab then why not be enthusiastic for data about lab research to be open so you can rule that out?
- jacquesm 5y agoImagine for a moment that everything is reversed and read 'USA' for 'China' and 'China' for 'USA'. Now what do you think are the chances that an American research facility will open its books to the world after a political war of words all but blaming the USA for a pandemic? Because - in my opinion rightly - such a mission is bound to generate a lot of data that will then be mis-interpreted by people with an agenda seeing proof in everything that they were right all along, no matter what the scientists say.
- tim333 5y agoYeah which is why I think the US should start by going after the US institutions involved.