6 ms·
This is extremely impressive. It’s the first GAN I have seen which lets you tweak the result in a meaningful way rather than being just random. I think the spe
by Gigachad 5y ago
This is extremely impressive. It’s the first GAN I have seen which lets you tweak the result in a meaningful way rather than being just random.
I think the speed that GANs have come in to the world has really shaken people up and it’s hard to process what this all means and what it will result in. Especially the ones which generate based on real people.
But the feeling this gives me, is what happens for the future of art. Sure, this example is no where even close to replacing real artists, but it’s already generating images better than I can draw after a year of practice. It does give me a feeling of “what is the point”. Which might be an irrational feeling, but I’m sure others feel the same.
- zacmps 5y agoWe have been here before, and we certainly will again. It was not so long ago computers bet humans at chess, yet people still play.
- Gigachad 5y agoYeah I totally get this is the same thing that has happened so many times before. But at least for chess, it was never a practical thing and was a competition. Like how the existence of aimbots does not ruin a game as long as you are playing against other humans. For art it feels a bit different since it’s not competitive and more a practicality thing. Perhaps art will shift from placing individual strokes on an image and move to making creative directions for AI to resolve in to an image or enable more people to create labor intensive works like animation.
- _trampeltier 5y agoOr with the internet , Linux and open source. Suddenly you could downloads 1000s of apps, most much better, what I ever could do byself.
- DavidPiper 5y agoI've been thinking about this a bit lately, incomplete thoughts ahead... Yes, people still play, but they no longer create. With the exception of Adversarial attacks on particular algorithms, no human is creating new Chess theory, discovering new openings, for example. As a game, challenge, competition, social activity, chess is alive and well. As a creative endeavour, or vehicle for discovery, Chess is solved. It is no longer an art of its own. We're part way through this transition now with Go as well. New opening theory, new joseki, new strategies are being played by robots, and at the highest professional levels we are playing catch-up to understand.
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago> no human is creating new Chess theory, discovering new openings, for example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bongcloud_Attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bongcloud_Attack
- lmm 5y ago> With the exception of Adversarial attacks on particular algorithms, no human is creating new Chess theory, discovering new openings, for example. That's not true though? Human chessplayers are constantly exploring new lines, and engines are a useful tool but by no means the bottom line - indeed lines that were neglected because engines gave them low evaluations have been a fruitful source of ideas lately, because humans play differently from engines and may not be able to find the refutation.
- 9dev 5y agoBut isn’t that inevitably the final form of any highly complex tactics game (in lieu of a better word) humans create? I guess we reached the ceiling of what we can fathom on our own, so the logical next step is to hand over to robots that can grasp a wider range of possibilities, and learn from them. I once heard someone say people will never be able to understand God’s plan, just as a dog will never be able to really understand why their owners do things the way they do them. I feel like this is a similar threshold; a humans mind is incredible, but not perfectly suited for thinking in advance, or calculating probabilities. So I guess my point is, while this certainly feels a little scary, I think it’s just a consequence of the game, and probably okay.
- jychang 5y agoWell, digital art already allows you to copy/paste a layer and stuff that traditional art never allowed for. Imagine copy pasting a statue. This is sort of the same thing on steroids. You can copy/remix previous art by feeding them into a ML model in training mode, and it will be massively utilized the same way ctrl-c ctrl-v is used, but it's a part of the toolset of art creation, not replacing it.
- numpad0 5y ago> You can copy/remix previous art by feeding them into a ML model in training mode, and it will be massively utilized the same way ctrl-c ctrl-v is used, Then you need attributions for said previous arts, all of it, at least going by texts of laws.
- Gigachad 5y agoNo you don’t. Otherwise human artists would have to list out hundreds of attributions for every bit of art they saw that influenced their style.
- numpad0 5y agoCtrl-C Ctrl-V is a career killer for human artists. Why it's not for ML? e: the argument for human artists is human inspirations are generalized and artists’ own interpretations are always added to it, and for ML it’s that their network weights are highly generalized and likewise not a copy; but IMO a more solid line has to be drawn and distinction has to be made between C-c C-v and generalization at some point forward.
- nybble41 5y ago> Ctrl-C Ctrl-V is a career killer for human artists. Why it's not for ML? Human artists use copy/paste as a tool all the time, and it doesn't kill their careers. The element you're missing here is that jychang wasn't talking about copying pieces verbatim from others' work without permission & attribution, but rather using it as a tool to manipulate your own art ("to copy/paste a layer"). Imagine being able to do the same but with an AI model working behind the scenes to adjust the object to fit the scene it's being pasted into.
- liuru 5y agoHaha, this is something that constantly ponder, while I am developing this product. Though, the conclusion I've come to is that that hand-drawn art will always meaningful for humans, because it is born of the human experience. An interesting example is the invention of photography, which at its time, was very good at doing the thing artists were doing back then (capturing likenesses) But photography didn't replace art: instead, artists now use photographs to be more expressive, convincing, and make better art. In tandem, the widespread adoption of photography meant that more average folks could get their likenesses taken! Personally, my skills as an artist has improved by quite a bit, after launching this product, purely because observing it offers some fascinating insights into how anime is created! I hope that as an industry, we'll find better ways to create, and what we know to be the "best" art today will be even better in the future!
- eezurr 5y agoOne thing to consider is the number of artists employed by businesses. I dont have actual numbers but i know video game companies employs many. Businesses have different values than an individual human, and won't care if the art is made by a computer if its cheaper and passable. Theres also huge market for NSFW art. Whos going to know who or what made the image? Comparing photography to hand drawn art is silly. They are two different mediums. Your company could be the first to capture the market. I guess if you can sleep with the consequences of your work,who cares? Im not judging because if its not you, it will be someone else. Personally i think we as a society need to step back and press pause and really consider the consequences of this technology, and even existing technologies. If you become rich, could you set up a charity for all the future starving artists, if that future comes to pass? I dont want to live in a world where theres no room for human creativity. Not an artist, just a concerned human.
- throwaway2331 5y agoIt's no longer art if it's for commercial purposes. Those who have the courage necessary to become artists, and renounce the vulgarity of the world, will continue to do so. Those who delude themselves into thinking they're creating anything while being employed in commerce, will be managed out. The deep crevice where the two meet and manage to find compromise, will continue to be filled by wealthy, independent patrons. Asking others to think and do as we wish is silly. Ironically, if it's that important to you, why don't you start giving monetary support directly to artists? Changing one's own actions is more impactful than trying to change those of the many (and the prior is more likely to lead to the latter, than if one were to focus solely on the latter).
- bmitc 5y agoArt isn't about statical copying or drawing well. It's about human expression.
- Gigachad 5y agoThese generated pieces look extremely similar to real human art so they look very expressive to me. And you can even add your own input by hitting refresh until you get something similar to what you wanted.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> And you can even add your own input by hitting refresh until you get something similar to what you wanted. that is the exact opposite of creation. I'd put it this way: this is the IKEA of drawing.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI hear what you're saying, but at the same time, there's a ton of mass-produced, low-creativity art out there, where the objective is not to express oneself but to churn out products with the intent to make money. This is not just in artwork, but in other design based things like e.g. website designs as well.
- capableweb 5y agoThere is definitely a difference between art and mass-produced art. In the beginning, we only had art as an expression of human creativity, and it's not until later that we got mass-produced art, whose only goal is to provide profits for the author(s). It'd be useful to distinguish the two in conversations like this.
- adrianN 5y agoIt doesn't seem far fetched that in the near future an "artist" doesn't need to be able to draw at all. If GANs or the like become sufficiently tunable, I can express myself by telling the GAN what I would like to have drawn.
- plutonorm 5y agohahaha. Now everyone will get a piece of my existential ennui. Welcome to the club!
- Filligree 5y ago> But the feeling this gives me, is what happens for the future of art. Sure, this example is no where even close to replacing real artists, but it’s already generating images better than I can draw after a year of practice. It does give me a feeling of “what is the point”. Which might be an irrational feeling, but I’m sure others feel the same. There's a similar situation ongoing with fiction writing, by way of NovelAI. (And some competitors, but NovelAI is head and shoulders ahead of the pack. Thankfully; they seem to be the nicest of the lot.) I'm a fairly prolific (fan-)fiction writer, and also AI enthusiast, so of course I jumped on that bandwagon as soon as I could. What I've found is... - AI cannot write stories on its own. It just can't, full stop. Some people try, including me, but the results are nonsensical without significant tweaking. I expect that to change eventually, but not without a conceptual breakthrough or two. - AI is immensely useful as a prosthetic imagination. What I use it for isn't to write the story for me. It's to, in case I ever get stuck at some point, offer me suggestions for how the story can continue -- suggestions that I can accept or deny. Even if I deny it, it's useful as a way of illuminating my own ideas for the story. There's got to be a reason I don't like that continuation, and that is often enough to think of something I do like. In other words, it's mostly eliminated writer's block. It's also handy for expanding my vocabulary. English is my third language, and while I like to think I'm good enough for daily life -- I've lived in Ireland for over a decade, after all -- there's a big difference between 'good enough for daily life' and 'good enough to write good fiction'. Prior to using NovelAI, my writing was... dry. Conceptually heavy SF doesn't necessarily require high-end wordcrafting, but it helps. The AI, especially when told to emulate Sheridan Le Fanu or any of the other great authors, is better than me at this. And since I can ask it to jump in at any point, it's become the most attentive, capable cowriter I've ever had. Perhaps noticing this, NovelAI now calls their default AI tuning 'Co-Writer'. It's still likely to write something I can't immediately use, but that just means I need to absorb its ideas and make them my own. Repeat a hundred times per day, and I end up learning much, much faster than I ever did when I was writing on my own. To summarize, I don't use AI to write my stories for me. I use it to get better at writing. I think it should be possible to do the same for other forms of art.
- AStrangeMorrow 5y agoIf interested in an other project that offers good tweaking, artbreeder (artbreeder.com) has been around for a while too. You have different models to play with (faces, anime, general, buildings, paintings etc...). Not all of them have the same level of quality and customization, but for example if you go for the face one, you get a really high level of customization: "cross-breeding" of 1 to 8 faces and then tweaking of many attributes (gender, color theme, age, ethnicity, realism, and other various details).