6 ms·
John Milton Argues for Divorce (2021)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LNSY 5y agoI think the primary reason Jesus never argued for divorce is that he didn't reach middle age.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments like this. It leads to worse discussion. In this case we got a religious flamewar—the dumbest and most avoidable kind of flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gwd 5y agoIt's unfortunate that just bringing up Jesus can cause the discussion to go off into the weeds like this, but FWIW I don't think GP can be blamed for that. I think their comment was relevant (the main reason Milton would have even had to argue for divorce was because of the way Jesus' words were interpreted by the powers that be at the time) and respectful (lots of people are unrealistically idealistic when younger, and develop more complex views after being exposed to more life experience). I think it would be a shame to prune off relevant points just because other people are prone to start flamewars in response.
- dang 5y agoThe comment was a shallow one-liner which doesn't come close to supporting your interpretation. The Jesus bait just made it more flammable. Commenters can, and should, do better than that here.
- kstenerud 5y ago
- jfk13 5y ago> a fictional character Harry Potter is a fictional character. Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character. Bilbo Baggins is a fictional character. They never existed outside of their authors' (and then readers') imaginations, although in some aspects they may have been modelled on real people. Jesus of Nazareth, in contrast, is a real person who lived in Galilee and Judea, a couple of thousand years ago. It's hard to find a serious historian who would dispute this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_Jesus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_Jesus You may not believe every aspect of the "official narrative" (or other stories about him), or agree with their view of his significance. But to call him "fictional" is ridiculous.
- trasz 5y ago
- kstenerud 5y agoYes, much along the same lines as Gilgamesh. There may have been a historical seed, but the fruit of his deification and the descriptions of his exploits and character are most definitely fictional, to the point that any actual person has been lost to the sands of time. We can say this because the major miracles attributed to him are verifiably borrowed from existing legends in other kingdoms.
- interpenetrate 5y agoWe can much more easily deny the attribution of the major miracles to the real Jesus by saying miracles don't happen. The much more interesting question for historians for hundreds of years, which you are avoiding, is what real things can be attributed to Jesus?
- kstenerud 5y ago
- q-base 5y agoHaha this made me laugh :)
- watwut 5y agoJesus never married in the first place. Nor had sexual/romantic relationships.
- efdee 5y agoMaria Magdalena would like to have a word with you.
- jfk13 5y agoDan Brown and Nikos Kazantzakis are novelists, not historians.
- efdee 5y agoNeither did they invent Maria Magdalena.
- netcan 5y ago...joining a long tradition of storytelling about this person.
- wiredone 5y agoHave HN Gold my friend.
- unknown_apostle 5y ago...some of which claim to be eye witness accounts, being weirdly restrained in describing the highly miraculous, placing these miracles against a backdrop of great received wisdom and mundane details, all the while sounding as if they actually have the personal backgrounds, sources and motives they claim to have.
- refurb 5y agoSure but some stories are a little more reliable than others.
- gwd 5y agoActually the primary reason he never argued for divorce was that in his day, divorce was actually super easy. During his day there were two schools of thought on divorce; one required specific grounds for divorce (which included adultery, abuse, and abandonment); the other allowed it for "any cause". There's a case to be made that Jesus' teaching on divorce (most fully represented in Matthew 19[1]) was aimed exclusively at the unfair use of this "any cause" divorce [2]. [1] https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+19%3A1-12&version=NIV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+19%3A1-... [2] http://www.instonebrewer.com/DivorceRemarriage/Articles/WhitefieldBriefing.htm http://www.instonebrewer.com/DivorceRemarriage/Articles/Whit...
- netcan 5y agoThe style is a little too flowery and verbose for my taste, so I skimmed and might be missing something. This is the (long) period of British history where the main political & rhetorical battleground was the protestant reformation. Milton himself was a convert, as were many (most?) notable Englishmen his generation. Divorce was a primary/defining point of contention between catholics & protestants. I feel like there's not enough context here, to get an understanding of what being pro-divorce means in his time & place.
- wonderwonder 5y agoKind of off topic but I sometimes wonder how many unhappy marriages that should end in divorce for the benefit of both parties don't due to financial hardships. Which might also explain why the trope of rich men being on their 3rd or 4th wife exist as there is no financial hurdle to them staying in a marriage. They are able to decide that the marriage is not working and just end it and start again.
- cookieswumchorr 5y agois this really a thing? I mean if you can afford it, go on, but why make the same mistake 3 or 4 times in a row
- gumby 5y agoThe triumph of hope over experience.
- medo-bear 5y agoor maybe it is not due to financial hardship, but for the sake of their children. while growing up i have seen too many kids being socially disadvantaged due to their parents being divorced
- notch656a 5y agoAnecdotally, it's definitely way cheaper to be married with kids. Child support is commonly like 30% of salary after taxes (20% before). As a married couple we definitely don't need to spend anywhere near that to maintain the kid, but the courts after a divorce say you must pay it or go to jail. So the end result would be the one in custody gets to pocket that difference. Very expensive on the parent without custody. If my wife and I ever split, I would much prefer to stay estranged while being half responsible for the kid, to being divorced paying 30% of my salary for no fucking reason beyond that's what some bean counter decided is the cost of the child.
- heresie-dabord 5y agoRich folks can be as naive as anyone else, and they certainly must attract different predators... Not that I would know. ^_^ > marriages that should end in divorce for the benefit of both parties don't due to financial hardships. The Sunken Cost Fallacy. It's a cruel -- and common -- steady-state among married people. It makes no sense to gamble that ten years from now two people will be the same and want the same things. People change. You might reach the SCF steady-state, but you might also be stuck with a wretch or a lunatic. Having children gives the SCF steady-state even more inertia.
- pyuser583 5y agoSo he went to collect and debt payment, and instead married the guys daughter. How does that happen?