3 ms·
Scientists do not have the luxury of pretending politics and bad actors don’t exist.
by ceejayoz 5y ago
Scientists do not have the luxury of pretending politics and bad actors don’t exist.
- Jimmc414 5y agoPolitics and bad actors have always existed. Scientists should counter them with facts and honesty not censorship.
- xqcgrek2 5y agoThat's not how the world or mathematics (game theory) works
- Jimmc414 5y agoCan you think of a scenario where science has ever benefited from censorship? Correct me if I am wrong, but respectfully that is the argument you are making, right?
- sooheon 5y agoNot that science benefits from censorship, but that game theory sometimes necessitates it. Imagine a scientist with significant political cachet. This allows them to receive more funding, do more science. They cannot optimize their behavior only for truth-seeking, because that fails to maximize their political capital. If they optimize for the former, they will be replaced by someone who is better at the latter. Any scientist that relies on external funding must balance science with politics to continue to do science, sometimes this involves censorship.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Scientists should counter them with facts and honesty not censorship. Scientists must be careful in how they communicate, and organizations like the CDC and FDA need to staff expert scientific communicators who can explain complicated things to lay people. Bill Nye types. "Vaccines contain dihydrogen monoxide, a chemical that killed over 200,000 people within hours in 2004" is a scientifically factual statement, but not a well communicated one.
- johncena33 5y agoThe reality is not so rosy. Many virologists know that if lab leak is true their careers will be over. So I am very skeptical of how much obfuscations and disinformation spread by virologists is for the good of humanity and how much of it is just to protect their self interest.