4 ms·
Is it RESF, or is it Rust's unique feature of memory safety (and data race safety) without GC? D is a nice language to be sure, but it's going to have trouble
by zozbot234 5y ago
Is it RESF, or is it Rust's unique feature of memory safety (and data race safety) without GC? D is a nice language to be sure, but it's going to have trouble matching these features. Of course, this is not meant as a criticism of D - other languages like Jai are practically in the same boat. The C++ folks are at least aware of the challenge, as is clear from the C++ Core Guidelines effort.
- WalterBright 5y agoD already has most of the memory safe features of Rust. Of course, the most valuable memory safety feature is array overflow protection, which D has had since its inception. By most valuable, it tops the list of security vulnerabilities in compiled code, year after year. D also has a prototype borrow checker.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoRust definitely has a lot of merits. I was definitely following it, and excited by its release. But you cannot deny the RESF was obnoxious. And pervasive. But ultimately successful - the people who voiced their dislike would get down-voted to oblivion.
- mustache_kimono 5y agoThe anti-Rust stuff was/is pretty tiresome too. FWIW, I think disagreements about the choices Rust made make plenty of sense, or even the disagreements re: its style. But that wasn't what most of the anti-Rust stuff was/is -- it was/is just resentment regarding the hype of a thing, which is just the worst sort of criticism.
- sundarurfriend 5y agoRESF = Rust Evangelism Strike Force apparently, for those not in the know.