4 ms·
> Roads are the most commons example of induced demand. Adding new roads rarely decreases travel times because new roads encourage more people to drive which le
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Roads are the most commons example of induced demand. Adding new roads rarely decreases travel times because new roads encourage more people to drive which leads to more traffic that soaks up any benefit the new roads added.
The problem with "induced demand" is that it's misnamed. It's really suppressed demand.
Suppose you have a congested road. It has two lanes and currently has enough traffic to require three lanes. So you add a third lane. Then you turn around and it's congested again.
Because the congestion suppresses demand. The third lane relieved some of the congestion which increased use. To satisfy the demand that exists when there isn't any congestion, you would need four lanes.
But not necessarily five, because once the congestion is gone, adding more lanes doesn't make it any more gone. If you built a twenty lane road there, traffic to fill it wouldn't just magically appear. (China has done the experiment.)
This is important because it applies to anything else you want to use to relieve the congestion. "Don't build more roads, that's induced demand. The only solution is more mass transit." But if you build the mass transit and it removes one lane worth of traffic from the road, that's the same result as adding the third lane. Which isn't enough for the same reason -- the reduction in congestion increases use of the road. Because the demand isn't being induced by a wider road, it's being suppressed by the existing congestion.
The internet speeds are a great example. In the dial up days, the low speed heavily suppressed demand. Your connection was pretty much maxed out whenever you were using it. Now connections are 1000 times faster or more and we use what, 20 times more bandwidth? Maybe 100 times? The speed increases outpaced the usage increases. It's possible to do that.
- mcphage 5y ago> But if you build the mass transit and it removes one lane worth of traffic from the road, that's the same result as adding the third lane. Mass transit can handle much more than one lane worth of traffic.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Mass transit can handle much more than one lane worth of traffic. It's not about how many people you can physically fit on a train car. They all have to be going the same way or it doesn't work. There could be one lane worth of people who are doing that and the others are going to thousands of different places.
- slg 5y agoI read this mostly as a semantic difference. Both supply and demand generally exist as curves and changing the position of the supply curve changes the position it intersects with the demand curve. The demand curve isn't actually changing. Whether we call that move from the first intersection to the second "induced demand" or "release of suppressed demand" doesn't really matter in my opinion. The concept is the same. Jevons Paradox is a little different in that it doesn't change how we traditionally model the supply curve (that is probably why the two graphs on that Wikipedia page only show the demand curve). But the end result is the same that we have now moved to a different spot on the demand curve.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYes, it's all about moving to a different place on the demand curve. It's two things that regularly get missed with induced demand. The first is the assumption of infinite demand. If two lanes isn't enough, and you add a third and that isn't enough, by induction (pun intended) you wouldn't have enough even with infinity lanes. But in practice it will be finite and might only be four. The second is that you can "induce" demand by removing demand, and therefore reducing congestion and increasing demand. If your goal is to eliminate congestion then one way or another you have to satisfy the demand that exists without congestion.
- beerandt 5y agoAnother blind spot is people using it as an reason/excuse for public transport. They somehow see a new lane as inducing demand, but not train tracks or a seat on a bus.
- 9935c101ab17a66 5y agoIf more train lines or more bus seats increases the number of people using public transit, that's an unequivocal victory and is in fact the whole point of public transit.
- beerandt 5y ago
- gwern 5y agoBy shifting the bottlenecks elsewhere, in the case of bandwidth. People would totally use way more download bandwidth, for videoconferencing / streaming if nothing else, but you run into latency and upload limits first, rendering the idea of nice 4k streams impractical.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's what it is for everything, no? Something is "enough" when it moves the bottleneck somewhere else. In the end it becomes humans. What's the resolution of your eyes? How many streams can you watch at once? It's less bandwidth than fiber has, isn't it?
- barrkel 5y agoFor roads specifically, it's not necessarily suppressed demand. Commute times are a significant element in peoples' calculations about where to live. Increase road capacity and living further away (with cheaper land, bigger houses and so on) becomes more attractive, which adds to traffic on the road. The road capacity attracts the demand through second order effects.
- vidarh 5y agoIt's not just suppressed demand, though. E.g. most people in big cities tends to measure commutes in unit of time rather than distance. Reduce congestion and the region considered commutable by people increases, and as a result the region becomes more desirable as a place to conduct business because you have access to a larger Labour pool. It certainly is possible to outpace the increase, but the point remains that you need to consider that there likely will be an increase beyond any measurable suppressed demand. It also matters because sometimes it points to alternative strategies: for roads it may turn out it is better to seek to induce demand elsewhere to alleviate congestion, for example. One of my pet peeves, living in London, is that instead of alleviating congestion in the centre it'd be better to improve commutability between the town around the edge of London to draw demand out of the centre, for example. Another way of putting that is that to take advantage of induced demand, when capacity issues you should look for options to leverage it to spread the load whenever that is cheaper than increasing the capacity to the core of the system, and often spreading the load can be a lot cheaper.