4 ms·
> Graph databases are necessary to implement semantic web databases. This just isn't true, on multiple levels. RDF is an interoperability standard that does n
by zozbot234 5y ago
> Graph databases are necessary to implement semantic web databases.
This just isn't true, on multiple levels. RDF is an interoperability standard that does not per se depend on a 'graph-like' data model - you can very much expose plain old relational data via RDF, and this is quite intended. Additionally, modern general-purpose RDBMS's support graph-focused data models quite well, despite being built on 'relational' principles - there's no need for special tech when working with general-purpose graph models, unless you're doing some sort of heavy-duty network analytics.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoYou're talking about extending a database design created 50 years ago to work with models and methods that involve significantly different operations and concepts. Let the RDBMS die so we can make something that is much more powerful and requires less fidgeting and squinting to work the way we want. RDBMS were a niche research project for a decade before they started to catch on in business apps. They've stayed around forever because they're just functional enough to be dangerous. But we've already hit the upper limits of both reliability and performance years ago (remember NoSQL?) and we just keep bolting on features because nobody wants to leave them. The old designs and implementations are holding us back.
- mdavidn 5y agoYou and I work on very different kinds of projects. I find myself fidgeting and squinting at the database far more when it fails to enforce a schema or provide ACID transactions.
- gmfawcett 5y agoWas this supposed to be a rallying cry, or a grumpy rant? I'm getting a mixed message.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoThat's... a perfect summary of everything I think about technology. Very grumpy and very optimistic. :)
- gmfawcett 5y agoLOL, fair enough. Then your delivery was pitch-perfect. :)
- smarx007 5y agoRDF is a labeled multigraph data model with URI-based predicates as edge labels, where each triple represents an edge. You are right that relational data can be exposed in RDF, just like CSV can be loaded into a graph DB.