4 ms·
I don't see how the man-mad warming camp can make-such-matter of fact assertions such as in http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/09/07/krugman-shape-of-earth h
by pbreit 15y ago
I don't see how the man-mad warming camp can make-such-matter of fact assertions such as in http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/09/07/krugman-shape-of-earth http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/09/07/krugman-shape-of... when the evidence does not seem to be conclusive. It's even more alarming that the other side is belittled.
Surely there must be something more compelling than "An Inconvenient Truth" on the matter?
- nl 15y agohttp://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-basic.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-basic.htm is what you are after. See also http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-intermediate.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-intermediate.htm and http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-advanced.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-advanced.htm depending on the level of discussion you like. How do human CO2 emissions compare to natural CO2 emissions? http://www.skepticalscience.com/human-co2-smaller-than-natural-emissions-intermediate.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/human-co2-smaller-than-natur... is also related The whole site is rather good. You can pull up your objection and erad the discussion: http://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php http://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php
- hartror 15y agoJohn Cook is my hero I've referenced his site in so many arguments with people on friend's facebook statuses[1]. [1] This is a hobby of mine, many friends of friends seem to work in the coal mining industry and therefore need the cognitive dissonance of climate change denial (not skepticism you will note, denial) in order to operate.
- hugh3 15y agoThat's a fairly good site, actually. However, when the position taken up by one side is "There is no room for skepticism about what my model predicts will happen in the future!" and the position taken up by the other side is "There is some room for skepticism about what that model says will happen in the future" then the no-skepticism side has already lost. If only these folks would phrase it as a balance-of-probabilities issue rather than an absolute-certainty issue then they'd have me on their side. But as it is, I'm forced to side with the skeptical side. Nothing could be worse for science than to try to make "skepticism" a dirty word.
- epistasis 15y ago>"There is no room for skepticism about what my model predicts will happen in the future!" Can you show me an instance of someone espousing this position?
- hugh3 15y agoWould you like it in those exact words, or would you settle for something functionally equivalent? If you want those exact words then it'll probably take me a while to dig up. If you want something functionally equivalent go watch Al Gore's movie.
- MarkPNeyer 15y agoal gore, for one, has said climate change skeptics are comparable to racists, and are peddling bullshit. http://www.mediaite.com/online/al-gore-compares-climate-change-skeptics-to-20th-century-racists/ http://www.mediaite.com/online/al-gore-compares-climate-chan... i grew up in the conservative midwest and was exposed to near lethal doses of rush limbaugh as a child. it took me FOREVER to consider that maybe global warming was real, becuase i was only hearing about it from people who were clearly motivated more by political concerns than anything else, and who insulted me for daring to disagree. i have a BS in physics, and although this in no way makes me qualified to assert climatologists are wrong, it does give me more insight into the situation than someone with no such background. i grew tired of trying to explain concepts like the physical mechanisms of heat transfer, emission / absorption spectra (which are ostensibly at the root of anthropogenic warming), the statistical mechanics definition of temperature, the idea that the atmosphere has layers, &c &c, to people who had no idea what i was talking about, and clearly didn't care. they always gave me the "pascal's wager" argument: that it didn't matter of the science was wrong, because on the chance it was right, we're fucked. i'm still not sure how i feel about global warming, but i do know this: if you want to convince people that they are wrong about something, telling them they are racist morons probably isn't going to do the trick.
- epistasis 15y agoI asked a question about scientists who say their models can't be questioned. Is this related in some way? In the interest of burning karma, let's change the subject to the interesting topic of near lethal doses of politics (as in potential loss of life). My colleagues get firebombed in their homes from morons on the leftist side of the political spectrum. In a similar manner to the filth that you linked, they are riled up by demagogues that lie and misrepresent in any way to smear their target. These followers are not bright, but they want to feel as if they are enlightened and as if the world is crazy. They just want to belong. They want to believe fervently in something. Believe that they're fighting the good fight. You can tell they're getting riled up when there's an increase in graffiti that says things like "Humans Suck" at the bus stops, or if there are fliers in scruffy coffee houses listing biology professors' home addresses. Fortunately these losers are as terrible at firebombing as they are at reaching a larger audience. In Southern California they don't even make the news due at the behest of the University. In Northern California, there's a local news article, the scientists hold a 15 minute vigil at 5:30pm and share encouraging words, then head back to their labs to squeeze in one more DNA purification or to feed the cell cultures, and the terrorism has had zero lasting effect, other than some terrified kids that crawled out the rope ladder in their room because the front door was on fire, and some FBI guys that get to sit in cars on the street for the next couple months. These aren't the "enviros" that cut power lines, harass gold miners, or tree sit, but they are friends with them. Perhaps if they had grown up in the conservative west and weren't incompetent, their terrorism would cause permanent damage to life. It doesn't matter which side of the political spectrum they come from, those who deliberately misrepresent the truth and pander to the most base and violent instincts, those who are driven by ideology rather than observation and reason, are poisoning the intellectual well. They can't be ignored, as they are more dangerous when they can play their dirty tricks in the dark, but they can't be encouraged. Very frustrating. What's the solution? I have absolutely no idea. No person in their right mind would read the quote in the linked article and think that Al Gore called climate skeptics racists. A person in their right mind would think that Al Gore was using the largest cultural shift in recent history to illustrate his prediction of another cultural shift, in Al Gore's typically goofy and easily mocked fashion. But frame the quote in the way you did, and a person is already too riled up to read it in their right mind. And maybe they don't want to be in their right mind, maybe they want to feel justified in the contempt for the political Other. It's a perfectly human reaction to circle the wagons when under attack. And thus is perfectly rational human instinct subverted to the detriment of all. But back to my question, is there any climate scientists that has said that there's no need for scientific questioning of their models? Because the impression I'm getting is climate science is fraudulent because of Al Gore. Just like when he invented the Internet, that Al Gore is getting too big for his britches. And he doesn't have Vint Cerf to bail him out this time. Edit: sorry if this came across as rude, I didn't mean to. I didn't understand your point, and then just started riffing on the great idea of a lethal dose of Rush Limbaugh.
- hugh3 15y agoFTFA: Climate change may or may not be occurring. But there is no dispute that 98 percent of climate scientists believe that it is happening and is man-made. The problem is in the phrasing of the question. Questions like "are global average temperatures increasing on a decade-to-decade timescale?" and "is climate change at least partly due to human activity?" are very different questions to "is the observed change in climate due primarily to anthropogenic factors?" and "to what extent is this likely to be a problem in the future" and "is it time to agree to [random policy proposal X that might help to cut CO_2 emissions slightly]?" -- but all these questions are treated as if they're the same question. I'm so glad I work in an area of science where politics rarely intrudes.
- nl 15y agoare global average temperatures increasing on a decade-to-decade timescale?" and "is climate change at least partly due to human activity? Yes. See page 3 of http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/cmb/bams-sotc/2009/bams-sotc-2009-brochure-lo-rez.pdf http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/cmb/bams-sotc/2009/bams-s... "is climate change at least partly due to human activity?" "is the observed change in climate due primarily to anthropogenic factors?" These might be different questions but the answer is the same. Yes. See http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-advanced.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/its-not-us-advanced.htm, in particular these quotes: The late-twentieth-century warming can only be reproduced in the model with anthropogenic forcing (mainly GHGs), while the early twentieth-century warming is mainly caused by natural forcing in the model (mainly solar). Our results show significant anthropogenic warming trends in all the continental regions analyzed. I don't believe that there is consensus around how bad a problem this will be in the future (beyond "bad").
- pewpewlasergun 15y agoDo you mind saying why you don't find thousands of scientific articles published in a wide variety of journals compelling?
- pbreit 15y agoI lean towards the man-made position but am disappointed in how the evidence is presented and the knee-jerk dismissal of any and all contrary information. Also, I am not aware of 1000s of (independent) articles.
- gjm11 15y agoHave you investigated the literature in such a way that you would expect to be aware of "thousands of articles" if they were really there?
- pbreit 15y agoYes. I would be very surprised if there were thousands of original articles.
- gjm11 15y agoThe original comment merely referred to "thousands of scientific articles". You've now said you'd be surprised if there were thousands of "independent" articles, or if there were thousands of "original" articles, without indicating what you mean by "independent" and "original" or why only thousands of "independent" or "original" articles are the right thing to look for. If you're implying that the great majority of published climate science research is literally plagiarized, then that's an extraordinary claim and I'd like to see your extraordinary evidence. But I'm guessing you mean something else -- e.g., that most papers (in that or any other field) aren't startlingly creative, or that most papers make some use of other earlier research rather than doing anything from scratch. In that case you owe us an explanation of why it's a problem. Do you know of thousands of "independent", "original" articles supporting general relativity or the Standard Model or particle physics or evolution or, well, anything? (I think "dependent", "unoriginal" work is vital, both for scientific progress and for providing evidence. Consider: One paper introduces a brilliant new idea and provides some experimental support for it. Ten other papers explore its theoretical consequence. Ten more report on experiments done using the ideas in the original paper and those ten successors, getting results consistent with the theory. If the research in those papers is sensibly chosen and competently done, we now have much more evidence for the original brilliant idea than after the first paper, even though that's the only "original" one.)