6 ms·
Good. Between insurrections in DC, women's clinics burning down, church fires, etc., etc., etc., we need a federal-level team coordinating efforts against this
by kstrauser 5y ago
Good. Between insurrections in DC, women's clinics burning down, church fires, etc., etc., etc., we need a federal-level team coordinating efforts against this stuff.
- notch656a 5y agoHopefully they will start with the domestic terrorist organization that fired upon civilians in Waco and Ruby Ridge.
- mulmen 5y agoThey did, you can see the consequences of that in Malheur.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikecoles 5y agoThey tried to give Chipman a top-level position. This indicates the target of this new regime is after.
- syki 5y agoThe federal government executed a search warrant on the Branch Dravidian compound. It was a legally executed warrant and 4 government agents were killed in a gun battle. After this the FBI surrounded the compound for 51 days before using tear gas to storm the compound. A fire started (possibly due to FBI incompetence) and a lot of people died. This does not qualify as domestic terrorism. If a government can’t enforce a search warrant then it’s pretty much useless. It’s weird to use Waco and not a multitude of other legitimate examples of government law enforcement overreach. At any rate, none of those would qualify for the label “domestic terrorism” in the strict sense of the word but would suffice for a broader point you might be trying to make. To wit, are there adequate checks on the abuse of police power. The answer is no and one group that tried to bring up this issue, ironically given your apparent political leaning, is BLM. Police in the U.S. regularly mete out non judicial punishments and there are virtually no real checks against this. The common ground, perhaps, that we share is that government overreach and abuse of police powers ought to be addressed in a meaningful way before expanding police powers or creating new investigative units. Especially when the charge is to stop domestic terrorism. That phrase can be twisted and abused in a such a manner that a non violent advocate like Martin Luther King could be labeled a domestic terrorist.
- notch656a 5y agoAgreed on the common ground. >'The answer is no and one group that tried to bring up this issue, ironically given your apparent political leaning, is BLM' Is this supposed to be some smear at me suggesting I don't believe many very real claims that have been made by black demographic regarding police abuse? What do you even mean by this being ironic? >The federal government executed a search warrant on the Branch Dravidian compound That's the most charitable view I think I've ever heard described defending what happened at Waco. You believe what happened was 'legally executed'? Or that those killed were legally executed? I'm not sure if number of people who died means anything in terms of who was right and who was wrong, but it's pretty telling you mention the 4 government agents that died by number but don't number the 25 dead children (mostly burned alive) and 2 pregnant women. This all after Koresh could have just been grabbed peacefully outside the compound rather than in a standoff. Afterwords agents POSED over the rubble and dead bodies. But a few paragraphs of us describing Waco isn't going to do justice to ourselves or fellow HNers, so please the few of you who haven't read about it please study and make your own decision. Lastly: I didn't say Waco had to be interpreted by the reader as 'domestic terrorism', I said they (DoJ) should start with the 'domestic terrorism organization' that carried it out. Do you understand the difference? You can decide for yourself what agency or body(ies) that applies to.
- syki 5y agoI’ll rephrase to clear misunderstandings. A legal warrant was obtained and federal agents attempted to exercise that warrant. Whilst attempting to carry out the warrant a gun battle ensued in which 4 federal agents were killed and 7 or so members of the cult were killed. After 51 days federal agents stormed the compound and quite a few people including children died. All of the blame rests on the people in charge of the cult. Nothing they did was moral or justifiable. A government should have the power to exercise legally obtained warrants. Otherwise it is a useless government.
- notch656a 5y ago>I’ll rephrase to clear misunderstandings. A legal warrant was obtained and federal agents attempted to exercise that warrant. Whilst attempting to carry out the warrant a gun battle ensued in which 4 federal agents were killed and 7 or so members of the cult were killed. After 51 days federal agents stormed the compound and quite a few people including children died. I take this as basically accurate. >All of the blame rests on the people in charge of the cult. Nothing they did was moral or justifiable. A government should have the power to exercise legally obtained warrants. Otherwise it is a useless government. You make a lot of presumptions about what I've said about Waco. ALL I said was DoJ should start with the 'domestic terror organization' that fired upon civilians at Waco and Ruby Ridge. I said nothing about morality, whether the WARRANT was justified, or even who the blame for Waco rests on. This is starting to look like your own rabbit-hole we're going down where you think something you say about who is to blame at Waco discredits the ONLY assertion I made about Waco (which was civilians were fired upon.) It's starting to look like your own personal vendetta, one I'm very confused of the reason behind. >All of the blame rests on the people in charge of the cult. Even I don't have this level of confidence as to what proportion of blame to assign to who at Waco. The fact that you've reached such confidence about an event where we still lack full accuracy of details, is one of the most stunning and clear cases of Dunning-Kruger-esque effect I've seen on HN. Regarding a useless government? Nah I think the government can still maintain functional ability to execute a search warrant without executing in in the way the fatal siege was executed in Waco.
- gedy 5y agoYou say that, but then imagine "the other side" calling BLM protests, etc as domestic terrorists and same feds go after them.
- kstrauser 5y agoSo we should never investigate partisan criminals because someday "the other side" might do the same. That leads to the situation where any violence is allowed, and I don't want to live in that society.
- runjake 5y agoI think the commenter was just trying to even the political playing field. The threat list you provided seemed like it was from someone left-leaning. It did not mention the commonly-occurring mayhem, riots, vandalism, and arson coming from people describing themselves as affiliated with Leftist organizations (sorry, I cannot find better wording here. I am not trying to sound partisan here.)
- fallingknife 5y agoThey are being investigated now by law enforcement without this special unit.
- aschearer 5y agoThat happened. They sent white vans to pick people up in Portland... https://www.npr.org/2020/07/17/892277592/federal-officers-use-unmarked-vehicles-to-grab-protesters-in-portland https://www.npr.org/2020/07/17/892277592/federal-officers-us...
- giraffe_lady 5y agoYes. Leftist activists tend to be pretty unenthusiastic about this stuff because any new tools, powers, or resources will be turned on us eventually. Shit just in the last few years we've had pipeline protestors charged with domestic terrorism, BLM protestors facing gang enhancement felony charges for property damage (paint not arson if that matters). It's good that the government is ready to back down its stance of "ignore extremist violence as long as they call themselves patriots" but I don't want to find out what the tucker carlson administration would do with a domestic terrorism task force ya know?
- bilbo0s 5y agoMy only confusion is that I believed that they surely must have had a domestic counterterrorism unit previously? I mean if they didn't, what are we paying them for? No wonder Walmarts, schools and places of worship are getting shot up. I guess it's good they created one now, but if they didn't have a unit with dedicated resources on the domestic terrorism problem previously, it really does demonstrate a lack of military sense.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI'm certain the US government had more than one of these units prior to this announcement. I sense this is probably more of an organizational realignment more than anything else, kind of like how "The Space Force" was created by carving out elements from the other branches, mainly the Air Force, and calling it something new.
- skissane 5y agoDOJ has a National Security Division, headed by the Assistant Attorney General for National Security. Within the DOJ National Security Division, there is a Counter-Terrorism Section, headed by the Deputy Assistant Attorney General for Counter-Terrorism. The Counter-Terrorism Section deals with all cases of terrorism, whether international or domestic. My interpretation of this story, is they are creating a dedicated team of people within the Counter-Terrorism Section to handle "domestic" terrorism, rather than having the same team(s) handle a mixture of "international" and "domestic" cases. It really is a nothing story. It is nothing like the Space Force – that involved a major legal change in the high-level military structure, changing reporting lines for senior officials (the Air Force's space head was elevated to membership of the Joint Chiefs of Staff), this seems to just involve a change in the internal team structure of an existing government office (a section of a division of a department). They just want to make it sound like they are doing something. How do you decide what is "international" and what is "domestic" terrorism anyway? If someone is recruited by Islamic State to commit a terrorist attack, that's international. But if some lone wolf radicalises themselves by spending hours a day watching Islamic State propaganda videos, and that inspires them to commit a terrorist attack – is that "international" or "domestic"? And how is that different from if the lone wolf had spent hours a day watching QAnon videos instead?
- 18237198371q 5y ago
- footlose_3815 5y ago[dead]
- hidudeurcool 5y ago
- fallingknife 5y agoYou can say a lot of things about the Jan 6 rioters. But you can't call them terrorists. They didn't go after civilians. They went straight at the government.
- jmondi 5y agoTerrorist - an advocate or practitioner of terrorism as a means of coercion Terrorism - the systematic use of terror especially as a means of coercion They were exactly terrorists. Also, insurrectionists...
- fallingknife 5y agoAny attack involves fear. The soldiers at Pearl harbor were probably terrified. Doesn't make it a terrorist attack.
- orang2tang 5y ago
- space_fountain 5y agoThe government having a monopoly on legitimate violence is politics 101. I agree that arguing by definition is bad form, but like beating someone up because they aren't letting you into the capital building so you can disrupt the counting of the votes for your political opponents is an extreme violent way of going about things. Encouraging such violence destabilized politics and encourages your opponents to start using violence too leading to an escalating cycle. You don't want to call that terrorism fine, but it is a very bad thing.
- tamaharbor 5y agoI guess they weren’t insurrectionists either, as no one has been charged with that crime.
- beeboop 5y ago
- cm2187 5y agoBrought by the same people who supported the destruction of entire city centers last year.
- syki 5y agoI’m assuming you are referring to BLM and those who support them. I don’t know of anyone who supported the destruction of entire city centers. One person convicted of burning a building down in Minneapolis was not from Minneapolis and was a right wing supporter. I do know that people felt that police abuses had gone too far and with impunity. In places like Minneapolis police no longer had the consent of the governed. Quoting the Declaration of Independence: That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,—That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Perhaps you view the protestors as terrorists but I suggest this is a twisting of that term. I do not embrace a domestic office of terrorism for the same reason that I oppose the Department of Homeland security. We Americans have become a divided people wallowing in fear of those fellow countryman who adhere to the wrong ideology. It is too easy for a demagogue to usurp the normal functioning of the law enforcement to go after “domestic terrorism”. Too many people will willingly support the infringement of the rights of those with the wrong ideology. One thing we should all agree with is that major police reforms are badly needed.
- beeboop 5y agoI live a couple blocks from CHOP/CHAZ. There was no destruction. I got my haircut every couple weeks at a business inside CHOP. Everything was and still is entirely normal.
- majinuub 5y agoThis type of mentality is what lead to forever wars in the Middle East. How about we don't establish organizations that will likely be used to infringe on the rights of innocents?