4 ms·
If parking gets too expensive, I can imagine self-driving cars circling the block until the owner is ready to go.
by criddell 5y ago
If parking gets too expensive, I can imagine self-driving cars circling the block until the owner is ready to go.
- kspacewalk2 5y agoPassing an enforceable law against that will be a lot easier, since the companies responsible for self-driving car algorithms can be bashed upside the head with it.
- sokoloff 5y agoSend the car on an errand and have it come back, or even send it “home” and summon it later. (I’m deeply skeptical that we’ll have level 5 self-driving cars in my lifetime, but if we do, we won’t need to pay $50 in today’s money to park anywhere…)
- jdminhbg 5y agoEven outside of "cheating" like this, self-driving would have a pretty significant impact on parking economics. You don't need to have parking spread throughout the city in convenient places, because you can send your car to the central parking depot while you're shopping and recall it when you're done.
- criddell 5y agoI don't think sending a car on an errand is cheating in any way. In fact I think it's one of the great promises of self driving cars. People already do curbside pickup of groceries, dry cleaning, restaurant food, etc... There's no reason a person needs to be in that car.
- vkou 5y agoThis sounds wonderful, except for the part where your desire to avoid paying for parking is creating gridlock for everyone else, as your car drives around, creating traffic. [1] Since I'm not interested in paying the taxes necessary to double the amount of roads in town, and since I hate traffic, I'd rather just make what you describe illegal [2], just like how many other nuisances are illegal on public roadways. It should be pretty easy for legislatures to force vendors to disable self-driving summons/parking on public roads. [1] And no, even if the traffic you create is counterflow, we will still need more road capacity, and I'm not paying for it. Where I live, there is no 'counterflow' - traffic consistently sucks in both directions of travel. [2] Or toll you, preferably to the point where you'll find it more advantageous to just pay for parking.
- jdminhbg 5y agoI think you misunderstood. I'm not talking about driving around in a holding pattern. I'm saying that instead of interspersing valuable real estate with parking lots so that people can walk from their car to the shop/restaurant, you can put all the parking in one (realistically, a few) places.
- SECProto 5y ago> Send the car on an errand and have it come back, or even send it “home” and summon it later Now imagine what this will do to rush hour traffic - There would be twice as many vehicle trips for the same number of people. Road tolls (particularly on unoccupied cars) would be needed as part of any solution, which everyone loves even more than parking fees.
- rahimnathwani 5y ago"Road tolls (particularly on unoccupied cars)" Why should the number of occupants affect the amount of the toll?
- kspacewalk2 5y agoTo disincentivize cars driving around empty.
- rahimnathwani 5y agoA toll on all cars (not just empty cars) would already disincentivize driving around empty.
- SECProto 5y agoA larger toll on empty cars would disincentivize it more.
- rahimnathwani 5y ago"A larger toll on empty cars would disincentivize it more." A larger toll on all cars would disincentivize it just as much. My point is: why not set the toll at an optimum level, and then let each car owner decide whether it's worth the car driving at a particular time and place? If we want to charge people based on the contents of the car, why not charge lower tolls for cars with 5 occupants instead of 4. Or lower tolls for cars carrying older or fatter people (who are less able to take public transport)? It seems to me that road usage prices should be high enough to limit/eliminate congestion and that, if they were that high, there would be no need to discriminate based on what is being carried.
- kspacewalk2 5y agoAgreed on the likelihood of having ubiquitous level 5 self-driving cars in my lifetime as well (I'm in my mid-30s). But I'm also very skeptical about the desirability of this kind of a transformation, and the desirability of (re-)building cities around it. Your examples are two of infinitely many that illustrate how self-driven or not, cars fuck things up. In short, many people agree that the human-driven, gasoline-powered car is the problem. But far too many zero in on the adjectives, implying that solving the "human-driven" part will solve our cities' problems (love the traffic-light-free intersection visualizations, totally want to be a pedestrian trying to live next to those). Then there are people pretending electric cars are more than just marginally better for the environment when the full life cycle of both the energy required to power them and the materials that go into them is considered. Stop trying to fix the car. The car is the problem. Specifically, at a certain point (you can quantify it as certain population density, or population size) there are too many of them to rely on them for transportation of most people and to have liveable cities. In North America, we sacrificed the liveability of cities to keep the car, in Europe they're sacrificing the car for liveability. There's not too much more to it than that. Electric self-driving cars change this a bit, but not enough to matter. It's basically the same as above.
- Symmetry 5y agoWhy do that when you could send it somewhere where parking is cheap? The behind anti-cruising laws is to prevent cars from jamming up popular locations, if you send it somewhere other than your destination block then the law is working.
- sokoloff 5y agoIf there’s a place nearby that’s more advantageous than a farther away place, people will naturally do that. It would hopefully spur some competition for economy parking someplace close but not in the city center.
- jstarfish 5y agoThis will run you afoul of existing no-cruising laws. (...which were put on the books decades ago to keep taxi drivers trolling for fares out of high-congestion areas.)
- brk 5y agoFortunately we're still quite a long ways away from self driving cars in the sense of truly driverless cars that can be relied upon to navigate safely on their own in random settings, like a city block.
- criddell 5y agoYeah, for sure. Malcolm Gladwell wrote about his experience in a Waymo and he came to an interesting conclusion. Because self driving cars always defer to pedestrians, pedestrians will get very bold and not be scared about stepping off the curb in front of a self driving car. It could mean traveling through dense urban centers by car is almost impossible. Of course, car owners vote in enough numbers that, if this were to happen, I could see cities installing barriers between side walks and streets like Las Vegas has in the strip area.
- alkonaut 5y agoBetter yet, with some planning it could go quite far to a place with ample parking (or even back home) to wait. Then come pick me up.
- jjav 5y agoBut that trades a lot of unnecessarily wasted energy to move those 4000+ pounds to a faraway place and back, empty, just to work around the parking rules. (See parallel thread on "Lufthansa confirmed that 18k flights had been flown empty to keep slots", which feels related.)
- alkonaut 5y agoCompared to constant driving around the block it can’t be much worse? Worst case it drives away and comes back later with no stop. Best case it drives home or to a parking and waits then returns. The former could be worse than cruising constantly (due to potential higher speed) but the latter is better than constant cruising.