5 ms·
I'm all for not bending over backwards to support a 10-year-old browser, but 2 years is a really tight support window.
by lolinder 5y ago
I'm all for not bending over backwards to support a 10-year-old browser, but 2 years is a really tight support window.
- bee_rider 5y agoIt is software. It can be updated over the internet. People should run up to date browsers.
- mauricioc 5y ago> So I looked at the version of Chrome on my parent’s computer. Version 76! I knew we were at ninety-something in 2022, so I figured that was the culprit. “I’ll just update Chrome,” I thought. > Turns out, you can’t. From what I could gather, the version of Chrome was tied to ChromeOS which couldn’t be updated because of the hardware. No new ChromeOS meant no new Chrome which meant stuck at version 76.
- bee_rider 5y agoThe blame here falls on Google, not the website developers.
- lolinder 5y agoIt falls on Google and the website developers. It's up to Google to allow people to update their software. It's up to the website developers to recognize that the reality doesn't always match the ideal and to develop for the reality.
- bee_rider 5y agoI disagree, Google and Apple are the ones that have locked these devices down. They have the keys and the technical abilities -- they have an obligation to keep them up to date or unlock them. There might be a business rationale to bend to reality, but no obligation. In this case it appears to be a volunteering organization, so I guess they might not be as motivated to solve niche problems.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- simion314 5y ago>it is software. It can be updated over the internet. People should run up to date browsers. There are 2 issues 1 some hardware is locked, you can run what you want on it, it must be approved. In the TFA is is cearly shown that it was impossible to run a new browser version. 2 since is just software as you said, I assume the developers could install some software and have the JS transpiled to a more compatible version or popup a message if the user does not use latest Chrome or Safari and send them away. Maybe search engine should check this websites in an older browser engine and remove SEO points, also try the website with JS off and if you get nothing, no text that you need JS also remove points.
- bee_rider 5y agoGoogle should, due to their inability to keep their devices up to date, SEO-down people who use modern features?
- simion314 5y agoNot Google, all search engine. And let's not forget that others too lock their devices so you can't install a different browser (Apple too), you should be able to read Wikpedia even if your device is 10 years old, My comment was about "is just software" so should the software guys do the transpilation step rather then forcing users to throw their devices? (since again "IS JUST SFOFTWARE)
- bee_rider 5y agoThere's no obligation for websites to support old browsers. NB: this appears to be some volunteering platform. It is probably maintained by volunteers. These volunteers should not have to step up and fill in for incompetence on the part of two of the most profitable companies in human history.
- simion314 5y agoI understand, I am not obligated that my blog work on Safari, I could make it Firefox and Linux only. I also understand that Google and Apple are rich and are always chasing more profits and I don't defend this evil giants. I also understand that are exceptions like you are not building a simple webpage but a very complex image/video/code/graph editor or video game and you need a very specific feature. What I am saying is if you put a webpage that targets everyone (not a limited subset like say our internal team that all run latest Apple shit) then since "is is just software" it is easier to transpile the code then ask the world to throw away their devices and buy new stuff. I am sure you are not OK if all websites will use a new JS feature in the exact day it is released and the updates did not had time to propagate to all users, so the question is how many percent of an users should is small enough so a average webdev can stop using the transpiler and break stuff?
- iam-TJ 5y agoHow about when the updated browser removes functionality that servers require? Especially in 'enterprisey' networks there are devices that /still/ require SSL, Java applets, Flash (urghh!), SSH v1 support, or features of (X)HTML, CSS, and Javascript that have been removed or modified. Most of that hardware would be expensive and disruptive to replace. I still maintain a version of 32-bit Netscape Navigator for accessing some key infra-structure devices that continue to work perfectly and are on isolated private networks. Some examples: Cabinet Distribution Units (CDUs - network-controlled power switches), network KVM (Keyboard-Video-Mouse over Ethernet), Ethernet switches
- genewitch 5y agoA lot of the Motorola radios require ancient software, I have a win98 VM and a win XP VM just to program the old stuff. When I think Motorola I think enterprise, so, another data point.