3 ms·
> 1) coal use went way down since they decided to switch off the nuclear plants. people assume it was replaced by coal, but this is false How is this relevant?
by fsflover 5y ago
> 1) coal use went way down since they decided to switch off the nuclear plants. people assume it was replaced by coal, but this is false
How is this relevant? There is still a lot of coal used and it could be much less if the nuclear was in use.
> 3) phase out of coal was started last year and is on schedule to last until 2038
It's definitely too late for the climate.
- locallost 5y agoIt's relevant because people are assuming otherwise and are stunned that someone would do such a thing that in reality exists only in their imagination. See current top comment: It's absolutely insane they want to shut down Nuclear and replace it with fossil fueled plants False. Simply false.
- fsflover 5y agoTo me it's equivalent. The removed nuclear energy is replaced with coal. It doesn't matter even if overall it's decreasing. It could decrease much more. Actually, it's not even decreasing: https://www.dw.com/en/coal-and-fossil-fuel-share-of-german-electricity-rises-in-3q/a-60114010 https://www.dw.com/en/coal-and-fossil-fuel-share-of-german-e...
- locallost 5y agoNo, coal as a percentage of their electricity production went down from 45% to 25% in 10 years. They removed nuclear and coal and replaced both with renewables (coal is the bottom two). Data: https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/styles/800w400h/public/medien/384/bilder/3_abb_bruttostromerzeugung-et_2021-05-10.png?itok=ePAY3Zf4 https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/styles/80...
- fsflover 5y ago> coal as a percentage of their electricity production went down from 45% to 25% in 10 years. Couldn't it go to 5% by using nuclear?
- locallost 5y agoSee, so as usual we land in goalpost shifting land. First comes the shock that somebody would replace nuclear with coal, but when this is refuted, instead of relief comes further criticism why it's still wrong. I won't bother anymore, since there were other things to consider in the nuclear phase out, and the goalpost shifting will continue until judgement day. I will leave you with a thought: If you wonder how bad Germany is doing, imagine that the US was at 60% fossil fuels 2010, and stayed there 2020. Germany is doing way more for the climate.
- fsflover 5y ago> First comes the shock that somebody would replace nuclear with coal, but when this is refuted No, my original argument was about stronger reduction of coal by using nuclear, no matter that it's already decreasing. You just didn't understand me (or shifted the goalpost?). Upd: I see that you avoid answering this question all the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29768086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29768086.
- locallost 5y agoYou asked why does it matter that coal use is drastically down, when it could be even less. I answered that it's because people don't get that this actually happened, and repeat the opposite of what is true. As proof for this, check the top comment in this thread that makes the false claim nuclear power was replaced by coal. So obviously it is important. Apparently there are enough people to not only write that Germany's coal use went up, but also to upvote it. To this you replied with a link that you did not understand, and again repeated the claim that nuclear was replaced by coal. Quote: "The removed nuclear energy is replaced with coal." False. If the removed nuclear was replaced by coal, coal % of the produced electricity would go up. In reality nuclear % went down, was replaced by renewables, and coal % also went down, also replaced by renewables. As a result of this, carbon emissions are way down, despite the nuclear phase out. Yet another thing that people like to falsely claim. And of course as usual, once we establish what is actually going on, the goal posts get shifted to "well it could be even better". There is nothing to avoid really, my position on that I've posted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29770486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29770486. But don't pretend you're having a rational debate. You don't check the numbers to form an opinion, you google for links to prove your point which is based on the wrong data, don't adjust your opinion when you see the data and instead shift the topic to something else. So there is nothing to discuss there.