4 ms·
In a Parachute-Effectiveness Trial, Who Gets the Placebo?
- niels_olson 18y agoThat BMJ parachute article has made the rounds for years now. I think I last saw it a week or two ago on reddit. I wonder if the Freakonomics guys are now entering the same sort of funk that Merlin of 43 Folders says he's coming out of.
- Protophore 18y agoThe article cited in the NY Times: http://tinyurl.com/6ol8fk http://tinyurl.com/6ol8fk Is a bit absurd. While I agree that in some instances it is beneficial to test drugs without a placebo group, the placebo effect has been demonstrated repeatedly. I can't seem to find a link to the article, but I recall reading one recently in which people were given the same painkiller but told that it the price anywhere from $0.10/pill to $10/pill (or something along those lines). People taking the "expensive" painkillers rated their level of relief much higher than those taking the "cheaper" pill. Sure, in some situations (Cancer, AIDS, etc) we may want to do away with a placebo group, but they are still very useful in many situations.