4 ms·
I think this is overall a good thing. Power users have trained their behaviour to work in the way that simple systems can deal with. While average users ask the
by Gigachad 5y ago
I think this is overall a good thing. Power users have trained their behaviour to work in the way that simple systems can deal with. While average users ask the question exactly how they would ask another human. Google has now reached a level where it works best when you deal with it in a natural and human level.
There is nothing actually better about the way we originally used search engines, it was just required at the time.
- evouga 5y agoNo, I disagree. With keyword search, I am confident that eventually, with enough included and excluded terms, I will find what I’m looking for. With natural language search, sometimes it works great, but it’s a crapshoot and when you don’t get the results you need you’re stuck. Several times in recent memory Google has returned results so bad, I completely gave up searching. Most recently was when i was trying to look up a Windows 11 BSOD error code (where even pasting the error code verbatim only brought up pages of garbage sites with no useful technical information).
- SturgeonsLaw 5y agoGoogle results for Windows error codes have been gamed to hell and back by the likes of Easus and Drivereasy, where their tools are somehow the answer to every single fault Windows could possibly manifest.
- ghusto 5y agoI was ridiculed by my Natural Language Processing professor twenty years ago for exactly this. P: "Pfft. So, what? You think the current state of search is good?! Having to type in keywords instead of just asking a question in normal language?" Me: "... is this a trick question?"
- Mezzie 5y agoI think it's somewhere in the middle. For some queries, being able to ask off the top of your head without thinking is good. Think 'what day of the week was June 14th, 2002?' or 'Who is the mayor of Los Angeles?' For quick questions with clear answers, the current system is a huge advantage over what we had before. For other, more complicated queries, the act of composing your search and considering your keywords, etc. is a step in the process that helps a searcher mentally understand the results they're going to receive along with what they mean. Having to stop and consider makes you aware that you're working within a system and its constraints, which makes it more suitable for questions that are complex or not socially settled. Not all information is the same.