4 ms·
Cromwell?
by Animats 5y ago
Cromwell?
- forgingahead 5y agoFirst example that also came to my (vaguely aware) mind - seems like a clickbait title once again.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThe English seem divided on this, which I do not understand.
- Animats 5y agoThey got rid of the king, but got a dictator instead. After he died, his son took over, botched the job, and was replaced by a king again. France went through something similar. The aftermath of the French Revolution was botched so badly that France got Napoleon. Russia after the breakup of the USSR, Germany after WWI... You screw up a democracy, you get a dictator.
- wavegeek 5y agoBack in Roman times Cicero pointed out that democracy leads to chaos, which leads to tyranny, which leads to monarchy which leads to Aristocracy which leads to democracy. There seem to be a few democracies sliding increasingly into chaos.
- watwut 5y ago> The aftermath of the French Revolution was botched so badly that France got Napoleon. That is fascinating choice of "worst thing to happen after French Revolution" thing. The regime after it was serious literal dictatorships, afaik there was no serious attempt for democracy.
- seanhunter 5y agoI think the division is merely into people who know about British history and people who don't. We had a civil war which ended when we chopped our king's head off and replaced the government. That has to count as a "revolutionary moment" or the phrase has no meaning.
- paganel 5y agoPlus, intellectually speaking movements like the Levellers and the Diggers were way ahead of their time, imho even the French Revolution didn't get to that level when it came to speech related to societal change, they had Babeuf but afaik he wasn't as mainstream, comparatively speaking. I think the radicalness of their speech was only matched on the Continent from the mid-19th century onward.
- timClicks 5y agoIt's worth looking into. That period is why the American military is constitutionally dependent on the legislature. If you will forgive me omitting many important details, Cromwell replaced a monarch and became a military dictator. Militaries and politics shouldn't mix.
- pjc50 5y agoNot really a popular revolution, more of an intra-elite conflict; not rooted in modern concepts of democracy, more in sectarianism; and it didn't "stick". The country reverted to a monarchy after his death. However, Parliament was then resolved to control the monarch - in particular to prevent the monarch ever being politically Catholic. Hence the uneasy toleration of Charles II (Catholic, but hedonist) and eviction of James II. Cromwell is regarded, not unreasonably, as a mass murderer in Ireland.
- ajuc 5y ago> Not really a popular revolution, more of an intra-elite conflict; that's almost always the case, at least at the beginning > Cromwell is regarded, not unreasonably, as a mass murderer in Ireland. most revolutionists are mass murderers
- tragomaskhalos 5y agoFrom a revolutionary perspective, the Diggers and the Levellers were the really interesting players to emerge from the civil war.
- Ericson2314 5y agoTo be clear, I mean "was it a revolution", not "was it a good one".
- duxup 5y agoThat was my thought too, but that era of English history is an absolute tar pit for my American brain. No matter how much I try to understand it I don’t and each time I try I find I start in the same place no matter how often I try.
- gerikson 5y agoThat's me (Swedish, but fluent English reader and interested in UK/European history) when it comes to the American Civil War...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kitd 5y agoSeems a reasonable question. One might say that Cromwell represented one power faction and Charles the other, so it was more a change at the top (albeit a popular one) than a grassroots uprising. It was also an early expression of the Enlightenment. That I think is the real revolution here and around Europe and the Americas around that time. One point of interest is that, after the restoration, many of the ousted Parliamentarians settled in America. To carry on the work as it were!
- billpg 5y agoKing Oliver Ⅰ of the House of Cromwell?
- dghf 5y agoIIRC, the Protectorate Parliament offered him the Crown, but factions of the Army made it clear he would not survive should he accept.
- hardlianotion 5y agoLord Protector. Not entirely clear to me how his power differed from that of a king.