4 ms·
Sure, there's no density-based law, but you could just make the fire egress rules onerous and there'd be an army of disingenuous people arguing that you don't c
by renewiltord 5y ago
Sure, there's no density-based law, but you could just make the fire egress rules onerous and there'd be an army of disingenuous people arguing that you don't care about safety. Here's a quick one: every building under 3 stories must have two independent egress mechanisms, for every story taller they must have one additional egress path per story.
Done.
There are no loopholes for you because you are not a friend. The system intentionally is all based on human to human trust because that allows complete discretion, and therefore abuse. You can't rules lawyer it. They will simply wait you out because they pick the wait period and they're paid to wait and you pay to wait.
- kevinburke 5y agoMy understanding (not legal advice!) is rules that preclude development at a given density would not be enforceable especially if they deviate from e.g. the International Builders Code, unless you could make some case that Davis was uniquely susceptible to fires, which it isn’t. Like Los Altos Hills could mandate that new apartments be covered in real gold, but they don’t do that.
- zbrozek 5y agoNo, but we have plenty of other policies designed to prevent construction. Like having needlessly complicated and subjective lot coverage rules where simple objective ones would work fine. Or nerfing SB-9. Our town government also extorts conservation easements out of folks in exchange for permits. I've been struggling for two years just to fix a leaky roof. When my town fails to get an approved Housing Element, I'll probably build condos out of spite. And move to a red state so I have some property rights and better ROI on taxes.
- defen 5y agoThe state government is pretty explicitly anti-NIMBY / pro-density (relatively speaking) right now, so bad-faith attempts to restrict growth like that might not go over well.
- renewiltord 5y agoI doubt the state government has any real power. My city just banned housing development on a valet parking lot saying it would cause gentrification.
- shuckles 5y agoIf you’re referring to San Francisco, the city is on track to be sued under state law for that denial. It is also being investigated by the state for it.
- renewiltord 5y agoI’m sure they’ll back off around the time the developer has spent too much money to make the project viable. In fact, I’ll do you one better. I’ll bet $1k that two years from now, no residential building will exist on that lot.
- danans 5y ago> Here's a quick one: every building under 3 stories must have two independent egress mechanisms, for every story taller they must have one additional egress path per story. In that case they would just have to ban buildings over three stories, no strange egress requirements needed. That would in turn get tested against state laws. No doubt there are plenty of anti-density regulations on the books, like cities with minimum lot sizes in the SF Peninsula, but it would be challenging to pass those regulations now in California.
- twblalock 5y agoThe classic move, not just in California but everywhere, is a lawsuit about the "environmental impact" of the project on some kind of local wildlife. Davis has a somewhat famous precedent for that too: https://localwiki.org/davis/Toad_Tunnel https://localwiki.org/davis/Toad_Tunnel
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> on some kind of local wildlife Wildlife?? Oh sure, "environmental impact" can be about wildlife and the environment, but it could also be as minimal as traffic patterns and aesthetics. That's why just about anyone can get in on the California environmental review process and go through several rounds of delays in hopes of extorting something from you, and a key reason California has trouble building anything. On the other hand, "omg! birds running into the windows!" is as good a start as any.
- zbrozek 5y agoCEQA needs to be repealed. It seems to have accidentally acquired scope far beyond what its writers intended.
- MarkSweep 5y agoAt least for the "complete discretion", California has the "Housing Accountability Act", which roughly says cities have 60 days to approve developments that contain 20% low-income housing. If they deny it, it must be for an "objective, quantifiable, written development" policy. It's not much, requiring cities to have their housing rules written down ahead of time. But it is enough the organizations like CaRLA are having some success suing cities for capriciously denying housing. https://carlaef.org/category/legal-action/housing-accountability-act/ https://carlaef.org/category/legal-action/housing-accountabi...