3 ms·
The article casually equates gain to change in "power or amplitude of a signal." While not wrong per se, this is one of the drawbacks of using lay references i
by CamperBob2 5y ago
The article casually equates gain to change in "power or amplitude of a signal." While not wrong per se, this is one of the drawbacks of using lay references in specific fields. Power and amplitude mean the same thing to 99% of people, but they are not the same thing at all. Amplitude is measured in volts, while power is measured in watts. Voltage doesn't do work, convey information, or obey conservation laws; power does.
As a result, when engineers refer to gain in voltage alone, they will (or should) go out of their way to use the term "voltage gain." Otherwise it's a power ratio, in which the denominator is typically a given number of watts or the power present at the feedpoint of a hypothetical isotropic antenna.
Antenna people rarely care about voltage gain outside the context of impedance matching or regulatory matters. Voltage is useful when discussing field strength in volts per meter, but at the end of the day, the antenna engineer's job is to deliver power, not voltage. (Also, to avoid embarrassing Steve Jobs.)
- SigmundA 5y agoYou casually provide nothing contradictory to what I have stated and have multiple times dismissed power gain in antennas, electronic amplifiers have electronic gain, antennas have gain not dependent on electronic amplification, gain is the correct word. With antennas it is power gain not voltage gain, but gain non the less, thank you for confirming GAIN is the correct term in the most ridiculous concession possible...WTF.
- CamperBob2 5y agoSounds good, best of luck in your studies.