4 ms·
It's also much heavier and much more expensive. This really isn't a breakthrough more than it is a special case optimization. Any new design could easily have
by ajross 5y ago
It's also much heavier and much more expensive. This really isn't a breakthrough more than it is a special case optimization. Any new design could easily have accommodated a similar capacity battery with traditional construction just by making the car 2cm taller or whatever.
I mean, lithium batteries are already pretty space-efficient. This kind of optimization surely has a home in some application (to be clear: it already does in consumer electronics!). I'm just not sure cars are where it's best applied.
- vmception 5y agodoes the weight impact anything consequential? I guess perhaps acceleration and handling? But I'm not sure the article went into that I just want a car that does what is described, ideally without other tradeoffs. I would consider paying a premium for that, to an extent. I mean Tesla has been teasing Roadsters w/ 600 miles per charge at $250,000 for 5 years now. So someone just do the thing and make the option.
- serf 5y agoweight impacts everything; acceleration, handling, braking performance, brake wear , tire wear, road wear, generally increased NVH if the weight gain isn't part of the superstructure, drive train loads, consumable suspension (bushings/wear items) wear .. the list goes on, but you get the point. it's all a cost/benefit ratio between duration/range/cost/marketability/reliability ; you can take care of the technical issues behind weight gain, but is there still a market there once you do and the cost to produce skyrockets?
- fragmede 5y agoIs range consequential to you? The battery pack's already quite heavy (>1,200 lbs) and it takes both power and energy to move that much weight around. The bigger the pack, the more of both it takes to move it. The 100 kWh battery already gets 400 miles per charge. Doubling the battery pack with existing technology isn't going to get double the range. At some point there are diminishing returns where adding more batteries reduces the range due to the added weight. Also keep in mind that with an electric car, most users will use a home charger and start each day at full charge (even the slow charger can manage this if you're getting enough sleep). At the article's state 55 mph to get their range, it would take just over 7 hours of driving to go 400 miles. That's plenty for daily, non-fleet use.
- vmception 5y agoI don't want double, I want 20-25% more. That will cover all my edge cases.
- cnasc 5y ago> does the weight impact anything consequential? Kinetic energy. That could make collisions more dangerous (though I’m not sure by how much)
- joe-collins 5y agoNumbers: Tesla Model S: 4600 lbs (Original battery: 1323 lbs) https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-s-weight/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-s-weight/ Gemini Battery: additional 730 lbs https://www.carhp.com/news/one-s-prototype-battery-registers-a-range-of-752-miles-on-the-tesla-model-s https://www.carhp.com/news/one-s-prototype-battery-registers...
- iramiller 5y agoCurious if they bothered to comply with the GVWR for the vehicle. An extra 730lbs is most of the typical payload capacity for a typical car. The model S has a GVWR of 5600lbs and weighs about 4600lbs meaning you can only put about 1000lbs of stuff in/on it safely. With this extra battery weight there isn’t enough capacity left to carry more that two typical adults let alone any luggage.
- serverholic 5y agoIt's almost like Tesla has to optimize for more than just raw battery performance.
- thedrbrian 5y ago>1323 & 730 lb Jeeez. That’s almost the curb weight of my Miata.
- hiptobecubic 5y agoBut, interestingly, miata's get pretty boring fuel economy given their size. I'd call it downright bad if you're looking at earlier models.
- ksec 5y agoThx. I guess they were only interested in cars and not battery. Hence the article was rather poor. I was thinking where are you getting these data from as the article doesn't include much information. Some reply below showed added 700Lb to the car.