4 ms·
Like I pointed out in the sister thread about EU telcos: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29875805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29875805 Phone car
by rcarmo 5y ago
Like I pointed out in the sister thread about EU telcos:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29875805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29875805
Phone carriers do not want to be a dumb pipe - and having Private Relay go through their networks breaks:
- HTTP header enrichment (which they use for self-care/customer sites/services),
- zero rating (which they set up deals for with social networks, music streaming services, etc., often applying specific QoS tags) and
- all sorts of value added services (many using deep packet inspection and DNS analytics) that they offer instead of raw, unfettered connectivity.
I don't think many people are aware of exactly how much data telcos are sitting on, anonymized or not.
And, of course, it also plays havoc with legal interception because there is no easy way to do MITM.
(edit: readability)
- Spooky23 5y agoMITM is pretty moot right now with TLS everywhere. Apple is taking this stand because it’s inline with their business. Zero-rating is really bad for Apple. And by making themselves the virtual network layer, they have the ability to roll out their own last mile networks later.
- r-w 5y agoTo be fair, you could make the same argument that TLS is moot because everything at the other layers (routing, application, and even hardware) is extremely vulnerable to attack. MITM is still a very real thing. If anything makes it moot, it's not other technology; it's social engineering attacks.
- paxys 5y agoThe point of TLS is that every bit of network infrastructure could be compromised but your connection would still be secure as long as your own device and the end server (and the cert authority) remained clean.
- oflannabhra 5y agoOne big difference in the US is that most telcos also have ad businesses, and this will negatively impact them.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThis is more about selling data to aggregators.
- lstamour 5y agoI doubt long term that it causes much havoc with three letter agencies. If anything, it simplifies it a small bit because now they can look at the records of only two intermediaries, Apple and the CDNs they use. That said, why go to the trouble? Depending on how it's configured, Apple would already likely be tracking your browser history in iCloud, backups, etc. Plus websites that track user activity (e.g. have logins) can be asked directly for data.
- nathanyz 5y agoExactly, carriers really don't want anything that helps push net neutrality in any real way. They don't want to be commoditized to where it's just pipe for Internet data to transmit through as you mentioned.
- 88840-8855 5y agoI have been working through some consulting activities with 8 telcos over the past years on the topic BiG DaTa. While it is true that telcos have data, ALL of the telcos I have worked with lack the capability to do ANYTHING with that data. First, they dont get the right people, because good people dont go to telco. Second, they have super fragmented stacks, especially in markets that have consolidated over the years. Third, they simply dont have figures out ANY business model for that data (except some We SeLl LoCaTiOn DaTa To GoVeRnMenTs that is illegal in most Western countries anyway by now). So... all this "TELCO SOOO BAD BECAUSE ALL MY DATA THEY EAT" talking is laughable to me after seeing the truth. I am surprised what people here in HN think of the capabilities of telcos. Edit: as I saw some comments below on "three letter agencies". Fun fact, ALL the 8 telcos that I have experienced hat guys from the local "three letter agencies" working there to detect crime stuff.
- jeroenhd 5y agoIs this really about EU telcos, though? In the European article I mostly see messages about this from UK telcos, which are European but no EU anymore. I've heard that UK net neutrality law is kind of a joke, and now that they're outside of EU control the UK can do whatever the hell it wants, and I fear for UK citizens that the mostly consumer-focused EU ideals aren't shared by the current UK leadership. Plenty of telcos want to force competitors out of the market with zero rating and triple play subscriptions, but I don't think any of them have made any moves against net neutrality this bad. A few years ago I've seen carriers doing HTTP introspection to force images through their compression proxies (usually budget ISPs who want to stop people from actually using up their data plan so they can make a profit) but that seems to have stopped completely now. As for legal interception, this doesn't make any difference. When law enforcement finds that the suspects are communicating over Apple's network, they'll just knock on Apple's door with a warrant and demand a wire tap from their network. That's how legal interception of "privacy protection" VPN providers works, and Apple isn't even trying to ship traffic outside national borders, just to the closest data center.
- Tijdreiziger 5y ago> Is this really about EU telcos, though? From that article: > Via The Telegraph, operators including Vodafone, Telefonica and T-Mobile signed an open letter voicing their opposition to the rollout of the feature. Those are each large telcos with operations in a multitude of countries.
- jyrkesh 5y agoShouldn't those all be true of ISPs too, though? Why are telcos different? Is it just because they need stricter QoS because of airwaves vs. cables? Do you think that argument still holds water in a post-5G-saturated world?
- kaba0 5y agoI am pretty bad with networks, but isn’t most of the http traffic https nowadays? How can they do header enrichment and the others, then? Isn’t that the purpose of https to forbid that? The only thing they are supposed to see is the target domain.
- yokoprime 5y agoThere is very little room for EU telcos to do any sort of inspection of packets, beyond maybe identifying if its streaming traffic or regular traffic (there are some subscriptions which give you free streaming traffic). Storing personal information is a big no-no, and anyone can at any time request a dump of all identifyable information a telco has about you. While I understand that private relay will give telcos less actional information, its not that much to work with to begin with.