5 ms·
> It's a race to the bottom, but is there a realistic solution that still provides choice and opportunity to both men and women? The core of the race to the bo
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> It's a race to the bottom, but is there a realistic solution that still provides choice and opportunity to both men and women?
The core of the race to the bottom is artificial scarcity.
You need a house, another family needs a house, there is only one house. If they have two incomes and you don't, they get the house, but it costs them the second income. Better solution: Build another house. Then you can have one without a second income and they can spend the second income on vacations or something. But we have zoning restrictions prohibiting that, hence the problem.
That's the biggest example, but artificial scarcity exists in other places. Education is a big one. For K-12, get school vouchers and stop tying it to housing costs -- that will also help with housing costs.
Make more of stuff instead of forcing people to outbid each other for artificially constrained supply and the extra income becomes extra income instead of the baseline you need in order to stand still.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>Make more of stuff instead of forcing people to outbid each other for artificially constrained supply and the extra income becomes extra income instead of the baseline you need in order to stand still. While I agree with the gist of your comment, the reality is that humans create artificial scarcity regardless of actually supply in many scenarios. The want to compete is deeply ingrained in the mating process, and it inevitably manifests as participants of society outbidding each other for something.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoSo let the artificial scarcity be in vapid signaling bullshit instead of necessities you actually need to live and thrive. Look at me, I have more expensive art than you. Your car is efficient and reliable but mine costs three times more and has the right logo. Better yet, I donate more to charity than you. Competition for true scarcity is fine. Competition for artificial scarcity deserves to burn.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat competition is at least partly responsible for the zoning laws. The standard real estate advice is to buy the cheapest house in the most expensive neighborhood you can afford, so that your kids can be surrounded by kids of parents of better means and resources, thereby strengthening their network.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's kind of the point. We can shape what the competition looks like by changing the zoning laws and not tying schools to housing. The competition will then move somewhere else, but the somewhere else could be more efficient, i.e. it sends more money to schools or charities or artists rather than inflating a housing bubble and making housing unaffordable.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOh, I see. The only problem with that is the current non dense US suburban design makes it so the distance to school has a huge effect on quality of life, and I wonder if many neighborhoods would be dense enough to be able to support multiple schools serving multiple levels of incomes. Because if not, then that brings back the same incentive to only live near those at or above your level.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe lack of density in the suburbs is a consequence of the zoning. Higher density housing is the thing that's prohibited, so allowing it would address that. > Because if not, then that brings back the same incentive to only live near those at or above your level. But then what happens if there is no constraint on building higher density housing? More people want to live near the good school, so housing prices are higher there, which causes higher density housing go up there and the housing supply increases until prices come back down. That doesn't happen now because the zoning doesn't allow higher density housing to be built there. They'd probably find a way to gate access to schools other than housing costs, e.g. testing for which test prep courses improve outcomes, something like that. But it would stop making housing unaffordable.
- jimbob45 5y agoVirtually every part of your argument has been empirically disproven by evidence. We would be much better off banning AirBNB and rentals to return supply to the market rather than building more to throw away as “luxury rentals”. - Vouchers don’t work. The vast majority of parents don’t have time to shuttle their kid(s) outside of their district. - Removing housing prices from school funding was such a disaster in California that they reversed the policy - You cannot build more housing in major cities which is where the vast majority of people want to work. There is no more space. We used it all on housing. - Making more doesn’t help anyone as long as foreign investors are allowed to come in, buy it up, and effectively remove it from the real estate market by turning it into an AirBNB (to say nothing of Zillow inflating prices beyond affordability to begin with).
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Vouchers don’t work. The vast majority of parents don’t have time to shuttle their kid(s) outside of their district. So put a drop off point in each district where a bus takes everyone from there to a school in another district. Or build more, smaller schools so they compete with each other without being far away from each other. > Removing housing prices from school funding was such a disaster in California that they reversed the policy Politics was involved. > You cannot build more housing in major cities which is where the vast majority of people want to work. There is no more space. We used it all on housing. We know how to build hundred story buildings. No city on earth is comprised entirely of hundred story buildings. We can build more housing anywhere. > Making more doesn’t help anyone as long as foreign investors are allowed to come in, buy it up, and effectively remove it from the real estate market by turning it into an AirBNB (to say nothing of Zillow inflating prices beyond affordability to begin with). People do this because they predict housing prices to increase in the future. They predict housing prices to increase in the future because they predict that zoning will constrain sufficient housing from being built. Build enough housing that prices actually go down and see how many speculators it attracts.
- fallingknife 5y ago> You cannot build more housing in major cities which is where the vast majority of people want to work. There is no more space. We used it all on housing. The only place in the entire US where you possibly make this argument is Manhattan.
- majormajor 5y agoI completely disagree. This happened even to demographics where essentially everyone already had a house. But your neighbor has a pool. But your other neighbor has a Range Rover. But your OTHER other neighbor has a sweet home theater. There's a huge gap between 'basic food and shelter needs met' and what people will compete for.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> This happened even to demographics where essentially everyone already had a house. Because you're not just competing with people in the same demographic. Suppose you used to be able to afford a house on your single income, but only just. Now a family with two workers who each make 60% of what you make you show up and outbid you on the house you'd have bought, because together they make 20% more money than you. You just got priced out of a house unless you too get a second income. > But your neighbor has a pool. And that's not a problem. If you want to go from being a housewife to working for money so that you and your husband can have a house with a pool and a Range Rover and a sweet home theater, more power to you. If that's what was happening, we can make more pools and more Range Rovers and more home theaters -- and there would be more labor to do it with. As long as anybody who just wants the house and doesn't want to be forced into a change in lifestyle, could still get the house. But then a family with two incomes outbids you and when nobody is allowed to make enough houses for both families, that is no longer true.