3 ms·
> Freedom (or possibility of) for women, at least in some sense from their spouse/family. Does this actually work against the two income trap? Before you need
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Freedom (or possibility of) for women, at least in some sense from their spouse/family.
Does this actually work against the two income trap?
Before you needed one income, so a woman not allowed to work had to find a new man before she could cut loose a bad one.
Now you need two incomes, so a woman who has to work in order to provide one of the incomes has to find a new man before she can cut loose a bad one. And has less time to find one because she's working 40 hours on top of everything she used to do in the home.
Sometimes progress doesn't know which way the arrow is pointing.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoPerhaps for the women at the bottom of the pay scales, but an average or above average earning woman should be able to downgrade quality of life and still "cut loose". Progress for some portion of society can be a regression for others. There is no question that I would rather live in a world where my daughter had just as much opportunity as my son to be a doctor or start her own business or whatever she wants to do. The possible cost of this reality is that the variance of family life across society will increase, with those at the bottom experiencing a quality of life worse than they would have had if society did not offer women the freedom to pair up with similarly advantaged men and compound their benefits.
- watwut 5y agoDomestic violence rates went down significantly by all estimates. Also, they in fact go up and down with female employment - when women loose work they go up, when they get it they go down. > Now you need two incomes, so a woman who has to work in order to provide one of the incomes has to find a new man before she can cut loose a bad one This is simply not true. People break up a lot. Real world people sometimes stay with bad partners for money reasons, but employed ones significantly less so. The "I can't leave because I have no job" is a thing tho.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Domestic violence rates went down significantly by all estimates. Also, they in fact go up and down with female employment - when women loose work they go up, when they get it they go down. https://xkcd.com/2560/ https://xkcd.com/2560/ A plausible theory is that things that improve the economy reduce both domestic violence and [female] unemployment. Or maybe it's what you said. Or maybe it's something else. No way to tell because correlational studies are worthless. > This is simply not true. People break up a lot. I think lotsofpulp has it on this one. It's a real benefit to women who make good money, because they can actually leave. It makes things worse for women with low pay or no job, because it makes things cost more, which makes it harder to survive on your own and exhausts the resources of non-rich friends or shelters.
- watwut 5y agoTo first paragraph, no. Male employment going in did not lowered domestic violence. Only female. Male employment going down compared to female did lowered it. Simply, if that person materially depends on another, he (or she tbh) is less likely to be abusive or violent ton the source of money. Statistically, poor people divorce more often. Middle class and rich people have more stable marriages, actually. Poor and lower class women still leave relationships. Both partners then go to live with parents, friend or to even worst housing.