3 ms·
> If my "geometric intuition" is working properly, the "problem" is that the figure in the picture wouldn't meet in a point. There would be a line at the top, a
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> If my "geometric intuition" is working properly, the "problem" is that the figure in the picture wouldn't meet in a point. There would be a line at the top, and it wouldn't be a pyramid. But there's nothing "impossible" about that.
The proof given in the article seems fine. Assuming the figure has three flat faces, the arrangement of those faces is impossible. A figure such as you describe, with a line on the top, would not be ruled out by the proof, but the depicted figure cannot match that description.
For a quick summary-style restatement of the proof:
1. Consider the three sides (as opposed to the top and bottom) of the shape to be flat. Each of them will come to a separate point. Those three points are labeled G, H, and I.
2. We can easily show that the point G lies in the same plane as each side of the shape. We can symmetrically show that this is also true of H and of I.
3. When G, H, and I are the same point, this doesn't restrict the sides in any meaningful way - no matter what the "angles" of three planes are, you can always translate them such that they'll all intersect at an arbitrary point.
4. But when G, H, and I are all different points, there is only a single plane that contains them all. ("Three points determine a plane".) This tells us that the three faces of such a shape would all be coplanar, which obviously can't happen.
-----
(5. You are positing that, for example, G and H might coincide while I is a different, second point. But the depicted figure doesn't satisfy that description.)
- thaumasiotes 5y agoTry approaching the problem from another direction: imagine you're positioning three planes (which will form the side faces of the truncated pyramid, but imagine infinite planes). How would you position them so that they didn't come to a single point? It can't be done; the first two planes will form an infinitely long "trough" in more or less the shape of a Λ (well, an X, but we're only interested in the part below the intersection), and then, wherever the third plane cuts through, you have the single point that a three-sided pyramid requires.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> It can't be done Cheeky: it can, but they must be parallel.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoGood luck positioning parallel planes to form the sides of a pyramid. ;D