3 ms·

This ignores the effort each studio would need to do, in perpetuity, to render hat tokens in their game's engine and art style. Eventually there would be so man

This ignores the effort each studio would need to do, in perpetuity, to render hat tokens in their game's engine and art style. Eventually there would be so many years of hat tokens that game studios would either have to draw a thousand hats just to launch, or abandon older hats. Which would devalue them and scare off future hat token prospectors.

Buttons840 5y ago
Imagine the outrage when a gamer learns his $1,000 silly hat won't render in the latest horror game.
alkonaut 5y ago
You grab the hats of the players that are actually in the game (i.e. only the ones you need to render). Custom graphics like decals have been a thing for decades. It's not much harder for clients to download a hat model as e.g. an fbx, than it was to download a sprayed decal in counter strike 20 years ago. The actual buying and selling of hats doesn't need to take place in the game.
- somehnacct3757 5y ago
  You misunderstand my use of render. I don't mean render during gameplay; I mean turn an abstract idea, like an NFT for a bull horn hat, into a 3d or 2d asset that aligns with the art direction of the game. There's no chance for asset reuse across games. Not only do the asset file formats differ from game engine to game engine (or platform to platform) they also differ perspectively, aesthetically, and thematically. Madden 2023 has incentive to sell NFT assets for sports jerseys. And Elder Scrolls 6, NFTs for wizard robes. But render those assets in the other game and they will look out of place. Even two games with wizards in them will have different aesthetics, mostly to differentiate in the marketplace!
  - alkonaut 5y ago
    No I mean that games that do this would literally allow frog-hats and butterfly hats regardless of genre and art direction. They’d then obviously need to be able to import the asset and render it on player’s heads and that’s it. If it doesn’t fit the renderer exactly then it’ll look out of place, badly lit etc. But that’s exactly like hats already are in these game. They are out-of-place, ugly assets. The hat-games some times even seem deliberate directed in a style that seems to be for the purpose of allowing a wider variety of art without looking too off (e.g. Fortnite).

Buttons840 5y ago

Imagine the outrage when a gamer learns his $1,000 silly hat won't render in the latest horror game.

alkonaut 5y ago

You grab the hats of the players that are actually in the game (i.e. only the ones you need to render). Custom graphics like decals have been a thing for decades. It's not much harder for clients to download a hat model as e.g. an fbx, than it was to download a sprayed decal in counter strike 20 years ago. The actual buying and selling of hats doesn't need to take place in the game.

somehnacct3757 5y ago
You misunderstand my use of render. I don't mean render during gameplay; I mean turn an abstract idea, like an NFT for a bull horn hat, into a 3d or 2d asset that aligns with the art direction of the game. There's no chance for asset reuse across games. Not only do the asset file formats differ from game engine to game engine (or platform to platform) they also differ perspectively, aesthetically, and thematically. Madden 2023 has incentive to sell NFT assets for sports jerseys. And Elder Scrolls 6, NFTs for wizard robes. But render those assets in the other game and they will look out of place. Even two games with wizards in them will have different aesthetics, mostly to differentiate in the marketplace!
- alkonaut 5y ago
  No I mean that games that do this would literally allow frog-hats and butterfly hats regardless of genre and art direction. They’d then obviously need to be able to import the asset and render it on player’s heads and that’s it. If it doesn’t fit the renderer exactly then it’ll look out of place, badly lit etc. But that’s exactly like hats already are in these game. They are out-of-place, ugly assets. The hat-games some times even seem deliberate directed in a style that seems to be for the purpose of allowing a wider variety of art without looking too off (e.g. Fortnite).