4 ms·
Random ideas for improving HN voting
1. Public 'flags'.
What would people think if their flagging of an article were made public? It surely wouldn't stop people flagging very off topic or spam posts, but perhaps it would limit other forms of flagging ('this author annoys me', 'this is about a language I hate').
2. A downvote quota.
Suppose you had unlimited upvotes, but a limit number (say 5) downvotes per day. I'd hope people would choose to use them wisely
- thaumaturgy 15y agoAs a semi-frequent flagger, I could appreciate #1. It would be nice to be able to publicly state disapproval of a thing without having to clutter up the comments section. Re: #2, I don't really see the point. Downvotes here just aren't a problem. Most of the items that are a light shade of grey are deserving of it, and even then, given the size of HN's user base now and the score required to make something a nice light shade of gray, I don't think limiting daily downvotes would have any measurable effect at all.
- mooism2 15y agoI'm another frequent flagger. I'm not sure that I would get any benefit from publicly stating disapproval without also stating why I disapprove. I think the problem with flagging is more that it's too easy for a link to pick up enough flags to keep it off the front page --- imo, if a link hasn't picked up enough flags to kill it, it hasn't picked up enough flags to disqualify it from the front page. (Re #2, I agree with you.)
- revorad 15y agoI don't know how the current flagging system works, but dealing with it in a slightly more intelligent way could reduce the number of false positives. Some basic filtering based on obviously spammy links, domains, language could be used. For flagged posts which aren't caught by such a spam filter, let the total number of flags decide. Right now it seems that it only takes a couple of flags to push a story off the front page.