3 ms·
USB-D ought to need to pass this test before release: Dip both plug and socket in water, sand, pocket lint, soil, and cat fur. Plug in cable Wiggle a bunch,
by londons_explore 5y ago
USB-D ought to need to pass this test before release:
Dip both plug and socket in water, sand, pocket lint, soil, and cat fur.
Plug in cable
Wiggle a bunch, tug the cable in a few random directions.
Disconnect, then repeat the process 10,000 times.
If the plug and socket still work correctly after that, then it's a good socket design. If not, it is insufficiently robust and the designers should redesign.
- mcv 5y agoWasn't one of the goals of the micro-USB plug that if anything failed, it should always be the plug and never the socket? That's always sounded like a sensible approach to me. Of course I'd rather not have anything fail, and yeah, micro-USB plugs do seem to break a bit too easily, but they're easier to replace than a socket.
- londons_explore 5y agoThe sockets also break though. The plastic 'tongue' in the middle snaps off and then it doesn't work at all.
- dTal 5y agoI've long held that USB should have been TRRS (like headphones) from the beginning - compact, physically robust, rotationally symmetric, and very very easy to plug in. I've heard two objections to this - packet loss caused by intermittent contact from the connector rotating while plugged in, and the requirement to make the system resilient to transient shorts while being plugged and unplugged. Neither seems like a serious engineering challenge, in light of the reliability and user interface fiasco that pretty much every USB connector has been so far until USB-C.