9 ms·
Novak Djokovic wins appeal as Australian court quashes visa cancellation
- crimsonnoodle58 5y agoNovak Djokovic, unvaccinated, was deemed a risk to public health by the Australian government. Ironically, Nick Kyrgios, double vaccinated, just tested positive to COVID and has vowed he'll still be playing in the Open next week.
- daniel-s 5y agoIt's important to clarify. He was promised entry by the government then only had his visa cancelled on arrival after the political climate changed.
- qayxc 5y ago> He was promised entry by the government Clarification: It was Tennis Australia who told him he could play, not the Australian government.
- pomdapi 5y agoHis medical file was reviewed by the governement's own Australian Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation (ATAGI) for COVID-19, and a state of Victoria medical review board set up to review such cases. He took two test before taking off from Belgrade, and then in Dubai. Then, based on that, the Australian embassy delivered a visa for his entry on Australian territory. That visa was then rescinded by a deputy assistant directly under the Minister of Foreign affairs after his plane from Dubai took off. So "the government" all the way, no Tennis Australia in sight.
- sofixa 5y agoAn advisory body and a state authority are not "the government" of a federal country like Australia.
- pomdapi 5y agoWait, you are saying that the ATAGI for COVID-19, which was set up directly under the Minister of Health as part of the Federal Department of Health to advise and adjucate on everything immunity and vaccination related, who has produced all the current stringent Australian Covid rules, is somehow NOT part of the federal government ? They have litterally made the rules, and are sometimes delegated to adjudicate on specific cases. Checking that would have taken you exactly 5 seconds. It's litterally on their web page header, but in their statutes as well.
- infamia 5y agoHe was granted a visa to enter Australia, and then they suddenly canceled his visa. This stinks of politics. https://abcnews.go.com/International/djokovic-courts-controversy-tennis-star-granted-medical-exemption/story?id=82086762 https://abcnews.go.com/International/djokovic-courts-controv...
- grujicd 5y agoI might be a bit naive, but IMO if a country organizes an international sports event it should be held responsible to accept all qualified athletes. And if there is an official invitation, there should be no questions asked at the border. Either that, or don't organize event at all if you have some concerns. Leaving to individual athletes to navigate country's ever changing visa rules is not fair or realistic. Even lawyers on Australian law subredit couldn't tell for sure how judge will rule in Djokovic's case and which laws and statutes should be taken into account and which have precedence. This is not only about Djokovic. It's also about tennis players who received Sputnik vaccine and couldn't go to Australia Open. Yet we have numbers from few non-Russia countries which tell us it's in the similarly effective as other vaccines. Also, I'm not talking about tennis and Australia only, too many times athletes were stopped from competing because of politics and it never seems fair.
- mjbeswick 5y agoHe probably presents a very low risk; it's more the principle of not making exceptions to the rules for someone entering the country just to play tennis. Couldn't he make the whole problem go away by just getting vaccinated!?
- crimsonnoodle58 5y ago> Couldn't he make the whole problem go away by just getting vaccinated!? What would he gain from that? He has natural antibodies from prior infection, and the vaccine very clearly does not stop, or reduce, transmission (in the light of Omicron).
- sofixa 5y agoAs i said elsewhere here, he's probably lying about his prior infection: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29873187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29873187
- Andys 5y agoin Australia, a positive PCR test is a contraindication for vaccination for 6 months.
- sofixa 5y agoHe's probably lying about that one. On the very next day after he was supposedly tested positive there are photos of him, without any mask or social distancing, at a public event in Serbia. So either he's lying or a giant asshole ( which isn't out of the question from what we've seen).
- Const-me 5y agoThe COVIC pandemic is global and universal, but people responding differently. I’m not from Serbia but I live nearby, speak pretty much the same language, and culturally Montenegro is very close. Over here, many people are generally skeptical towards media, and most people are skeptical towards statements of our own government. Due to such cultural traits, public perception of COVID is rather diverse here. For instance, despite vaccines are freely available for almost a year now (I think I got a first vaccine shot in April 2021), only about 50% of population (myself included) are vaccinated. Just because Đoković attended a public event after testing positive doesn’t mean he’s lying about the test. He might simply think it’s not a huge deal. Maybe he’s a bit careless, but I think “giant asshole” wording is too strong. Other people attending the event were adults fully aware of COVID pandemic, they were free to skip the event, they were free to wear masks if they wanted. Also, there’s lots of research showing that positive COVID test doesn’t mean the person is infectious. For instance [0] says “people can continue to test positive for up to 3 months after diagnosis and not be infectious to others… the amount of live virus in the nose and throat drops significantly soon after COVID-19 symptoms develop” [0] https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/s0814-updated-isolation-guidance.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/s0814-updated-isolat...
- e-clinton 5y agoRules are rules… unless of course you have money to pay for expensive lawyers.
- exodust 5y agoHappy to hear our government must pay Novak's court costs. The manner he was detained was clumsy and disrespectful, and makes Australia look bad. The politicians down here are about optics and spin. Political blame games are the national sport, not cricket. The media loves a villain to target. Outrage is currency. Drummed up, spoon-fed. If Novak tests negative multiple times, that's enough to confirm he is safe. Omicron spreads extremely easily among vaccinated people, as we know. Vaccination status is therefore not a significant variable in transmission risk. The charade of Novak being a "risk", is misinformation. On Australian breakfast TV yesterday, a presenter said "think about the ball boys and girls who are at risk from Novak". This misinformation spreads to anxious viewers, who are accepting of information when it's framed in a public health crisis context. Novak had Covid before. In Australia the guidelines are to wait 6 months to get vaccinated after infection. But the main thing is, when someone doesn't want the vaccine, their decision should be respected if they're willing to comply with tests and masks and other measures.
- omegabravo 5y agoThere are other benefits to the vaccine other than reducing spread. They of course are not quite as effective against Omicron, but they are still there. With the testing infrastructure beyond capacity (some samples have expired before getting tested), I don't think catering to people who chose not to get vaccinated right now is a good idea. This will of course change as the pandemic further develops in Australia, but the rules as they are written at the moment make sense. Australia doesn't need to be importing further risk to its health care system already at capacity. Absolutely clumsy performance from the government and they should have to answer for this show.
- exodust 5y ago> There are other benefits to the vaccine other than reducing spread. Omicron spreads easily among the vaccinated. Any "reduced spread" is negligible. The only other benefit is reduced severity of illness. Most over 60s and vulnerable in Australia have had the vaccine. That leaves the unvaccinated group as mostly younger, healthy and significantly less likely to need hospital care. They are not a risk or burden. They get mild symptoms, recover soon after, and now have natural immunity. > importing further risk There's statistically no risk. An unvaccinated person who tests negative is not a transmission risk or an illness risk. This is where we're at with Omicron. Your suggestion to discriminate against those not vaccinated, doesn't add up.
- FartyMcFarter 5y agoWhat I'm curious about is: how had he been planning to get into Australia before he happened to get infected with Covid on December 16? I can think of a few possible answers, but none that are both a) legit and b) make a lot of sense.