6 ms·
Did Britain Ever Have a Revolutionary Moment?
- JdeBP 5y agoAlthough Betteridge's Law of question headlines suggests "No.", I think that the executive summary is 'In our poll, 3 of these 4 historians answered "Yes, it did.".'. (-:
- djohnston 5y agoPeasant revolt sparked off by some knobhead tax collector raping women definitely counts.
- Ericson2314 5y agoI don't understand why the first answer is even controversial. Sure the 17th century was a violent shit-show for everyone, but the commonwealth stuff really raise more existential questions does it not? Anyways, Dutch Revolt -> English civil wars, American revolution -> French revolution seems pretty clear.
- Animats 5y agoCromwell?
- forgingahead 5y agoFirst example that also came to my (vaguely aware) mind - seems like a clickbait title once again.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThe English seem divided on this, which I do not understand.
- Animats 5y agoThey got rid of the king, but got a dictator instead. After he died, his son took over, botched the job, and was replaced by a king again. France went through something similar. The aftermath of the French Revolution was botched so badly that France got Napoleon. Russia after the breakup of the USSR, Germany after WWI... You screw up a democracy, you get a dictator.
- wavegeek 5y agoBack in Roman times Cicero pointed out that democracy leads to chaos, which leads to tyranny, which leads to monarchy which leads to Aristocracy which leads to democracy. There seem to be a few democracies sliding increasingly into chaos.
- watwut 5y ago> The aftermath of the French Revolution was botched so badly that France got Napoleon. That is fascinating choice of "worst thing to happen after French Revolution" thing. The regime after it was serious literal dictatorships, afaik there was no serious attempt for democracy.
- seanhunter 5y agoI think the division is merely into people who know about British history and people who don't. We had a civil war which ended when we chopped our king's head off and replaced the government. That has to count as a "revolutionary moment" or the phrase has no meaning.
- paganel 5y agoPlus, intellectually speaking movements like the Levellers and the Diggers were way ahead of their time, imho even the French Revolution didn't get to that level when it came to speech related to societal change, they had Babeuf but afaik he wasn't as mainstream, comparatively speaking. I think the radicalness of their speech was only matched on the Continent from the mid-19th century onward.
- timClicks 5y agoIt's worth looking into. That period is why the American military is constitutionally dependent on the legislature. If you will forgive me omitting many important details, Cromwell replaced a monarch and became a military dictator. Militaries and politics shouldn't mix.
- pjc50 5y agoNot really a popular revolution, more of an intra-elite conflict; not rooted in modern concepts of democracy, more in sectarianism; and it didn't "stick". The country reverted to a monarchy after his death. However, Parliament was then resolved to control the monarch - in particular to prevent the monarch ever being politically Catholic. Hence the uneasy toleration of Charles II (Catholic, but hedonist) and eviction of James II. Cromwell is regarded, not unreasonably, as a mass murderer in Ireland.
- ajuc 5y ago> Not really a popular revolution, more of an intra-elite conflict; that's almost always the case, at least at the beginning > Cromwell is regarded, not unreasonably, as a mass murderer in Ireland. most revolutionists are mass murderers
- tragomaskhalos 5y agoFrom a revolutionary perspective, the Diggers and the Levellers were the really interesting players to emerge from the civil war.
- Ericson2314 5y agoTo be clear, I mean "was it a revolution", not "was it a good one".
- duxup 5y agoThat was my thought too, but that era of English history is an absolute tar pit for my American brain. No matter how much I try to understand it I don’t and each time I try I find I start in the same place no matter how often I try.
- gerikson 5y agoThat's me (Swedish, but fluent English reader and interested in UK/European history) when it comes to the American Civil War...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kitd 5y agoSeems a reasonable question. One might say that Cromwell represented one power faction and Charles the other, so it was more a change at the top (albeit a popular one) than a grassroots uprising. It was also an early expression of the Enlightenment. That I think is the real revolution here and around Europe and the Americas around that time. One point of interest is that, after the restoration, many of the ousted Parliamentarians settled in America. To carry on the work as it were!
- billpg 5y agoKing Oliver Ⅰ of the House of Cromwell?
- dghf 5y agoIIRC, the Protectorate Parliament offered him the Crown, but factions of the Army made it clear he would not survive should he accept.
- hardlianotion 5y agoLord Protector. Not entirely clear to me how his power differed from that of a king.
- twblalock 5y agoHistorically the Peasant's Revolt, the civil war, and the Glorious Revolution of 1688 probably all count. So does the American Revolution, because the American colonies were part of Britain until they revolted and became independent. And what about the 1857 Indian mutiny, which replaced Company rule in India with direct government rule? In the 20th century, the collapse of the British empire involved revolutions in Malaya, Kenya, and arguably also in India to some extent (e.g. the Indian Navy mutiny). Consider that the British empire controlled about 25% of the population of the planet 100 years ago, and now the UK is a small country of ~67 million people. People who are looking for revolutions often need to look outside the physical geography of the British Isles to find them, but they are definitely there, they happened in parts of the world that were controlled by Britain and were considered part of Britain at the time, and they all had a huge impact on Britain.
- 369548684892826 5y ago> the American colonies were part of Britain This doesn't sound right because Britain is the name of the island. The American colonies were part of the British Empire I guess.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoTo be pedantic the country was called the Kingdom of Great Britain from 1707 to 1801. And the American colonies were part of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Great_Britain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Great_Britain
- twic 5y agoWere they? I thought they were separate entities under the same crown. The way that the Channel Islands and Isle of Man are not part of the UK today. They had their own legislatures, and their own bodies of law, separate from that made by Westminster.
- helsinkiandrew 5y ago
- thedailymail 5y agoThe Magna Carta was revolutionary for its time, putting limits on divine monarchy and making steps toward a rule of law, not men.
- fmajid 5y agoAnything but. It was all about the rights of the barons to oppress their fiefs without royal interference.
- ajuc 5y agoIn anglosaxon world for sure. Meanwhile in Scandinavia and Eastern Europe several countries had elective monarchies and self-government at local level :) I highly recommend this article to people who only ever read about history of political systems through anglosaxon POV: http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/poland-was-shockingly-liberal-in-the-1400s http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/poland-was-shockingly...
- jarl-ragnar 5y agoThere’s been a few. For example, the Barons’ revolt that resulted in Magna Carta in 1215 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta Or the Peasants’ Revolt of 1381 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants%27_Revolt https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peasants%27_Revolt in part arising out of the aftermath of the Black Death.
- donbox 5y agoIRA? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_War_of_Independence#:~:text=The%20Irish%20War%20of%20Independence,Irish%20Constabulary%20(RIC)%20and%20its https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_War_of_Independence#:~...
- angry_octet 5y agoIf you read this, you might enjoy Mike Duncan's Revolutions podcast: https://thehistoryofrome.typepad.com/revolutions_podcast/ https://thehistoryofrome.typepad.com/revolutions_podcast/
- known 5y ago
- nimchimpsky 5y ago
- dghf 5y agoOutside of Britain proper, but in what was then a British dependency, you had the United Irishmen revolt at the end of the eighteenth century, in which (as the name might suggest) Protestants and Catholics made common cause. That must have caused some alarm in London. It did inspire similar movements in Britain itself -- United Englishmen, United Scotsmen, United Britons -- but they don't seem to have amounted to much.
- jbverschoor 5y agoI think it's pretty revolutionary to state that god gave you the crown and that's why you're the king
- ljm 5y agoIt's interesting reading the comments here, most of which are of the kind, "well, it doesn't count because it was X or Y, or because this was already normal somewhere else in the world." And then a bunch of other comments which say, "well, if you include A and B then...yeah, it did." I mean, sure...Britain either did or didn't ever have a revolutionary moment, depending on how you change the definition and requirements of 'revolutionary'. In those terms, the conversation so far feels more like "Do I think Britain ever had a revolutionary moment?"
- pjc50 5y agoWell, yes, it's not an especially well defined term, and it's interesting to explore the boundaries of what does and does not count.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThe second closest in recent-ish times was the rioting after the Lords defeated the Second (Electoral) Reform Bill in 1831. Rioting broke out in a number of UK cities and rioters took over in a handful. But the British are essentially oppositional, not constructive, so after they'd done a bit of shouting and running around and setting fire to things they went home. Wellington watched it all unfold. Apparently couldn't believe his eyes when a mass of people who could easily have overthrown the government and started a French-style revolution gave up after some fairly token brick throwing. The closest was probably the General Strike in 1926 - nominally over coal supplies - which was much the same story but with almost no violence. Although in fact you could easily argue that Brexit was a kind of reactionary revolution, where a group of fascist intellectuals and journalists persuaded the more gullible elements of the population that leaving one of the world's biggest trading blocs would be entirely friction free and a glorious patriotic future would ensue - and not at all the entirely predictable economic and social disaster it has turned into.
- acjohnson55 5y ago(Half jokingly) Brexit?