4 ms·
> There is good enough metric for your 'work', its wealth generated at the end of it. In a company larger than a startup, this is usually outside the employees
by AlexandrB 15y ago
> There is good enough metric for your 'work', its wealth generated at the end of it.
In a company larger than a startup, this is usually outside the employees control. A project with a small (or no) market, isn't going to make a lot of money, even if it was a lot of work to create. The people assigned to work on such a project may not be there by choice. Also, what about "internal" projects that don't actually generate revenue, but make everyone more efficient?
- kamaal 15y agoThose projects generate wealth too! The point isn't that a productivity can't be measured, but there seems to be a lack of willingness to measure it. Its simple, if you actually start paying people by their work. You are at the same time putting a lot of other not-so-good-but-lucky people in serious trouble. People higher up in the hierarchy are especially very afraid of this. People who got quickly promoted during the gold rush, people who benefiting from job hopping by claiming 30% hikes on each hop every 9 months will be in serious trouble. In a place where all your work is transparent and your rewards are driven by it. A few productive people will run the asylum. The majority isn't going to be happy with this. People love getting rich by chance and not by choice and work.
- Woost 15y agoThis still doesn't deal with the problem of "what you work on isn't your choice" If I get assigned to, maybe, improve the front page by implementing a design from the graphic designer who gets paid more if the front page drives more signups? The graphic designer, for his/her awesome design? Me, for the time I spent implementing it? Both of us? What if it fails horribly? Do I take a hit (in the sense of not creating wealth/not getting paid more) because the graphic designer did a horrible job? Orders came down that said "Implement this" and I had no choice but to say "ok" (maybe I could argue the point, but at the end of the day it's not my decision)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- AlexandrB 15y agoDon't misunderstand, I'm not against measuring output - but you make it sound easy and it's not. In a small (< 20 people) company, you may be able to measure an individual's contribution to the bottom line, but in a company where an individual project may involve 30+ contributors, how do you evaluate who was most important to the projects success? I also fear that trying to measure output, like you suggest, would create perverse incentives. When everyone's pay depends on their contribution to the bottom line, it's in everyones interest to attribute as many accomplishments to themselves as possible (while downplaying any mistakes). In this kind of environment those who float to the top are not necessarily the best individuals, but the ones most skilled at self-promotion. This is no better than the current situation, really. Edit: In principle, if you could (in a non-political way) measure someone's contribution to the bottom line, this would be an ideal yardstick for setting compensation. But I think that the complexity of large projects and human nature makes this kind of measurement impossible.