4 ms·
> One thing I can't shake about the EV "revolution" is that it's going to require a massive expansion of our renewable energy capacity, like solar and wind, but
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> One thing I can't shake about the EV "revolution" is that it's going to require a massive expansion of our renewable energy capacity, like solar and wind, but we also need that renewable energy for other things, like household energy usage.
The big problem we have with renewables right now is matching generation with demand. Solar is really cheap for daytime generation, but what are you going to do at night?
Electric cars don't have that problem. They're parked for most of the day, they need to be charged once a day or less, so they can be charged whenever renewable generation is available. Which makes deployment of renewables more economical, which means we get more of it.
> If we were rational and serious about making the biggest impact, we would reduce car dependency so the green electricity we generate can go to less wasteful means.
We can do two things at once.
The biggest thing we can do to reduce vehicle miles traveled is to relax zoning near urban areas to allow higher density housing to be built closer to jobs. That works, it makes housing more affordable (which is independently good) and people waste less time commuting.
It also takes years before the new housing is actually built and even then doesn't solve the entire problem. You can't replace last mile truck deliveries with higher density housing or mass transit; you need electric trucks. Nobody is going to build low ridership mass transit to the low density suburbs that already exist, and they're not all going to cease to exist.
100% of cars are not going away anytime in the next century, but making the large majority of new cars electric is feasible within the next few years.
This is not a problem with a single solution. It's a problem with 100 solutions that each have a niche and you solve the problem best by deploying them all, each in the place where it makes the most sense.
- Matthias247 5y ago> Solar is really cheap for daytime generation, but what are you going to do at night? Theres batteries for that. And you can even use your EV as an a battery for your solar panels.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- manicdee 5y agoAssuming you are able to plug your EV into a (bidirectional) charger during the day.
- kybernetikos 5y ago> Electric cars don't have that problem. That's one of the things I'm concerned about - most people want to charge their EVs at night and drive them when there's solar power.
- gherkinnn 5y agoStick a battery in your garage.
- letitbeirie 5y agoThat’s expensive, especially on top of a new EV purchase and charger install. How do you avoid a tragedy of the commons without mandating batteries on every new charger installation?
- Retric 5y agoAn EV driving 15k miles per year only averages ~500w of electricity 24/7. The infrastructure is therefore relatively cheap. So at scale a 1GWh battery pack can charge ~100,000 cars at any time of the day. But, assuming PV adoption continues electricity prices will be lower in the day so most people will end up charging at the office.
- letitbeirie 5y agoTwo things: > averages They average 500W but that's a lot of 0W mixed in with a little bit of 10,000W. If everyone decides they want their 10,000W at the same time it's not going to work out. > a 1 GWh battery pack Some day soon. For now though that's about the total installed capacity for the entire USA [0]. [0] https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=40072 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=40072
- ulrikrasmussen 5y agoIf the workplace has chargers then a large number of cars can also be charged in the 9-5 time span when there is usually plenty of sun. Cars are idle most of the time, so we just have to make sure that they are plugged into the grid whenever they are not being driven, and then have intelligent charging systems that use EVs as sinks when there is a surplus.
- N1H1L 5y agoTrains are amazing for cutting out carbon from the delivery chain. You can even run double stack containers with overhead electrical traction (both China and India do it). Honestly using trucks to ship from a California port to Utah makes no sense - use trains and then transfer to trucks only for the absolute last mile
- zeristor 5y agoThere could be issues with capacity, but it would be good. Tesla trucks whilst nifty have issues, not least the huge road wear from heavy vehicles.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe whole "what about at night?!" line has been trotted incessantly out here, slashdot, hackaday, reddit, etc like people in the utility industry aren't aware. A huge amount of electrical load happens during the day that doesn't happen in the dead of the night, which is why many utilities offer nighttime cheaper rates. That hasn't stopped utilities from deploying wind and solar for 40% of their new generation over the last year or two, while shutting down coal plants left and right. For half a decade it's been considered settled fact that solar and wind are cheapest and the way forward. So, maybe this isn't as big a deal as you think it is. Attention long ago shifted toward planning the grid to accommodate that, and also on grid-scale storage projects. Pumped hydro has been used extensively in the UK for decades because every time the BBC finished a program, everyone watching TV would fire up their electric kettle at the same time. There are several pumped hydro installations in Canada and the US as well. Most EVs can schedule charging cycles and numerous utilities provide special rates for customers who agree to some level of utility control on their charging similar to how utilities provide discounts to people who let them tweak their AC thermostat; you can still override it, in most cases. In Australia, going back several decades, there was a grid load reduction signal system that worked by generating a harmonic that load reduction switches would look for. An increasing number of EVs are set up to be able to backfeed power into the grid, and the idea is that they could do so on request from the utility. Lots of utilities offer off-peak billing incentives. Imagine a world where your fridge does most of its cooling during the day, and "rides" through the night, etc. EV charging stations are starting to come with their own local battery systems because DC fast charging, particularly at 800V, is enough power that it can be difficult to get enough electrical service and in some locations the station sits unused for a fair period of time. Add in the fact that lithium ion battery prices continue to plunge following expected rules about production costs, as well as other technologies maturing; there's an iron salt based flow battery that looks really promising, made of very cheap and extremely prevalent materials (salt, iron, and water mostly) and scales fairly well.
- kspacewalk2 5y ago>That hasn't stopped utilities from deploying wind and solar for 40% of their new generation over the last year or two, while shutting down coal plants left and right. For half a decade it's been considered settled fact that solar and wind are cheapest and the way forward. So, maybe this isn't as big a deal as you think it is. Conspicuously absent in this incomplete story is the fact that so much of the coal has been replaced by natural gas, which doesn't have the giant unreliability downside of solar and wind. You can get away with >=~40% of your energy generated by solar/wind on every single day of the year with no interruption. Bump that up to 80% and it'll take a long time and a lot of money to accomplish that without sacrificing reliability. But why? Just use nuclear for the other half. The goal is not "renewable energy ASAP". The goal is "minimize fossil fuel usage ASAP".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]