4 ms·
For what it's worth, I do agree with Moxie that encryption is under-used and can make many kinds of semi-centralized infrastructure private. But that's irreleva
by mike_hearn 5y ago
For what it's worth, I do agree with Moxie that encryption is under-used and can make many kinds of semi-centralized infrastructure private. But that's irrelevant in this case. The focus is on WhatsApp because Moxie likes to use the speed with which it rolled out e2e encryption as the canonical example of why centralized services are better for privacy (this isn't the only place he's made this claim). But it's meaningless: something switched on quickly on a whim can also be switched off quickly on a whim. And, note, we found out that WhatsApp was newly encrypted because of a blog post and some messages in the UI. It could be switched off again silently and who would notice? We know the answer to this because hardly anyone realizes there are forwarding limits, even though it's in their FAQ. Apparently there aren't any groups reverse engineering every WhatsApp update to figure out if it's still encrypting everything.
With respect to the latter part, there might be a terminology issue here. I'm using "desktop" to mean any non-mobile/tablet/server device, including laptops or
stick PCs. A whole lot of people have such devices and in particular the sort of people who create content do. The idea that people only have mobile phones is false. There certainly are plenty of people who only have mobile phones and they matter, but there is also a huge population of people who have more powerful computers as well. And even for those who don't, a big part of why is not inability to have one but because they don't see any reason to buy one. That's not exactly fundamental.
Finally I would be very careful with predictions about technology trends. The computing industry has oscillated between big centralized computers and smaller more personal devices several times already. Even today the picture is quite ambiguous: as I argue in the article, a fully-bought-in Apple user is very much still a child of the PC revolution. Modern iPhones are as powerful hardware-wise as many PCs, just the form factor and usage model is different. The ecosystem there is very far from the canonical cloud-über-alles vision promoted by Google via the ChromeBooks.
- jpgvm 5y agoYour argument is pretty much that you can't/shouldn't trust WhatsApp/Signal and Moxie's argument is you don't need to if the cryptography is implemented correctly. It can't be just switched off, any update to the applications gets reversed within hours of release well before it's rolled out to a significant population of the users because exploits in both are quite prized. As someone else pointed out WhatsApp RCEs go for ~$1.5M USD, that is in a similar class to iMessage. Signals relay system is effectively untrusted at the protocol layer, this isn't much different from Bitcoin. The only real difference is the only people running it are the Signal folk. Is it an improvement to have a decentralized backend? Only arguably. From a user perspective it's actually often worse as fully decentralized peer-to-peer systems often perform worse and can't implement optimisations that are possible in centralised systems. From a purely "I can't trust anyone" perspective then no, but even Bitcoin and friends aren't that either. You trust the Bitcoin developers to not alter the protocol in a subtle way to weaken it just like you trust the Signal developers and server infrastructure not to subley subvert the cryptosystem. What I am saying is I think trusting the protocol developers of blockchain like systems isn't substantially different from trusting the Signal developers with the exception that it would be easier to fork a blockchain if you disagreed while spinning up your own Signal infrastructure would be quite a lot more work. As for powerful wall connected devices I do think you are being a bit facetious here. The vast majority of the population the mobile phone is their primary computing device. This is true across most of Asia, India and Africa. More modern developed countries have a wider proliferation of powerful consumer computing hardware but even there non-mobile computing is dwindling and while devices like iPad/tablets are becoming more popular they are prone to the same shortcomings of mobile devices (locked down OS, little/no background processing capability, unreliably connectivity). Also I wouldn't cling too quickly to the idea that Apple is selling you something drastically different from Google. If you look at their recent earnings reports they are now generating more and more of their profits as a precentage from their services business. They very much are attempting to follow the Google model, they just weren't as aggressive in the route they took. I don't actually see that as a problem though. If they can pursue a very cloud heavy model that is privacy preserving and protected by sufficient cryptography I don't see a problem. If however they keep going down the path of the device local CSAM scanning and the like... well I guess I won't be buying more Apple products. At the end of the day user experience is king. Everything else fades away under the weight of sheer amounts of money that comes from bowing to consumerism. If all this Web 3.0 stuff has a poor user experience vs what is being peddled by Google/Apple then don't expect it survive for that long.
- mike_hearn 5y agoI don't think it's safe to assume exploit vendors are concerned about end-user privacy. The point about decentralization is that merely noticing problems isn't good enough. Information propagation is hard! What are you going to do if a WhatsApp contact sends you a message saying the encryption was disabled? Forward the message, presumably ... ah. Audited builds aren't hugely useful unless there is teeth behind the audits, like the ability to block a change to the software that violates the social contract implemented by the encryption. If you don't have that then so what? With that level of control they are basically just saying "we aren't peeking right now, promise!" The reason it takes years to roll out end to end encryption in other protocols is not that centralization is inherently better or faster. It's that it takes a long time to build up a consensus around a new way of doing things and get people to take it seriously. That process isn't really optional though, if you skip it you get the WhatsApp problem where stuff is encrypted up until the moment a single executive decides it shouldn't be. If you can switch it on and off with the flick of a mouse then it's not actually making our society more robust against damaging behaviours by the adversaries, which is the ultimate point of implementing encryption in the first place.
- _tk_ 5y agoZerodium pays up to 1.5M$ for working exploits in i.e. WhatsApp [1]. Every widely used software, especially those used by millions and billions of users, is reverse engineered momentarily after every single patch by multiple groups. [1] https://zerodium.com/program.html https://zerodium.com/program.html
- md_ 5y ago> Apparently there aren't any groups reverse engineering every WhatsApp update to figure out if it's still encrypting everything. If that were true--in the case of WhatsApp, I'm pretty sure it's not, as another poster here pointed out--it would be equally true for any open source app. Like, I dunno, Debian (https://jblevins.org/log/ssh-vulnkey https://jblevins.org/log/ssh-vulnkey). There's absolutely a place for reproducible builds and binary transparency in the ecosystem. But those seem to me to be examples of what Moxie described: using cryptography to provide privacy and security guarantees while building on top of centralized infrastructure. Would you rather binary transparency, or would you rather run Sendmail on your Debian server in your closet because, hey, it's physically yours? The conclusion that the latter is better is just nonsensical. (And of course, Bitcoin Wallet is in the Play store, distributed in exactly the same way as Signal...)
- mike_hearn 5y agoYou can do both, they aren't exclusive. There's a class of problems you can't solve with cryptography. See the discussion up-thread about browsers. Would I rather have binary transparency or run my own mail server? Well, I might like an auditable Gmail but what I can actually get today is my own sendmail. So it's an academic point. Moreover, there's no particular reason running a mail server has to be as painful as it is. It's a PITA because nobody with usability skills has invested time to make it point-and-click, self maintaining etc (+ of course, finding a good reputation block of IPs). Nonetheless, if someone sat down and wanted to make messaging more decentralized today, making self-hosted email easier would actually be a tractable problem you could start on. Changing Facebook or Google policies, not so much. That has value even if it seems hard to imagine a great outcome today. Bitcoin Wallet is in the Play Store, can also be sideloaded, is open source, forkable, and connects directly to a P2P network. It doesn't rely on infrastructure run by the developers. It'd be even better if Android let you (or another app) audit installs but it's not a bad foundation.
- md_ 5y ago> Well, I might like an auditable Gmail Who proposed binary transparency for Gmail (the server)? The whole premise of tools like Signal is that enough happens in the client--which is amenable to binary transparency--that the server is immaterial. Sure, if you attack that strawman sufficiently, the only alternative is running your own Sendmail. And yes, it could suck less. My point was a bit bolder than that, though: not only does binary transparency (which, to be clear, is about client code, not the server itself) substantially mitigate the concerns you might have trusting a centralized service, but running a computing stack of millions of lines of code yourself does not at all mitigate those concerns. Sendmail isn't "yours", even if it's open source. It's a bunch of random patches from random people, some of which will erroneously "fix" a Valgrind error and remove cryptographic entropy from the RNG, others of which will contain intentional backdoors, etc, etc. The fact that you're running it yourself in your closet just doesn't matter. Physical locality--and hardware ownership--don't make a difference.