3 ms·
Most of this article is about the same solutions that are always proposed (wake me up when people actually use them and they actually solve the problem at hand.
by bawolff 5y ago
Most of this article is about the same solutions that are always proposed (wake me up when people actually use them and they actually solve the problem at hand.)
To me the most damning part of the article is:
> These critiques are usually unmoored to anything actually happening in the blockchain space, and unaware of the technological development and cultural vision. This bifurcation is extremely harmful for the health of the emerging technologies: these technologies are not going to go away, so if your only answer is dismissal and anger, you’re actually just ceding the power to decide what these technologies will look like in our world. This pattern of discourse creates a negative-sum feedback loop that does a disservice to all.
Quite frankly, if web3 really was all its cracked up to be, enthusiasists wouldn't be so offended anytime someone "didn't get it". After all, if it really was gold, they would be too busy making cool things and the results would speak for themselves.
As the author says, those who ignore something ceede power to those who show up. But why would the people who show up be so offended that people are giving them power? If it was actually valuable wouldn't they want it for themselves?
Every time someone criticizes cryptocurrency, its always the same refrain: people are wrong to be negative. All the bad vibes will turn your heart black, etc. That's what cults say, not what people with viable tech say.
- rezonant 5y ago> Every time someone criticizes cryptocurrency, its always the same refrain: people are wrong to be negative. All the bad vibes will turn your heart black, etc. That's what cults say, not what people with viable tech say. True. In reality the "bad vibes" are just folks trying to find a consensus on where this technology belongs- if you can't communicate the benefits of the tech in a convincing way, it's not everyone else's fault.
- mwattsun 5y ago"If something is too early to criticize it's also too early to evangelize" Kelsey Hightower @kelseyhightower, Jan 2, 2022
- telxosser 5y agoSpot on. Build Web3 and if it is great as you say it is I will use it. What else is there to discuss?
- nonbirithm 5y agoBecause even if web3 is a technological advancement and fulfills its stated purpose flawlessly, there are still negative externalities like the environmental cost. It's similar to building more data centers to house YouTube's "unlimited" storage for user-created videos. YouTube is one of the most successful platforms on the web with unprecedented societal impact, but will there ever be a time when we stop building more data centers, along with incrementing the total energy and environmental costs of running them all? And once a critical mass of people have adopted said technology, it becomes too easy for those in control to shift the blame onto the millions of functionally satisfied adopters when looking for solutions to the negative externalities that don't directly affect those adopters.
- kranke155 5y agoThe only major blockchains using proof of work and having considerable environmental impact at this point are Bitcoin and Ethereum. Bitcoin has stalled in development so I don’t think it will ever change, Ethereum has been talking about moving to extremely low energy Proof of Stake for years (hopefully will happen soon). Almost all the other major blockchains available - Polkadot, algorand, Tezos, NEAR, Solana, Cardano - are proof of stake, or similar extremely low energy consumption blockchains. The environmental criticism of blockchain is therefore going the way of the dodo. There are many valid criticisms of blockchain but the energy consumption criticism is about to be technologically outdated. It will age like milk. The only significant project using it is really Ethereum, and like I said, they have long promised to move on but have apparently gotten into a lot of technical trouble doing it, but they are still dead set on doing it.
- bawolff 5y ago> It will age like milk. Maybe. But right now PoW block chains have most of the marketshare. The environment concern is not a new one, maybe it will become spoiled milk one day, but so far it seems like the milk has had an incredibly long shelf life.