4 ms·
I’m excited to launch this product and the company behind it OK, so it's kind of an ad, although no product yet. He makes an interesting point. If you're going
by Animats 5y ago
I’m excited to launch this product and the company behind it OK, so it's kind of an ad, although no product yet.
He makes an interesting point. If you're going to have home servers so you own your data, they need to be in something you own and control that's always plugged into power. There's the router, but you usually don't own that. It belongs to the telco or the cable company. A "speaker", i.e. Alexa and friends? Amazon controls that. The TV? That's a slave to the TV maker, Google, or the cable company. The doorbell? That's run by Amazon and the cops. The refrigerator?
Apple used to sell a box, their "Time Capsule", which was a home server. But Apple discontinued that. Apple became so cloud-oriented that their thermostat has to contact an external server to get the outside temperature.
Most people now have no home electronics that isn't a slave to someone else. Where do you put a home server?
- keyme 5y agoYour phone? Double redundant networking, UPS protected power supply, and plenty of compute resources. Writing this from an android with 16G of RAM.
- severine 5y agoPotentially? Yes. In practice, not so much. Do you think we'll get there?
- firecall 5y ago> Apple became so cloud-oriented that their thermostat has to contact an external server to get the outside temperature. Did you mean Google with their Nest devices? Apple don't sell a thermostat. Although I wouldn't be surprised if HomeKit enabled devices needed to do what you described LOL :-)
- BHSPitMonkey 5y agoFor that matter, how is that even a criticism? A thermostat sits on your (interior) wall; If you want it to be aware of the outside temperature for any reason, you either provide additional equipment that consumers need to mount outside their building (in such a way as to get an accurate reading whilst being weatherproof and having reliable power/connectivity)... or you just fetch it from an API based on your postal code like a sane person would
- Animats 5y agoSorry, Google owns Nest.
- clktmr 5y agoThis is a cost of migration. I am totally fine with renting my server at AWS if I can move it to another provider at any time. The goal of decentralization is ownership of your data and services. Centralization only becomes a problem if there is no competition and a company has too much power.
- swalsh 5y agoFor me, the problem of Centralization was the gate keeping. It seems often when an API is used to migrate to a new system the API is turned off. Thats if there was an API at all. If the centralized service is an easily replaceable commodity... I'm not super concerned.
- Joeri 5y agoDon’t people here run raspberry pi’s for their home server needs? As for the general public, they have to trust someone to run their home servers for them, whether that is google, apple, amazon or their friendly neighborhood HN reader. Trusting a megacorp is not necessarily a bad move because while they do take abusive steps to further their bottom line, they are pretty good about security and software updates and as a customer you are unlikely to experience severe harm like having your bank accounts emptied because of the privileged access they have (well, except if you buy into the apple ecosystem, then the emptying of the accounts happens willingly).
- garrickvanburen 5y agoJust for pi-hole.
- threeseed 5y ago> Apple used to sell a box, their "Time Capsule", which was a home server. But Apple discontinued that Because no one is interesting in running their own server. > Apple became so cloud-oriented that their thermostat has to contact an external server to get the outside temperature Apple doesn't make a thermostat but they, along with many others, are moving to Matter. An interoperable, secure, private, open standard i.e. the very opposite of being cloud orientated.
- zimmerfrei 5y ago>> Apple doesn't make a thermostat but they, along with many others, are moving to Matter. An interoperable, secure, private, open standard i.e. the very opposite of being cloud orientated. Matter (formerly CHIP)? The protocol whose identity layer is allegedly based on a blockchain [0]? I think it needs the cloud, in the same way Moxie describes it. [0] https://staceyoniot.com/blockchain-101-how-distributed-trusted-data-can-boost-the-iot/ https://staceyoniot.com/blockchain-101-how-distributed-trust...
- tpetry 5y agoI have not read the specification of matter (which is a joint standard). But Apple‘s custom HomeKit protocol was designed to work without any cloud service by design. I use it without any cloud control, i won‘t be able to control my heater or light from on the go but because of WiFi without any central at my home.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Because no one is interesting in running their own server. "Home facing" servers and "network facing" servers are not the same thing at all. I'm not saying that implies a completely different attitude towards using them, but the differences are really important. If your social media identity lived on your own network-facing server, rather than FB/Twitter/Twitch/Discord/etc. servers, you may well feel differently about running it.
- swalsh 5y agoI'm not sure I buy the idea of "people just don't want servers in their homes". I think the people who have figured out how to do it, have captured the value. Some are hesitant to buy into that captured ecosystem. Many people who own 3D printers, plug them into a raspberry pi running something called "octo-pi". 3D printer people are more technical than most, but they're not allways coders and highly skilled IT people. Octo-pi's are open source, free as in beer, and free as in speech software. I know A LOT of people who go to pepole's houses, and say "hey that Alexa thing is cool, but why do you want Amazon to have a mic in your home". Lots of people see the value, many don't trust it.
- JimDabell 5y ago> Apple used to sell a box, their "Time Capsule", which was a home server. But Apple discontinued that. Apple became so cloud-oriented that their thermostat has to contact an external server to get the outside temperature. Time Capsule wasn’t a home server, just a NAS with integrated networking and backup. You couldn’t run software on it. There has never been an Apple thermostat. Are you confusing Apple with a different company? There’s nothing strange about a thermostat calling an API to get the outside temperature. Most thermostats aren’t physically able to measure the outside temperature themselves.