4 ms·
In high school debate, people can initiate arguments about the "rules" of the debate and argue that their opponent broke them in some way (like not staying with
by whimsicalism 5y ago
In high school debate, people can initiate arguments about the "rules" of the debate and argue that their opponent broke them in some way (like not staying within the topic) and thus should lose.
A big problem cropped up where this style of argument was essentially a "no-risk" proposition - because the issue was orthogonal to the actual content of the debate, teams could without risk argue that their opponent had broken the rules - if they convinced the judge, they won the debate, if they failed to, the debate just continued as usual.
Eventually, to deter the ever-growing proliferation of these objections, people started arguing that anyone who initiates one of these "rule violation accusations" should lose the debate if they fail to prove their claim. I'm wondering if a similar penalty could become commonplace (perhaps by default/presumption) in US courts.
- saagarjha 5y agoAh, high school debate. Are they still doing they thing where they throw bad arguments at you and then if you just refuse to engage with the stupid ones or don’t talk as fast as them claim they “win” because you didn’t address their points?
- whimsicalism 5y agoYes, the adage a "dropped argument is a true argument" remains true for many (but not all) forms of high school debate. That said, there is wiggle room in that an exceptionally stupid argument is not considered to need much response, but it should be touched on.
- Der_Einzige 5y agoThey do all of that, while speed reading their arguments at you! Btw, for former debaters, OP of this thread is talking about topicality, theory/framework (which makes the gamework!), and reverse voting issues (RVIs)
- danuker 5y agoI suspect the idea is to address stupid arguments by fixing the ignorance creating them. Communication is an easy way to improve. Still, it could be that the stupid arguments are malicious. In that case, perhaps one could prove it.