4 ms·
If John Deere is becoming a vertically integrated tech monopoly, the next step is for them to begin buying up the farms themselves. They'll have data as to whic
by echelon 5y ago
If John Deere is becoming a vertically integrated tech monopoly, the next step is for them to begin buying up the farms themselves. They'll have data as to which fields have the yields, best soils, best conditions, and are the most productive.
- chris_va 5y agoSeems unlikely. Not that it could not happen... there are various hedge funds that do this already, with mixed success. They generally lease back to a farmer. John Deere doesn't have any data that the farmer wouldn't have, and they certainly don't have better access to large sums of capital than hedge funds. I can seem them participating in a capital lease agreement for someone doing this sort of operation, but operating a farm is a very different proposition.
- Animats 5y agoJohn Deere doesn't have any data that the farmer wouldn't have. Sure they do. They have the data from all the farms that use their service. The farmer only has data from their own farm. Deere can tell who's doing better.
- bobthepanda 5y agoHaving data is not really sufficient to doing as well or better in a business though. As an example, Zillow had all that house price data, and then blew half a billion dollars because it thought it could use that data to start buying and selling houses itself.
- dane-pgp 5y agoThen, once it has a monopoly and doesn't need to add any new "features" to its products, it can just fire all its employees and replace the CEO with a DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization).
- radu_floricica 5y agoNah, they just package the knowledge and sell it for a nice profit. No point in doing anything else than what they already do very well. There are quite a few unknown unknowns when starting a side business, and little reason for them to do it (other than small pilot farms just to get a feel for how it works, to build better equipment)
- crackercrews 5y agoNo need to sell the intel. Keep it in house and make a killing in the commodities futures market.
- hkt 5y agoWould that be legal? Unsure if it counts as legitimate research or insider trading.
- kaydub 5y agoIs it possible to commit insider trading on commodities? I don't think it is.
- bluGill 5y agoYes. I work for John Deere ,but can't speak for the company. The tractor and combines are sending real time crop data, it isn't hard for someone to look at that data and see across all farmers that yields are a bit different from what the market is predicting and make a large profit trading on that insider knowledge. Those who work on that software and the admins of the database are registered with the SEC as not allowed to trade commodities. All that money they could make is directly out of our customers pockets and they wouldn't let us have that data if were were not protecting it.
- syedkarim 5y agoWhy not pay the farmers for that data (or share the resulting revenue) and sell the data feed to traders?