2 ms·
But different noises do different things and have different predictive powers. I think your statements about these systems being impossible to calculate are too
by godelski 5y ago
But different noises do different things and have different predictive powers. I think your statements about these systems being impossible to calculate are too strong. We use gaussian noise all the time. In fact there's plenty of machine learning models that use noise and change of variables (we learn the transforms) to represent different distributions. Ones that do actually have good clustering. We can be predictive in these domains. Chaos and randomness don't make inference impossible. This is the 21st century, we're not beholden to Newton nor to deterministic processes.
- avianlyric 5y agoI think we in perfect agreement here. Like I said in my comment, we can accurately describe the shape of noise, and that’s incredibly useful for making predictions. But we can’t make absolute deterministic predictions within the noise. I.e. we can say thing X has a 90% probability of happening. But we can’t say thing X will happen. And of course a strong probabilistic prediction is incredibly powerful and useful. I don’t want to suggest that it isn't, but it’s not an absolute prediction. And once again usefulness of a probabilistic prediction is almost always as useful as an absolute prediction (I would also argue that absolute prediction don’t really exist in the real world, they’re just extremely high confidence probabilistic predictions, but you haven’t bothered to model the actual noise).