3 ms·

You are missing the point completely. Someone who knows a lot about makeup and spends lots of skill and patience but in a completely different domain. Yea Linus

You are missing the point completely. Someone who knows a lot about makeup and spends lots of skill and patience but in a completely different domain. Yea Linus tech tips runs their own server because they happen to be in that domain. But that's not enough people to create a thriving ecosystem.

khimaros 5y ago
i don't think your parent was suggesting that youtube creators have the skills to run their own servers. i interpreted their post to mean that creating quality youtube content is a niche skill, similar to how running servers is a niche skill. i think they also were implying that, similar to the self-hosting demographic, a very small percentage of youtube users are high volume content creators.
- karmanyaahm 5y ago
  Yes, that's right and well worded.
intothemild 5y ago
I think I'm in a unique position here to reply to this. I run my own servers, and my wife is a professional makeup artist. The amount of time, energy, and effort she puts into just ONE single Instagram post is more than I put into any of my servers. It took both of us years of learning to do both these things we do, and honestly I get that you picked makeup as some kind of example because you think that makeup is easy or something. But it's not. Instagram, or YouTube takes a lot of skill, skills in recording video, camera, marketing, lighting, these aren't makeup skills, these are skills on top of makeup.. Then there's the outlay for recording and lighting equipment. Tripods to hold the camera, microphones for good audio. If you don't have these things your video will look like crap and people will click off it. Then there's the thumbnail! That's a whole thing on its own. YouTube or Instagram is just as labour and startup cost intensive as running a server. I'd even argue that servers are not as expensive. Have you seen how much money a good makeup kit costs? You can repurpose an old laptop or whatever as a server, or a raspberry pi... That's far cheaper than brushes for instance.
- giantrobot 5y ago
  > and honestly I get that you picked makeup as some kind of example because you think that makeup is easy or something. I think the parent picked makeup, not because they think it's easy, but it's a wildly different domain than system administration. Someone with a talent for makeup combined with a talent (or dogged determination) for creating mechanically good Instagram videos does not necessarily have a talent for system administration. Even some sort of makeup-Instagram-sysadmin polymath doesn't necessarily have the time to put into each of those topics to actually make a video people want to watch, serve it well enough that a majority of the population can watch it no matter their device, and even get people to their server to even view the content. At some point you must have noticed the credits at the end of a TV show or movie. More than one person is often involved in the production so each one can focus on a particular task or even subtasks. You know, division of labor. There's also the missing detail of no matter how good or a bad a makeup artist or Instagram video creator you are your makeup can't become a member of a malicious botnet or lock your home network down with ransomware if you do something wrong or leave it unattended for a weekend. The "run your own server" meme essentially requires everyone interested in content creation of any sort to be independently wealthy polymaths with no outside responsibilities.

khimaros 5y ago

i don't think your parent was suggesting that youtube creators have the skills to run their own servers. i interpreted their post to mean that creating quality youtube content is a niche skill, similar to how running servers is a niche skill. i think they also were implying that, similar to the self-hosting demographic, a very small percentage of youtube users are high volume content creators.

karmanyaahm 5y ago
Yes, that's right and well worded.

intothemild 5y ago

I think I'm in a unique position here to reply to this. I run my own servers, and my wife is a professional makeup artist. The amount of time, energy, and effort she puts into just ONE single Instagram post is more than I put into any of my servers. It took both of us years of learning to do both these things we do, and honestly I get that you picked makeup as some kind of example because you think that makeup is easy or something. But it's not. Instagram, or YouTube takes a lot of skill, skills in recording video, camera, marketing, lighting, these aren't makeup skills, these are skills on top of makeup.. Then there's the outlay for recording and lighting equipment. Tripods to hold the camera, microphones for good audio. If you don't have these things your video will look like crap and people will click off it. Then there's the thumbnail! That's a whole thing on its own. YouTube or Instagram is just as labour and startup cost intensive as running a server. I'd even argue that servers are not as expensive. Have you seen how much money a good makeup kit costs? You can repurpose an old laptop or whatever as a server, or a raspberry pi... That's far cheaper than brushes for instance.

giantrobot 5y ago
> and honestly I get that you picked makeup as some kind of example because you think that makeup is easy or something. I think the parent picked makeup, not because they think it's easy, but it's a wildly different domain than system administration. Someone with a talent for makeup combined with a talent (or dogged determination) for creating mechanically good Instagram videos does not necessarily have a talent for system administration. Even some sort of makeup-Instagram-sysadmin polymath doesn't necessarily have the time to put into each of those topics to actually make a video people want to watch, serve it well enough that a majority of the population can watch it no matter their device, and even get people to their server to even view the content. At some point you must have noticed the credits at the end of a TV show or movie. More than one person is often involved in the production so each one can focus on a particular task or even subtasks. You know, division of labor. There's also the missing detail of no matter how good or a bad a makeup artist or Instagram video creator you are your makeup can't become a member of a malicious botnet or lock your home network down with ransomware if you do something wrong or leave it unattended for a weekend. The "run your own server" meme essentially requires everyone interested in content creation of any sort to be independently wealthy polymaths with no outside responsibilities.