4 ms·
Why isn't there an enterprising law firm going through the credits of all the Star Wars (and similar-vintage films with ongoing commercial potential), contactin
by patio11 15y ago
Why isn't there an enterprising law firm going through the credits of all the Star Wars (and similar-vintage films with ongoing commercial potential), contacting every person on the list, and telling all the retired ones "There is a pot o' money with your name on it if you sign these papers which let us sue them for residuals on your behalf."?
I have to imagine that the legal strategy required there is a for loop with half-dozen templated documents: "Settle with $CLIENT regarding the residuals from the production of $FILM or in discovery we will subpoena all of $FILM's books and hand them to the forensic accounting department of $BIG_FIVE who will describe in vivid detail how they are an utter fiction, resulting in $DISTRICT_JUDGE issuing a judgement in excess of $GUESS against $YOUR_COMPANY."
- anamax 15y ago> Why isn't there an enterprising law firm going through the credits of all the Star Wars (and similar-vintage films with ongoing commercial potential), contacting every person on the list, and telling all the retired ones "There is a pot o' money with your name on it if you sign these papers which let us sue them for residuals on your behalf."? Because they'd lose.
- ZachPruckowski 15y agoLook at how hard it is to get traction on investigations into the current foreclosure/securitization boondoggle - it's taken 3 years for judges to actually start looking, the federal regulators are completely uninterested, and maybe 4 state AGs out of 50 have even started looking. And these are obvious and clearcut violations of pretty straightforward laws. Their reputations and legal teams have been a buffer against all sorts of suits and investigations. A Hollywood investigation would be worse politics, since you've have every TV station screaming about the government intrusion in investigating their parent companies. Look at things like the just failed Attorney General settlement with the banks - the worst case here is the company makes a one-time payment of a few pennies on every dollar of profit to some fund nominally targeted towards the victims. Then you throw in all the indemnification offered by corporate structuring and the fact that there probably aren't technical violations of the law here and good luck selling some accounting irregularities as a prosecution. Maybe in a few years that stuff will change, but right now the environment is such that nobody really buys the idea of government actually smacking someone with TR's Big Stick.
- ahlatimer 15y agoExcept that it isn't the government suing these companies, it's the people named in the credits.
- ZachPruckowski 15y agoRight (I blame 1AM posting for my error), but counting on $DISTRICT_JUDGE to bring down the hammer is equally over-optimistic. If one can barely get a judge to wade in on "a clearly fraudulent document was submitted to your court" when it undermines a foreclosure, I'm pessimistic about the idea that $GUESS is going to be show-stopping.
- philh 15y agoThe hope is that Hollywood would settle rather than take that risk. It's happened at least once before. Perhaps with higher stakes they would change strategies.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- elliottcarlson 15y agoI could easily see such an enterprising law firm becoming the type of patent trolling law firm that everyone here dispises. While this is an extreme case of someone not getting a dime when he clearly deserves it, I am sure there is enough book doctoring out there that simply going after $STUDIO/$FILM/$TVSHOW could become profitable if the threats are there and the fear of where the monies should be gets uncovered.
- anigbrowl 15y agoWhy isn't there an enterprising law firm going through the credits of all the Star Wars (and similar-vintage films with ongoing commercial potential), contacting every person on the list, and telling all the retired ones "There is a pot o' money with your name on it if you sign these papers which let us sue them for residuals on your behalf."? Because it's a violation of professional ethics to solicit clients in this way. That's one reason you occasionally see articles by lawyers explaining in copious detail why situation XYZ actually rests on a totally unstable legal foundation; they're hoping some interested party will notice the article and come to them.
- bane 15y agoweird, I get mail all the time from law firms..."you may already be owed this money!" or "we have records showing you purchased xyz lawnmower from abc, we have a class action suit blah blah if you simply sign and return this form you can join the class..."
- anigbrowl 15y agoAh, I see your point. But those notices are where a plaintiff has already filed suit, a class has already been certified, and a settlement offered. You are being notified as a possible party to the settlement of your right to accept the settlement terms or opt out and bring a lawsuit of your own. In keeping with the Star Wars example, suppose David Prowse sued on behalf of himself and all other costume-actors in Return of the Jedi - by 'costume actors' I mean people who appear on the screen but don't speak any lines. Darth Vader's lines are all spoken by James Earl Jones because David Prowse has a goofy accent that's not appropriate to the character; the Screen Actor's Guild mandates quite different royalty payments for actors who talk as against actors who merely appear. If a court agrees that 'costumed actors' constitutes a viable class of identifiable persons who are similarly situated (they probably would; they're listed in the credits, and many actors appear without having any lines to speak) then it may certify a class on the basis that it's more reasonable to wrap multiple plaintiff's claims into a single suit. A lot would depend on whether the court considered the suit to have any merit, which would require looking at industry employment agreements of the time. I don't know much about labor law so I couldn't tell you how likely that is. My gut feeling is 'not very' because these compensation practices are widespread. Anyway, say Prowse does a good enough case that he either wins, or Lucasfilm fears that defending the case will cost more than paying out and offers a settlement. Then everyone who played an Ewok/Stormtrooper/whatever but didn't have any lines will get a letter advising about rights arising from a class action. Basically, if you are ever invited to appear in a big-budget film or TV show you need to remember three things: do you have a line (otherwise it's low-paid day labor with free lunch and some celebrity-spotting fun), SAG minimum (get hired in accordance with the Screen Actor's Guild deal, or Actor's Equity on a TV program), Taft-Hartley (in case the producer says you need to already be a member of the actor's union). If you have a line and come under an industry agreement, you get a residual payment every time the film/tv show/commercial is rebroadcast. This can add up to a tidy sum if you are lucky enough to work on something that becomes a hit. If you get hired as an extra, you can try talking during the scene you're in to get a speaking credit, but you'd better add enough value to the scene that the director is willing to stick up for you when a producer objects. That's the basic difference between acting and just having a particular look. David Prowse can't act, sad to say; he's what people in the industry call a 'movable prop.'