4 ms·
I don’t know about teens, but something that annoys me as an adult about non-iPhone users is that I can’t be sure that they’re seeing what I’m seeing when I sen
by jiggawatts 5y ago
I don’t know about teens, but something that annoys me as an adult about non-iPhone users is that I can’t be sure that they’re seeing what I’m seeing when I send them a photo.
If I take a photo of a sunset in my iPhone and send it to another iPhone user, I can be assured that:
- The colours will be correct
- The high dynamic range will be preserved
- Live photos will work.
Etc…
With Android users, all bets are off. The colours will be shifted or wrong. HDR will generally not work.
(The same thing applies to Microsoft Windows users. If I email them something, chances are that it’ll be mangled in some way.)
Google, like Microsoft, just doesn’t care about quality or interoperability, and consumers like me notice.
- mixedCase 5y agoDoes this happen with Signal or Element? If not, you could ask your Android contacts to use a cross-platform messenger such as those, like the rest of the world does with WhatsApp.
- godelski 5y agoThis is the number one method for how I got my friends to contact me on Signal. No more potato videos and images. Can still do group video calls, reactions, everything that iMessage offers except it's cross platform.
- meowkit 5y ago> Google, like Microsoft, just doesn’t care about quality or interoperability, and consumers like me notice. Just to be clear, Google and Microsoft care very much about interop. That's why quality and ecosystem coherence are generally lower than Apple.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI mean, I agree with problem while vehemently disagreeing with proposed cause. It somehow puts blame on "others" for interoperability, whereas my personal perception is that Apple said "&@#& screw interoperability - we will make sure things work right in our own ecosystem only, through closed proprietary systems, and who cares about anybody not using our hardware". Live photos not working on other phones is not THEIR fault for goodness sake. It's a proprietary iPhone gimmick Apple have spent zero effort in trying to work anywhere else. Same for portrait photo etc. Apple is intentionally building a walled garden of proprietary stuff that purposefully doesn't work outside. From charger to text to photos to everything else, they see their future in blazing their own path as opposed to compatibility. I too am frustrated in my iPhone photos being a pain anywhere outside, but seeing as my android Nikon canon windows Linux google adobe Microsoft etc systems all seem to talk happily with each other, I know exactly where to scream in rage at. - Sent from my iPhone, fwiw Edit: not that you're alone mind you. Apple's marketing machine and prestige identity works brilliantly - Most iPhone users I know feel that's everybody else's fault, which only makes the brand loyalty firmer - it's a perpetually self enforcing perception.
- jiggawatts 5y agoThere was a great article on here yesterday that hits the nail on the head: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29845208 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29845208 Distributed standards inherently become ossified and are unable to innovate. The path of least resistance is to centralise and gain control, which allows fast iteration and innovation. Fundamentally, as a user I don't care about Google's or Microsoft's excuses. They're some of the biggest companies in the world. They've largely centralised their systems (G Suite, Office 365, Teams, etc...), yet have failed to capitalise on this centralisation, unlike Apple. I mean, we're talking about a trivial thing here: sending pictures! Yet only Apple gets this even remotely "right". Every other company is perfectly content with sending potato quality images, randomly mangling colours, etc... I just installed Windows 11 on a brand-new, high-end laptop with an OLED HDR screen. It's a shit-show. - HDR is off by default. I paid thousands for this feature, but let's just keep that disabled... for reasons? - HEVC is unavailable by default, so apps like NetFlix silently downgrade to 1080p & SDR. - HEIF support is available, but also off by default. - The Dolby Vision Extension is available, but cannot be found via the App Store search(!). You have to find an external link to it, and use that to navigate to the hidden storage page to download it. - Windows 10 used to have 10-bit SDR with wide gamut support. That has been removed. You can only have a colour-managed desktop by default in HDR mode. - HDR mode is forcibly disabled if you're running on battery. So you unplug your laptop and the colours shift. I could go on and on. And on. And on. You can't blame "standards" for this. Microsoft and Google are just too lazy to do things right, to have things "just work". With Apple, I can send another person a Dolby Vision 4K 60fps HDR video in a text message and it will work. With a much more powerful Windows 10 computer I can't. It won't play, and even if it does, it'll probably stutter like mad because an 8-core 5 GHz laptop struggles with something my phone can handle smoothly.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> Distributed standards inherently become ossified and are unable to innovate. I don't think it's as simple as that. When websites were proudly stating that they were "best viewed in Internet Explorer", there was very little innovation in the web platform, but then when Mozilla/Firefox and Chrome became popular, distributed innovation improved. Things are a little more complicated now that Chrome has a dominant market share, but I'd argue that it is actually Safari (and Apple's monopoly control over it on the iPhone) that is most holding back the web now.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Google, like Microsoft, just doesn’t care about quality or interoperability, and consumers like me notice. It's absurd to blame Google or Microsoft for this. If anything Google is the one pushing for an interoperable alternative to iMessage. When you send a photo using iMessage to an Android user, it's delivered over MMS. The technological restrictions of MMS are what's at fault here.
- godelski 5y agoThis is the reason I've converted a lot of my friends to Signal. We can share high quality images, reactions, everything that iMessage has. I only wish Signal would have an air drop like feature to transfer raw files in an anonymous manner without the need for internet.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RedBeetDeadpool 5y agoYes, but Apple could make their iMessage features available to non IOS products if their goal was to create a non-discriminatory messaging platform. They've had many many years to do this. Its simply not part of their plan. Their plan amongst other things involves this little cheap tactic of utilizing social engineering to draw users into their platform, when it doesn't have to.
- discardedrefuse 5y agoIt seems like you (and a whole lot of people in this thread) don't understand how iMessage and texting works. Let me take a stab at this: To text with non-Apple phones, iMessage uses SMS over the cellular network. This is pre-smartphone technology. A few years ago, SMS was upgraded to RCS (still over the cell network though). Lots of features were added. But Apple refuses to update their old SMS implementation in iMessage. Now on the other hand, to text with other iMessage users, iMessage uses Apple's own proprietary iMessage protocols over the IP network (the internet); Just like Telegram and WhatsApp does. Apple refuses to bring iMessage to other devices and doesn't let other messengers implement it's proprietary iMessage protocols. I hope you realize, the reason you have a substandard experience communicating with Android users is because Apple wants you to.
- jiggawatts 5y ago> still over the cell network though That's the rub. Why would Apple allow text messages to be once again controlled by both telcos and governments, including interception? > doesn't let other messengers implement it's proprietary iMessage protocols. I can't find an open standards document anywhere on the Internet for RCS. Can you? From what I'm reading, it's a mish-mash of random proprietary "standards" that were each an extension written by one or more telcos or corporations. The current "standard" probably isn't one in any meaningful way, and I would be money that it's full of security flaws due to the heterogeneous design.
- discardedrefuse 5y ago> That's the rub. Why would Apple allow text messages to be once again controlled by both telcos and governments, including interception? SMS text messaging ONLY works over the carrier's cell network, never IP. Its a hold-over from another time. It should've had died when phones became internet connected. But it didn't, and now we've tied MFA to it... so its here to stay. > I can't find an open standards document anywhere on the Internet for RCS. Can you? I haven't looked into RCS in a long time. But I do remember it wasn't great. The reason its such a mish-mash of carrier "standards" is because that is exactly what SMS is. When text messaging first came out, you could not message someone on a different carrier. Eventually carriers bridged their messaging networks, but it was always a hot mess (especially when it came to MMS).
- postalrat 5y agoI've seen some terrible colors from iphones with iphone users stating the colors are correct. Apple has trained you to see through their colored glasses.