4 ms·
A corollary to the Gibson quote is "The past is still here - it's just not evenly distributed". I can't help but think of this any time I see talk of "antivirus
by mindslight 5y ago
A corollary to the Gibson quote is "The past is still here - it's just not evenly distributed". I can't help but think of this any time I see talk of "antivirus software" in 2022 (among other things).
If you're reading this article and thinking that antivirus software is a sensible thing to be running and thus wondering how they could betray users, you need to seriously revamp your computing environment. For most tasks that you need a trustable environment for, you want a modern OS that isn't based around agglomerating random binaries from arbitrary sources, whether that's something Free or just proprietary+curated+isolated (eg Apple/Android). And sure you can still keep MS Windows around for whatever purposes, but since it's no longer handling your sensitive activities you don't have to be hyperactive about the Sisyphean task of "securing" it.
- pjmlp 5y agoIndeed every Linux user does a code review before pressing return on curl xpto | sh, or mypkg install.
- mindslight 5y agoYes of course you can transplant bad ideas over to Linux or anywhere else (another example: flashing your phone with rando "ROMs" from xda-developers). If you're doing these type of things then what I said applies to you as well, and you should obtain another device where you don't do such things for your trustable environment. But even if you are doing such things, you still won't be liable to add to your problems with "antivirus" software. That's a particular idea arising out of the longstanding binary potluck culture of DOS/Windows.
- pjmlp 5y agoInteresting argument, > It looks like you’re running macOS, Linux, or another Unix-like OS. To download Rustup and install Rust, run the following in your terminal, then follow the on-screen instructions. See "Other Installation Methods" if you are on Windows. > curl --proto '=https' --tlsv1.2 -sSf https://sh.rustup.rs https://sh.rustup.rs | sh
- mindslight 5y agoIt is terrible that this garbage has taken over the "open source" community - "just pipe this web page into your all-powerful command shell. Don't worry it's 'secure' because it uses HTTPS.". Even in the best case, it splays unreproducible junk all throughout your filesystem. Of course that doesn't matter because your Linux machine is a temporary "cattle" that you're just renting and accessing from your shiny iChromebook amirite? Not having looked at it in a while, it is highly disappointing that Rust specifically has gone down this path on their main fucking page. "Old man yells at cloud", and all that. IMO I think the future is distributed reproducible builds through Guix/Nix. I've never run Gentoo, but Guix/Nix feel like the best manifestation of software freedom that I've experienced. Mind expanding in the same way as functional programming or Lisp. And of course none of that addresses the whole issue of source auditing and provenance. Immutable logs like git get us 90% of a foundation, but obviously there is a lot of unexplored territory required to provide actual security guarantees.
- ttybird2 5y agoNix eh? https://nixos.org/download.html#nix-quick-install https://nixos.org/download.html#nix-quick-install curl -L https://nixos.org/nix/install https://nixos.org/nix/install | sh Unlike guix nix does not even have a way to verify package signatures because "it would hurt the workflow of these using the github webui to push stuff to nixpkgs"
- mindslight 5y agoThat's what I get for trying to be constructive. The cancer is everywhere. The real rebuttal is just because a project's page tells you to do stupid things, does not mean you should do them (of course advocating that crap at all makes one question their general security competence) I agree Guix has a much better story on foundational security (cf guix challenge). Nix seems to have more activity. Unfortunately, cancer spreads because it's good at multiplication. But really my greater point is they're both source distributions revolving around persistent package/system management, which allow one to obtain software while managing the provenance of its code.
- nix23 5y agoNo problem every Antivirus software makes that code review anyway...just install windows defender on you *nix machine...problem solved.
- unionpivo 5y agoI personally would not and I do not put any sensitive information on my phone. I know that many people disagree, and live their entire life on there, but for the same reason most hackers and governments and various "scurity" companies are gathering and hoarding exploits for them. Sticking to good old desktop almost makes you invisible now days.