3 ms·
So far I've read barely one article that mentions web3 and manages to describe the fundamental concepts and problems. Instead, most people writing about this se
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
So far I've read barely one article that mentions web3 and manages to describe the fundamental concepts and problems. Instead, most people writing about this seem to assume that the "problems" web3 is supposed to fix are completely self-evident, and then everyone who is in favor of the current "vision" of web3 simply assume that blockchain is the correct technological answer.
It doesn't seem that hard to state relatively quickly and simply:
Current ways of handling data online generally result in large centralized databases under the control of relatively or extremely large corporations, which gives these corporations too much control over (a) what data is accessible (b) what can be done with the data (c) the lifetime of the data.
Sensible folks generally acknowledge that this either is a problem, or is likely to become one.
So the central issue is: how do we have data available online without it under the control of corporations that run centralized databases?
----
In response to this, cryptocurrency advocates point to blockchain technology and say, in essence, "look! there's an example of a technology that does exactly that"
However, for this to be the best solution to the problem requires a few things to be true that are either untrue or not known (yet) to be true.
* was blockchain designed to handle arbitrary data blobs, or was it designed to handle transaction records?
* does pretending that any arbitrary data blob can be treated as a transaction record help or hinder solutions?
* are there other ways to distribute data storage and access that don't depend on the fundamental technologies/concepts inherent in blockchains?
----
Why anyone feels they can be certain that the answers all indicate that blockchain is the obviously correct technology to use for distributed trusted data storage and access totally escapes me.
- jollybean 5y agoFully agree that these articles often fail to put things in a broader context. But I'll take it a step further than 'Blockchain is not the answer' and indicate that Web3 itself probably isn't an answer to that much in the first place. "this either is a problem, or is likely to become one." Web 1/2 approaches have tremendous advantages. As the original article stated - people don't want to run servers. People don't want to manage confusing things. We want everything mostly SaaS. Some of those push a bit too far, like Apple locking you out of your Mac - but this is probably best dealt with with legislation. The privacy and control benefits of self hosting are limited to mostly niche use cases, and of course, blockchains have problems, as you mention. Web 2 is just a few bits of legislation, a few rational consumer choices, and a few fewer crappy companies away from being fairly ideal. Don't use iCloud, avoid Google for anything other than search, don't 'depend' on Facebook or Twitter and already you're doing well. Dialogue and experiments are great, but NFT/Crypto so far is just a lot of MLM noise.