3 ms·
Why consider it intimate data? Fear it will cause spousal resentment, impact future offers, being targeted by gold diggers or grifters? Wealth tied to identity
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
Why consider it intimate data?
Fear it will cause spousal resentment, impact future offers, being targeted by gold diggers or grifters? Wealth tied to identity?
- ramphastidae 5y agoDid you read the comment you are replying to? The answer to your question is literally the entire content of the comment.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoMaybe I'm just dense but it wasn't clear the motivation for keeping the info secret. It seems implied that fear of spousal conflict was involved.
- ramphastidae 5y agoI see. Sorry for my snark. My understanding was that they feel money has a deeply corrupting influence on relationships, and credits the strength of their parents marriage with the fact that they both made a clear effort to avoid taking about money (while still being responsible with it). I don’t think that they are saying that making tax returns public will directly cause more spousal conflict, but it will cause more general corruption of relationships across the board. I can certainly see that. In my experience, there are very few people who respond appropriately when they learn what someone makes. Rarely is it: “oh, good for them, anyway, moving on …” Most of the time, it’s unhelpful and toxic commentary about whether the person is overpaid/spoiled/poor with money/a sucker or whatever depending on their circumstances. I wish it wasn’t that way but that has been my experience.
- tagoregrtst 5y agoTo summarize my comment, because something as mundane as money is more likely to enter (and therefore effect) into my relationships with others when we know how much we make. Its hard to be friends with someone who you know makes twice (or half) what you make. But there are many people who I think are cool and would want to have a relationship with that make a lot more/less than I. Thats also a reason why modesty in our behavior is important - the wealthier person in a relationship shouldn't keep proposing things that are financially difficult for the other
- secabeen 5y agoThat has not been my experience. As a state employee in California, my salary is a matter of public record and has been for years. I have no idea who has looked up my salary, so I don't know what impact it's had on my friendships, etc.
- sanatgersappa 5y agoIt can give extortionists / kidnappers a nice list of potential targets.