3 ms·
The scoop: by tonnage, 40% of what is transported by sea is oil, coal, and LNG. By switching to local sources of energy (renewables mostly), humanity can serio
by nine_k 5y ago
The scoop: by tonnage, 40% of what is transported by sea is oil, coal, and LNG.
By switching to local sources of energy (renewables mostly), humanity can seriously lower the impact of ships on the oceans, and stop burning as much fuel to move them, too.
I'd like to add that all these fuels are very energy-dense. Producing as much energy locally would not be an easy or inexpensive enterprise.
- epistasis 5y agoAlready, solar is the cheapest source of energy, and is still in the exponentially decreasing phase of the tech curve.
- nine_k 5y agoBatteries need to shape up, though. Huge battery installations should become cheap and ubiquitous; so far they are neither. A number of interesting chemistries exist that would suit well the needs of stationary batteries, which can be heavy and bulky, but need to be cheap and safe. As usual, more time and money are needed :)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoNote that if batteries stayed at their current level of development forever, wind and solar would still be the best choice to build out at large scales today. It is unlikely that they wont progress dramatically, but even in that extreme case there's no need or reason to wait.
- criley2 5y agoThis is sadly wishful thinking. The unreliability of solar and wind plus the state of modern batteries means that nuclear and coal are still better choices for large scale baseload generation. One factor people don't consider is reliability of power. Since solar and wind are unreliable (example, German wind power saw -25% generation last year due to weather, and ended up increasing coal by as much as 40 to 50% to make up for it plus meet new demand) you end up needing to produce significantly more to have a guarantee of baseload. For every bit of ultra-reliable, ultra-safe, tiny-footprint nuclear you build out, you need ~4X the amount of less reliable and giant foot print solar or wind.
- _ph_ 5y agoUltra-reliable nuclear power, like in France where a couple of reactors had to be shut down due to safety issues detected? Yes, wind and solar are limited in their available capacity by the weather. The trick to get reliable power generation nonetheless are wide range networks (mitigates weather influences), storage solutions and storable renewables like bio-gas. For the gap, gas powered plans are the key. Even in the worst case, they are way more environment friendly than coal, only emit a fraction of the CO2 at the same output. But beyond that, they can be quickly switched in output, they are the ideal counterpart to wind and solar. That is the weakness of coal and especially nuclear power plants. Also, one can afford a lot of overproduction capacity for the cost of a new nuclear power plant.
- himinlomax 5y ago> Ultra-reliable nuclear power, like in France where a couple of reactors had to be shut down due to safety issues detected? A perfectly fine plant, Fessenheim, was shut down recently due to antinuke luddites.
- _ph_ 5y agoNo, an unreliable old plant with severe safety concerns was shut down not very recently. Currently 16 French nuclear plants are not operating due to maintenance. About 4 of those went offline very recently (as in November or December) because severe issues were detected which needed to be addressed at once.
- cedilla 5y agoHow are the people who want to build modern energy plants the luddites? If anything it's the people who insist to keep ancient technology on life support that had failed all its promises by the late 1970s who are luddites.
- ryan93 5y ago
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago
- CraigJPerry 5y agoIn the uk I’m currently not allowed to buy a cheap old nissan leaf car with a worn old 22kwh battery pack (that’s basically useless for transport now, something like 30 mile range in perfect conditions) and connect it to supply my house. I can buy electricity from the grid at 5p/kwh between 12pm and 5am and if i was allowed to charge that car and then draw my daily 10kwh of house usage from it instead of paying 20p/kwh during the day. I’d be happy to give some percentage to the grid but it’s just not allowed by most DNO’s here right now. Wallbox.com has a £10k bi durectional wallbox (quantum) that can be deployed in a few very select areas in the UK currently. My best option right now is a couple of £2.5k battery packs from givenergy but my supplier won’t switch me to the ev tarrif without proof i own an EV. Also the givenergy route is the same price as the old leaf but for half the capacity.
- mattbee 5y agoWhat kind of inverter could you use to connect an old traction battery to supply your house? (I have a Leaf and solar backed by a 4.5kWh battery so... for the future I suppose)
- CraigJPerry 5y agoThere’s a 7kw inverter in the wallbox https://wallbox.com/en_catalog/quasar-dc-charger https://wallbox.com/en_catalog/quasar-dc-charger - turns out i got the name wrong, it’s quasar not quantum :-)
- mattbee 5y agoHow cool, I didn't know that was possible. So CHAdeMO lets EVs discharge as well as charge? I assumed you were talking about a hack. So why can't that particular inverter be connected to your home? I have _two_ separate solar inverters connected to mine already!
- CraigJPerry 5y agoIt’s in use in Japan as i understand it but in the UK the DNOs currently don’t have appropriate controls in place for when the power goes out as i understand it. I believe people with solar and batteries on their property have no power when there’s a power cut - their inverter turns off for safety of the DNO operatives if mains power goes out. Im not that clued up on this. Tent with a big pinch of salt…!
- sundvor 5y agoThe quickest way to force/ assist adaptation of new tech is to stop complaining about it, start buying it when/if possible, watch how demand drives innovation for the years to come - yet be happy to have gotten in at a certain point which helps both yourselves and everyone. Solar panels for one have come a very long way in the last decade. The same will apply to batteries. How retired EV packs can be reused for home storage is but one field of opportunity I feel is exciting.
- epistasis 5y agoBatteries have shaped up, actually! Retail costs are about $300/kWh for at least 7000 cycles, which is only $4.2/kWh (plus inverter/BMS, plus electrician costs, plus sales markup, etc.). There has been a 10x decline in lithium ion battery costs in just 10 years, which is shocking. Check out this slide from Ramez Naam, of which batteries are only one component of the massive ongoing transition: https://t.co/2WnIrtuLpN https://t.co/2WnIrtuLpN Lithium ion batteries are getting deployed in large GW and GWh sizes all over, and in smaller sizes too. Worldwide production capacity is expected to grow by 10x every five years. I think other stationary battery chemistries will catch up for "longer-term" storage, where the charge rate is lower and the capital cost is lower, and they can't cycle as fast. My favorite are the iron air batteries, which are rumored to be as low as $20/kWh, but with a power/energy ratio of only 1%.
- hnaccount_rng 5y agoHow do you get from 300$/kWh to 4.2$/kWh?
- epistasis 5y ago7000 cycles out of $300/capacity, so $300 kWh capacity / 7000 cycles == $0.042 per kWh cycle.
- hnaccount_rng 5y agoSo the 4.2$ is just a typo and should have been 0.042$. Then I follow you, thanks
- epistasis 5y agoOops, yes, thanks so much!
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoDid you intentionally say "not be an easy or inexpensive" enterprise? That feels carefully crafted to suggest it would be harder or more expensive than getting the same energy with fossil fuels (which isn't true) while carefully avoiding actually saying that untrue thing.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe statement is not sufficiently defined to be true or untrue in all cases. Energy is not just energy. It has to have certain characteristics and parameters in which it can be utilized. In some instances, fossil fuels will be able to be displaced by local sources easily. In others, it will not.
- Fronzie 5y agoThe production cost of green energy is below that of fossil fuels already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:20201019_Levelized_Cost_of_Energy_(LCOE,_Lazard)_-_renewable_energy.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:20201019_Levelized_Cost_o... Taking overcapacity for wind free periods and energy storage into account, the numbers are less favorable, but transitioning to green energy doesn't really need to affect our wealth or lifestyle all that much.
- empedocles 5y agoI would not be so certain that this would reduce the number of ships, rather lower costs for shipping further as they try and find new cargo.
- tuatoru 5y agoOil tankers, LNG carriers, and coal transporters are specialized to their cargoes. I doubt that there are alternative types of cargo for any of them. Certainly not in the same quantities. Transporting water, for instance, is not economic beyond a few thousand km. For all the breathless talk (above) about how the cost of renewable energy and batteries are plummeting, it is still not clear how cargo ships will be powered sans fossil fuels, or what that will cost. Time and the market will tell, I suppose.