4 ms·
> Illegal images being sent to your wallet, forcing you to go to prison in some places. My god, I hadn't even considered that, but they're right, there's curre
by jeroenhd 5y ago
> Illegal images being sent to your wallet, forcing you to go to prison in some places.
My god, I hadn't even considered that, but they're right, there's currently n established blockchain the requires permission to send anything. That's fine with money, but with NFTs that actually represent something that could be a serious risk.
- neuroma 5y agoI forget the name but there was an NFT set that was dropped straight to wallets. It was various pixilated dicks. Kinda funny and cute I suppose. They had rarity traits etc.
- Joeri 5y agoSomeone can send you illegal material through the regular snail mail and call the cops as soon as the mail is delivered. Is this really that different?
- jeroenhd 5y agoI don't have to pay ethereum gas to hand the proof over to the police or to burn it if they don't care. The mail system also doesn't keep a public, permanent record of all things mailed to me that any political opponents might use to imply things. There are also countries where you don't want to let the police know you own crypto because of laws against alternative currencies. Real world comparisons don't really work well with public blockchains.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoWell, if you don't have a wallet then you can't receive it, and if you have a wallet, you're suspect anyway ?
- berkut 5y agoI personally wouldn't want to put possible key disclosure laws to the test in this situation. With post mail I'd imagine that scenario is somewhat timing-critical, whereas I'm not sure how feasible it is to delete things if they are in the blockchain (consensus for deletion? How does that work?) and the police seize all the computers in your house.
- samatman 5y agoThat's the point of this sort of (hypothetical?) attack: poor Bob now has a poison envelope on his private key, he has something which roughly constitutes 'ownership' of illegal bits. Does our legal structure support immediately transferring it to a null wallet as a disclaimer of ownership? Bob doesn't want to be the one to make that case law. Nor does he want to hand over his private key, or clean his wallet out of everything but the evil image and then hand over his private key. Basically there are no good options, although burning the offending data by sending it to /dev/null should emerge as a valid defense. Will it?
- jakear 5y ago"I swear officer, the only proof I have of ever being sent those images is this folder filled with infinitely detailed top-down photographs of each one of them lying face-up in my trash can""
- samatman 5y agoA tidy summary of the issue, that. But hey, if it was a Bored Cryptokitty, then Bob can't sell it and no one can buy it anymore, so clearly, he doesn't own it. The same principle should apply to evil bits, the real kicker being that the whole rigamarole is now written to a shared database whose, er, immutability is part of the product on offer. Man, the Twenties are gonna be lit.
- jakear 5y agoThe NFT principle only applies when content consumers value maintaining a chain of ownership to content authors. In cases where a clear chain of provenance is more of a liability than an asset, it's probably more desirable to forge a new copy for resale and shred the original. I suspect this is perhaps a part of why OpenSea maintains a lens over all wallet content requests... the impact of a mass mailing of evil bits to wallets would be devastating to the platform, perhaps to the entire crypto ecosystem. Any corporation who wants to be seen as legitimate must have the capability to keep evil bits out of users eyes.
- srqwe 5y agoWhere do you live that you can be arrested for someone sending you illegal material you didn't request?!
- jeroenhd 5y agoPossession if child porn is illegal in many countries. If digital wallets convey any kind of ownership (which anyone using cryptocurrency or NFTs would argue in favour of) then that implies receiving child porn makes you be in possession of illegal material. I'm no lawyer, but I'm pretty sure not reporting such content to the police immediately would be a crime, and even if you do the right thing the police might still suspect you if you're unlucky. Someone malicious could definitely send a collection of child porn through the mail and report you the second it arrives. If they can time it right, you could definitely be in trouble and the police would likely take all of your digital storage and search for more. It's a lot harder to do such things anonymously in the real world, where security cameras and physical mail boxes are a thing, but I wouldn't be surprised if someone would actually pull off something awful like this. Of course, the police probably won't arrest you if you immediately report the illegal contents and hand over the evidence (or destroy the evidence without involving the police), but that's not as easy with the blockchain. Transferring the NFT out of your account would likely involve paying some kind of transfer fee (ethereum gas is quite expensive) and the police aren't going to pay that for you. You won't be finding or suing the sender of the child porn either, because this stuff isn't hard to do anonymously. Even if you do manage to transfer the illegal content out of your wallet, the blockchain will forever keep a public record of the content you once owned, so even if you do everything right the accusation of paedophilia will forever be easy to make.
- meltedcapacitor 5y agoIs it fine with money? A ransomware operator could send the loot from an operation, channelled through a well publicized address, to someone they don't like which makes their account undistinguishable from that of a fence as seen by blockchain analytics firms maintaining the blacklists of addresses legit players do not task to. Or they could blackmail someone by threatening to burn their account by sending tainted funds. Politicians could be sent unwanted donations to dirty their reputation by making it looked they're supported by the wrong people. ...
- jeroenhd 5y agoYou can already do that though the regular old banking system, no difference there. Banks monitor and take action when they detect money laundering systems in their transfers, and they use graph analysis that's not dissimilar from the analysis law enforcement uses for tracking anonymous wallets. The mixers in the cryptocurrency world exist as school kids acting as fencers in the real world. A crime ring could definitely "taint" a politician's bank account if they wish to do so, but the manual oversight of the banking system probably wouldn't flag them. It's not that this isn't a problem with cryptocurrencies, it's just that it's a problem that already exists in the real world.
- meltedcapacitor 5y agoSure. The difference is it's harder to manage in crypto (by design).
- kamranjon 5y agoI realize that it is said to be prohibitively expensive to store an image on-chain - but if an actual illegal image was stored on-chain would that be irreversible? Basically I’m wondering if making the entire ledger illegal to posses is as simple as ponying up the cost? Could that bring down an entire crypto currency? Sorry if this sounds naive, I am just not sure what is currently possible.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoIt has already happened, and nobody cared. Very early on, the bitcoin blockchain ended up playing host to some illegal images, but nobody took down bitcoin or bitcoin nodes for storing them.
- jeroenhd 5y agoIt would be practically impossible, the only way you can remove something from the blockchain is to ask all nodes to revert to an earlier version and purge the offending blocks and any blocks related to them. This is also why using public blockchains for storing personal information is such a stupid idea, illegal even if the GDPR is involved in any way. Blockchains are designed so no information can be altered or redacted, and that's often an overlooked problem.