3 ms·
As usual in biochemistry, it is the dose that makes the poison. But also mode of consumption. We are indeed well adapted to consuming fruit. Even though modern
by inglor_cz 5y ago
As usual in biochemistry, it is the dose that makes the poison. But also mode of consumption.
We are indeed well adapted to consuming fruit. Even though modern fruit is bred to be much more sugary than its natural predecessors (ever tried eating a wild apple from a tree on a hike? Insanely sour), there does not seem to be any kind of health problem associated with consumption of raw fruit. We have a lot of metabolically sick people around the world - over a billion probably - but few of them, if any, have gotten to that point by eating too much fruit.
Fructose is not fruit, though. Even very sweet fruit like mango has only 16 per cent of fructose per weight. Fructose itself is 100 per cent, it is refined, concentrated stuff, from which all fiber has been removed.
Fiber that naturally occurs in fruit and veg slows down processing of fruit and veg in the digestive system - it takes fairly long (hours) to extract all the fructose from an eaten piece of fruit. As a result, the liver isn't overworked - it receives manageable quantity of fructose over a long period.
Now compare a situation when you drink a litre of sweetened beverage. That is a lot of fructose - you just drank an equivalent of seven? eight? apples in half an hour or so. And all that sugar comes in liquid form, so it enters your blood very fast, producing a huge spike. The liver is overwhelmed. It can cope somehow, but do this ten thousand times and some negative outcomes are bound to follow.
There is a scientist (Robert H. Lustig, professor of endocrinology at UCSF) who, more than a decade ago, published a long video called "Sugar: The Bitter Truth". It is stuffed with various biochemical observations and longish, but I found the information useful.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- hsn915 5y agoOk but this does not only apply to fructose. It applies equally well to glucose and fat/oil. Anything in excess can had dire consequences, including a lot of vitamins and minerals. Even water in excess can be bad for you. When the messaging is centered around "carbs are bad" or "fructose is bad" it will lead people to believe that fruits are bad for you. I've seen several health channels on youtube recommend not eating more than the equivalent of one apple per day in terms of fruits.
- inglor_cz 5y agoGlucose can be processed by every single cell in human body. I don't think you can eat or even drink so much glucose that you overwhelm the capabilities of the entire body to cope with it. You will vomit sooner than that. While people can and do consume excessive amounts of fat/oil, we are somewhat protected by the fact that fat has a very strong satiating effect, which makes it a little harder to completely pig out. Fructose has no satiating effect at all. Generally, yes, anything in excess has dire consequences, but in some things those consequences manifest sooner than in others. Sweetened beverages as consumed today are very much a definition of excess: big packaging, a lot of sugar within, and their mass consumption is societally normalized.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y ago> Glucose can be processed by every single cell in human body. That processing hinges on a healthy insulin response to keep blood sugar levels in check. Which for a large part of the population is probably not the case. Again with a suitable amount of fibres to go with that glucose intake, the load can be levelled somewhat though.